Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Is "At which age did you start coding?” a good data point for hiring?

news.ycombinator.com

61–70 of 90 posts

Re: Ask HN: Is "At which age did you start coding?” a good data point for hiring?

#61
No. For one, this doesn't say anything about someone's ability. There are people who "started coding" at 5 and cannot made CRUD applications at 30.

I had never used a computer in my life (except for a brief interaction with a TANDY) until I was 18, and I still went on to have a relatively good career as a Linux sysadmin.

Re: Ask HN: Is "At which age did you start coding?” a good data point for hiring?

#63
post #34

I guess I can offer a data point here. I started programming in C at around age 12. For a long period after that, I didn't know much about software engineering, I was writing really poor quality code, but I was tinkering with programming for years. Then I started learning it seriously in my late 20s and got to a senior role in a large tech company within about 3 years. It was easy for me to learn a lot quickly as I w…

[deleted]

Re: Ask HN: Is "At which age did you start coding?” a good data point for hiring?

#64

I am strongly against this question. You're basically looking at who's parents provided an opportunity for them to learn coding early. I'm sure you would find that most people who started programming at a young age (and are still doing it obviously) are probably better than average and also enthusiastic. However, I think it is still a disservice to anyone who didn't have support as a child. For the record I was learn…

This pretty heavily assumes that you can't learn programming by paper or on a shared school computer (quite widely available in the UK/US for a couple of decades now), which itself reveals a bias in your mindset here, tbh.

Re: Ask HN: Is "At which age did you start coding?” a good data point for hiring?

#65

This question, in an interview, seems to be likely to be illegal in many jurisdictions.

How? Years of experience is very standard question

"Years of experience" is age discrimination in a single phrase.

Sure, ask about competency and capability, but not years of experience.

By asking about age you started programming, you may be discriminating against parental income levels, family situation, schooling, gender and all sorts of other things.

Re: Ask HN: Is "At which age did you start coding?” a good data point for hiring?

#66

I am strongly against this question. You're basically looking at who's parents provided an opportunity for them to learn coding early. I'm sure you would find that most people who started programming at a young age (and are still doing it obviously) are probably better than average and also enthusiastic. However, I think it is still a disservice to anyone who didn't have support as a child. For the record I was learn…

that's true for old people, but almost anyone have access to the internet/computers today, so for younger generations the questions isn't did you have access/support, but did you prefer playing minecraft/fortnite/watching youtube or learning to code?

Re: Ask HN: Is "At which age did you start coding?” a good data point for hiring?

#67
A lot of people will say something really early, but then that age means copying and pasting from a tutorial and then not revisiting until they're adults.

If starting early actually did help them become better programmers, then it will be apparent from their current skill level and the accomplishments on their resume. Just focus on looking at that.

Re: Ask HN: Is "At which age did you start coding?” a good data point for hiring?

#68

I am strongly against this question. You're basically looking at who's parents provided an opportunity for them to learn coding early. I'm sure you would find that most people who started programming at a young age (and are still doing it obviously) are probably better than average and also enthusiastic. However, I think it is still a disservice to anyone who didn't have support as a child. For the record I was learn…

that's true for old people, but almost anyone have access to the internet/computers today, so for younger generations the questions isn't did you have access/support, but did you prefer playing minecraft/fortnite/watching youtube or learning to code?

Did you eat cookies and sweets all day or you ignored those and ate the normal meal as a kid provided you always had access to both?

There is no kid who choose hard learning over low hanging dopamine fruits these days. If they do the opposite they are either backed by parents or REALLY strange.

Re: Ask HN: Is "At which age did you start coding?” a good data point for hiring?

#69
post #9

Would you ask a doctor at what age they started surgery? It's irrelevant. You might as well ask about the wealth of the candidate's parents, which is significant factor in whether a child has access to a desktop computer on which they can do serious coding.

Most kids had computers at home when I was a kid in the 90s/00s but they had more powerful computers than I did so they would just play games. I couldn't even play Counter Strike on mine so I learned to program instead.

Re: Ask HN: Is "At which age did you start coding?” a good data point for hiring?

#70

I am strongly against this question. You're basically looking at who's parents provided an opportunity for them to learn coding early. I'm sure you would find that most people who started programming at a young age (and are still doing it obviously) are probably better than average and also enthusiastic. However, I think it is still a disservice to anyone who didn't have support as a child. For the record I was learn…

that's true for old people, but almost anyone have access to the internet/computers today, so for younger generations the questions isn't did you have access/support, but did you prefer playing minecraft/fortnite/watching youtube or learning to code?

I wouldn’t have a career in computer science if I didn’t take an early college computer science course my senior year of high school. I had no idea about the world of programming the same way the a classroom setting would gave me and my high school was so poor it didn’t have AP classes to introduce me earlier.

I’m in my early 20s. it’s absolutely about access/support.

Post reply on HN