Earlier quoted context omitted.
> Second, there is a small chance you're absolutely right, and you've just obviated a whole field from first principles. Mostly when I read about things like this happening, it's happening to a formerly intractable problem in mathematics. Do you have examples outside of math?
Alfred Wegener as the initial author on the theory of plate tectonics comes to mind. He was a trained meteorologist who observed the similarities between geological formations between the South American east coast and African west coast. He was lucky, in that his father in-law was a prominent geologist and helped him defend this thesis.
Oh yeah, revolutionary insights are very important for the advancement of knowledge and the elimination of wrong ideas. But as you wrote, this was the work of a thesis, not a random commenter from another field.