Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: TxtNet Browser – Browse the Web over SMS, No Wi-Fi/Mobile Data Needed

github.com

31–40 of 76 posts

Re: Show HN: TxtNet Browser – Browse the Web over SMS, No Wi-Fi/Mobile Data Needed

#31

Maybe it is a shame that WAP usage died off as you could probably get the essential information from a site with very few bytes. Combined with something like this it would be great for getting stuff done.

I feel a WAP resurgence will be inevitable once we are all in space ;-)

Re: Show HN: TxtNet Browser – Browse the Web over SMS, No Wi-Fi/Mobile Data Needed

#33

Would be super super useful over WhatsApp. Is it possible? There are some cases where only WhatsApp is available as free WiFi...

Like this?

https://alexanderell.is/posts/wikipedia-over-whatsapp/

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31463249

I'm sure I've seen what you're describing done before to make use of free WhatsApp in mobile plans in some countries, just can't find it, although I remember that one of the limitations found was rate limiting by WhatsApp, which is to be expected.

Re: Show HN: TxtNet Browser – Browse the Web over SMS, No Wi-Fi/Mobile Data Needed

#34
Those in countries with a low median income and prohibitively expensive data plans

I suspect SMS is likely to also be "prohibitively expensive" in those situations.

That said, although this is another good tunnel, I wonder if literal "dial-up" going through the (far more likely to be available on a mobile phone) voice channel will provide better bandwidth.

Re: Show HN: TxtNet Browser – Browse the Web over SMS, No Wi-Fi/Mobile Data Needed

#35

Would be super super useful over WhatsApp. Is it possible? There are some cases where only WhatsApp is available as free WiFi...

or DNS port ? i remember some captive portal would block all traffic except dns request until you login.

Re: Show HN: TxtNet Browser – Browse the Web over SMS, No Wi-Fi/Mobile Data Needed

#36
post #20

Isn't SMS a more expensive transport usually? Wherever I've seen paid and limited SMS, they were ridiculously expensive for the amount of data transferred (e.g. in Indonesia). Do you have a specific "target market" in mind, with cheap / unlimited SMS but censored internet access? E.g. China, Russia, Turkey?

SMS messages in Russia are expensive by default. Most carriers offer cheap-ish unlimited SMS packages but I've no idea who they're for. Or how unlimited they really are.

As far as censorship goes, a VPN is better by all metrics than this.

Re: Show HN: TxtNet Browser – Browse the Web over SMS, No Wi-Fi/Mobile Data Needed

#39
post #38

Could be usefull for places where government have shutdown internet for weeks https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/other-states/sambalpu...

My thoughts exactly - other places like Iran have also experienced deliberate government internet blackouts recently. Thanks for sharing.

Re: Show HN: TxtNet Browser – Browse the Web over SMS, No Wi-Fi/Mobile Data Needed

#40

Those in countries with a low median income and prohibitively expensive data plans I suspect SMS is likely to also be "prohibitively expensive" in those situations. That said, although this is another good tunnel, I wonder if literal "dial-up" going through the (far more likely to be available on a mobile phone) voice channel will provide better bandwidth.

For most cases, I imagine you are correct. There are probably only a few edge cases where this does work out financially. I've explored using the voice channel as an option, but that would require hardware to re-route call audio to the app since no API is available without root.
Post reply on HN