Live data from Hacker News

West Coast Trail – The 75km/48 mile hike in Vancouver Island (2021)

dquach.com

31–40 of 79 posts

Re: West Coast Trail – The 75km/48 mile hike in Vancouver Island (2021)

#31
post #10

6 days for 75km? I suppose this guy must've really been enjoying himself along the way. Don't think you need to precook stuff like quinoa. Can just cook it on an ethanol hobo oven pretty quick.

As somebody who’s hiked the length of the Pacific Crest Trail, I can say the West Coast Trail is very different from a walking trail. Basically a km feels like a mile on that trail. Everything is slippery, and steep. It wasn’t designed as a hiking trail it was an escape route for shipwrecks.

Re: West Coast Trail – The 75km/48 mile hike in Vancouver Island (2021)

#33

I was just about to comment about my dear of bumping into a grizzly bear while hiking there, but apparently “only” black bears live on Vancouver Island. That would still keep me away and I always wonder if I’m just way too cautious or if the likelihood of running into a bear is so low that it’s worth it?

They're pretty docile. Think of them as very big raccoons, not small grizzlies. The primary thing that brings the bravest black bears into close contact with humans is their love of untended food, but they're skittish and will scamper the moment someone hollers at them.

Personally, I worry more about cougars and wolves.

Re: West Coast Trail – The 75km/48 mile hike in Vancouver Island (2021)

#34
post #10

6 days for 75km? I suppose this guy must've really been enjoying himself along the way. Don't think you need to precook stuff like quinoa. Can just cook it on an ethanol hobo oven pretty quick.

A lot of people have attempted this trail with your attitude and got absolutely wrecked by the physical demands and environment. It’s much harder than scenic photos of the island would lead you to expect. It’s also hard to understand how serious and unrelenting the mud and rain can be if you haven’t experienced west coast downpours before.

Re: West Coast Trail – The 75km/48 mile hike in Vancouver Island (2021)

#35
post #10

6 days for 75km? I suppose this guy must've really been enjoying himself along the way. Don't think you need to precook stuff like quinoa. Can just cook it on an ethanol hobo oven pretty quick.

The 75km is a rough estimate. There are so many twists and turns, and logs to hop over, giant boulders to climb on top, plus there’s ~100 ladders over the whole train, some in better shape than others. Your actual traveled distance is closer to 90km.

5-6 days is a reasonable amount if you are not insane. The second time I did it, there was a couple that ran it in two days. Only saw them at the start, but presumably they made. The reason they did 2 days is because you can pay to rent a tent + food about half way through. So they were running with just a two litter bottle of water and presumably some snacks.

But if you want to actually enjoy the views … even 7 days is not too slow

Re: West Coast Trail – The 75km/48 mile hike in Vancouver Island (2021)

#36

When I did this trail long ago I got to meet Monique (since passed) who ran a very tasty burger joint at the mid point. She had quite the operation going with a sizable garden and food boated in regularly. Exchange students ran much of the kitchen. I must admit, I had not been prepared to find myself arguing over esoteric details of Python with her. Monique was a very interesting person who was still going to school…

Years ago I volunteered at Monique's for 3 weeks with my brother. It was a great and interesting time and I met a lot of cool people in Monique and her family and other hikers and volunteers. We used to sleep in a shack in the back and their red cat named Mess would sleep on my face. One scene I will always remember is eating porridge for breakfast and watching for whales in the bay. What a wonderful place!

Re: West Coast Trail – The 75km/48 mile hike in Vancouver Island (2021)

#37
A few random reactions:

> You would think sleeping by the beach is relaxing, but really that is far from the case. I didn’t sleep that well as the ocean was thundering in the middle of the night.

I agree sleeping on the beach is nowhere near as pleasant as it sounds. I remember one night I set up camp near the shore, and kept waking up throughout the night to the sound of lapping waves in a panic that the tide was rising and would inundate my tent... except on this occasion I was camped next to a lake!

> You would be surprised but there are so many debates in the hiking community. This debate is to bring hiking poles or not.

I definitely recommend using hiking poles. They are lightweight and easy to stow when not in use (many backpacking packs will have dedicated loops/straps for them). They have saved me from falling on numerous occasions when I have lost my footing on a slippery trail, and they also help to redistribute weight off of your legs which helps tremendously with fatigue on long hikes with heavy packs. I avoided hiking poles for many years because I thought they looked dorky, but eventually gave them a try when I was suffering from knee pain on descents - and have used them on just about every hike since. For me they making hiking so much more enjoyable.

> For the thru-hike there were two options, south to north or north to south. We opted to go south to north as it starts off super difficult, then slowly gets easier.

I can't comment on this trail specifically as I have never done it, but it might make more sense to start with the easy part and end with the difficult part. Reason being your pack will be lighter by the end of the trip, and also after a couple days I tend to settle into a rythm whereas the start of a trip can be a bit of a shock. On other trails where I have the choice I tend to prefer ascending on the steeper route and descending on the gentler route.

Re: West Coast Trail – The 75km/48 mile hike in Vancouver Island (2021)

#38

Good write up, and I'm impressed by his preparations for a first-time backpacker - especially his food dehydration. Most people, especially newbies, will just buy prepackaged meals. Although I had to laugh at his "green sand"[1] — beach glass? [1]: https://static-images-cdn.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/blog-21...

The author is a first-time thru-hiker, not first-time backpacker.

"I have done a lot of hiking, and cool trips, but never thru-hiking." and "upgrading all of my gear" indicate previous experience backpacking.

The line "I remember buying cascade hiking poles from Costco, and it breaking in the middle of hiking of Peru" may been an event which occurred after this hike, but a search of the site finds https://www.dquach.com/2023/04/05/personal-newsletter-2023-q... with "Back in 2015 we were eating at Astrid y Gaston in Lima, Peru ... I was going to hike the W, which was a 5 day hike in Patagonia Chile about 4 days later", further confirming previous backpacking experience.

Re: West Coast Trail – The 75km/48 mile hike in Vancouver Island (2021)

#39

Good write up, and I'm impressed by his preparations for a first-time backpacker - especially his food dehydration. Most people, especially newbies, will just buy prepackaged meals. Although I had to laugh at his "green sand"[1] — beach glass? [1]: https://static-images-cdn.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/blog-21...

My kids had a blast when we were in the Azores last summer digging through the volcanic sand beach for these green, orange, and red stones. They aren't found near the beach where we live, and we took a few larger ones back home.

This green specimen is Olivine, which is indeed quite common, but not ubiquitously everywhere.

Re: West Coast Trail – The 75km/48 mile hike in Vancouver Island (2021)

#40

A few random reactions: > You would think sleeping by the beach is relaxing, but really that is far from the case. I didn’t sleep that well as the ocean was thundering in the middle of the night. I agree sleeping on the beach is nowhere near as pleasant as it sounds. I remember one night I set up camp near the shore, and kept waking up throughout the night to the sound of lapping waves in a panic that the tide was ri…

We do "family" hiking (3 kids, 9 to 15) with up to 110km through the mountains with maximum 20 km and about 1000m up and 1000m down on a "hard" day.

I fully agree with you:

- start slow to get the body to find itself (and keep 2 days at the end of the hike to book a nice hotel with a pool for the kids).

- hiking poles are a must. It also saves the hike if you have ankle/knee pain as you can put the weight on your arms to release the pressure from the bad leg. Our kids prefer walking without.

Post reply on HN