Live data from Hacker News

There are no fees at America’s smallest bank

bloomberg.com

21–30 of 100 posts

Re: There are no fees at America’s smallest bank

#21

How many mortgages can they service with 3M in assets? Seems like they'd be very limited in that regard.

From the article:

There are currently only 40 or so mortgages outstanding, and as customers pass away, the stock is not being replenished with loans to younger generations, who have no particular affinity for in-person banking.

Re: There are no fees at America’s smallest bank

#22
post #8

With an aversion to technology, i really wonder how this bank supports electronic transfers like ATM, ACH, wires etc. Is there a core banking system running?

> Is there a core banking system running?

The Minimum Viable Bank System is a paper ledger, paper Know Your Customer records, and cash in a locked container. You don't have to support electronic transfers or even paper checks. Just let people withdraw and deposit in-person at the only physical office.

Re: There are no fees at America’s smallest bank

#23

I have bank accounts in 3 different countries and none of them have any fees either. What they have thought is redundant documentation of my funds that guarantee I won't be SoL when the building burns down with the paper ledger in it like this bank here. I really don't understand this fascination or even admiration for outdated ways.

The old-school way to document savings accounts is with a passbook:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Passbook

If this bank offers that, then you have the redundant documentation yourself.

Re: There are no fees at America’s smallest bank

#24

How many mortgages can they service with 3M in assets? Seems like they'd be very limited in that regard.

From the article: There are currently only 40 or so mortgages outstanding, and as customers pass away, the stock is not being replenished with loans to younger generations, who have no particular affinity for in-person banking.

The realest form of attrition...

Re: There are no fees at America’s smallest bank

#25
How viable is a bank, which offers exactly:

* No physical bank branch. Only online banking

* a current account with a monthly fee

* a debit card that can be used at other banks' ATM - monthly fee.

* Debit card can't be directly used online. But you can generate merchant specific card numbers on the website.

Say, your monthly fee is $20. Then 4000 customers brings in a million dollars an year. How much is spent on fraud by a bank every year?

Could a single person with a few part-time contractors run a bank of this nature?

Re: There are no fees at America’s smallest bank

#26

This may be America's smallest bank, but there are smaller credit unions! From what I can tell, Holy Trinity Baptist Federal Credit Union is the smallest, operating since 1966 with about $16k in deposits according to their EOY 2022 financial report: https://ncuso.org/credit-union/17269/financials/

Here’s an interesting article about church-based credit unions. It looks like they exist to offer better options to underbanked populations and are often limited to church members: https://religionnews.com/2018/10/30/church-run-credit-unions...

Re: There are no fees at America’s smallest bank

#27

How viable is a bank, which offers exactly: * No physical bank branch. Only online banking * a current account with a monthly fee * a debit card that can be used at other banks' ATM - monthly fee. * Debit card can't be directly used online. But you can generate merchant specific card numbers on the website. Say, your monthly fee is $20. Then 4000 customers brings in a million dollars an year. How much is spent on fra…

This is kind of how I'm set up. I use Ally for their checking and savings and privacy for their merchant specific card numbers. It works reasonably well for me.

It would be cool to have a real FDIC insured, licensed bank with this built in some how. I'd be willing to pay $25/mo for something that is first-party.

Re: There are no fees at America’s smallest bank

#28

I have bank accounts in 3 different countries and none of them have any fees either. What they have thought is redundant documentation of my funds that guarantee I won't be SoL when the building burns down with the paper ledger in it like this bank here. I really don't understand this fascination or even admiration for outdated ways.

> I have bank accounts in 3 different countries

How is this even possible? Do you have citizenship in all three countries?

Re: There are no fees at America’s smallest bank

#29

How viable is a bank, which offers exactly: * No physical bank branch. Only online banking * a current account with a monthly fee * a debit card that can be used at other banks' ATM - monthly fee. * Debit card can't be directly used online. But you can generate merchant specific card numbers on the website. Say, your monthly fee is $20. Then 4000 customers brings in a million dollars an year. How much is spent on fra…

This is kind of how I'm set up. I use Ally for their checking and savings and privacy for their merchant specific card numbers. It works reasonably well for me. It would be cool to have a real FDIC insured, licensed bank with this built in some how. I'd be willing to pay $25/mo for something that is first-party.

Relay (Thread Bank) offers generating virtual cards.

Re: There are no fees at America’s smallest bank

#30

How viable is a bank, which offers exactly: * No physical bank branch. Only online banking * a current account with a monthly fee * a debit card that can be used at other banks' ATM - monthly fee. * Debit card can't be directly used online. But you can generate merchant specific card numbers on the website. Say, your monthly fee is $20. Then 4000 customers brings in a million dollars an year. How much is spent on fra…

These sound like direct banks. In Germany, there are a few of those, ING being the largest, and represent about 50% of the private market. Pretty viable therefore.
Post reply on HN