Live data from Hacker News

New Arkansas bill to keep minors off social media exempts most social platforms

theverge.com

31–40 of 132 posts

Re: New Arkansas bill to keep minors off social media exempts most social platforms

#31

Is there a formal name to describe incumbents pushing for regulations in order to keep out new competitors? Something more specific than just “anti-competitive, monopolistic,” etc. This seems like such a common tactic that I’d expect there to be academic studies about it.

Typically, that’s what almost all regulations actually do. Just pull the ladder up farther out of reach.

It’s the reason companies lobby for them.

Re: New Arkansas bill to keep minors off social media exempts most social platforms

#32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They also exempt social media companies with less than 100 million gross revenue

So which ones does it apply to in the end?

Well, from the article, if you make a mildly successful multiplayer game, you better allow players to share tick-tock style videos too, or it will apply to you.

But I have no idea if the article representation of it is correct (that would be a first), and no interest on reading the original.

Re: New Arkansas bill to keep minors off social media exempts most social platforms

#33
I think people may be overlooking a bigger story here:

https://www.arkleg.state.ar.us/Bills/FTPDocument?path=%2FBil...

  Reasonable age verification methods under subdivision (c)(1)
  of this section include providing:
  (A) A digitized identification card, including a digital
      copy of a driver's license under § 27-16-601 et seq.;
  (B) Government-issued identification; or
  (C) Any commercially reasonable age verification method.

  "Digitized identification card" means a data file available
  on a mobile device that has connectivity to the internet through a state
  approved application that allows the mobile device to download the data file
  from the Office of Driver Services that contains all of the data elements
  visible on the face and back of a driver's license or identification card and
  displays the current status of the driver's license or identification card,
  including valid, expired, cancelled, suspended, revoked, active, or inactive;

Re: New Arkansas bill to keep minors off social media exempts most social platforms

#35

kinda makes sense, it's addressing a very specific problem that mostly arises around instagram and tiktok.

But strangely TikTok seems exempt? Or maybe they rely on federal lawmakers to can it from the US altogether?

Re: New Arkansas bill to keep minors off social media exempts most social platforms

#36

Is there a formal name to describe incumbents pushing for regulations in order to keep out new competitors? Something more specific than just “anti-competitive, monopolistic,” etc. This seems like such a common tactic that I’d expect there to be academic studies about it.

Typically, that’s what almost all regulations actually do. Just pull the ladder up farther out of reach. It’s the reason companies lobby for them.

You do realize there are thousands of regulations, related to everything from seat-belts to what chemical to use in hair coloring products. To say that "almost all regulation" comes from companies attempting "regulatory capture" seems simplified at best.

Lot of them surely come from pushes by companies, but if "almost all" is to believed, you're gonna have to cite something that shows this.

Re: New Arkansas bill to keep minors off social media exempts most social platforms

#37
post #18
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What makes lobbying to regulate your competitors out of existence neoliberal?

Further, what exactly does this have to do with capitalism? This is strictly a failure of government, and by extension the people.

When your whole political system depends on donations from large corporations, the government becomes in service of capitalism. Sure a failure of government but when you have built every incentives to promote those behaviours, the opposite would be surprising.

Many countries ban donations from companies, doesn't let companies pay for politicians ads, etc. Doesn't mean it's perfect, government rely on jobs from companies to make their citizens happy, but it does help to make the politician a bit more independent from corporate interest.

Re: New Arkansas bill to keep minors off social media exempts most social platforms

#38

Is there a formal name to describe incumbents pushing for regulations in order to keep out new competitors? Something more specific than just “anti-competitive, monopolistic,” etc. This seems like such a common tactic that I’d expect there to be academic studies about it.

Yes, the term you're looking for is "regulatory capture." Regulatory capture is a phenomenon where incumbent firms or industries manipulate regulations and regulatory bodies to create barriers to entry for new competitors, thereby maintaining or increasing their market power. This concept was first introduced by the economist George Stigler in his 1971 paper, "The Theory of Economic Regulation." Regulatory capture ca…

This is already being attempted with AI, under the guise of "safety".

Re: New Arkansas bill to keep minors off social media exempts most social platforms

#39
post #18
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What makes lobbying to regulate your competitors out of existence neoliberal?

Further, what exactly does this have to do with capitalism? This is strictly a failure of government, and by extension the people.

>Further, what exactly does this have to do with capitalism?

Well it clearly incentivizes regulatory capture, so there's that.

Re: New Arkansas bill to keep minors off social media exempts most social platforms

#40
post #33

I think people may be overlooking a bigger story here: https://www.arkleg.state.ar.us/Bills/FTPDocument?path=%2FBil... Reasonable age verification methods under subdivision (c)(1) of this section include providing: (A) A digitized identification card, including a digital copy of a driver's license under § 27-16-601 et seq.; (B) Government-issued identification; or (C) Any commercially reasonable age verification meth…

> Reasonable

No definition of that word matches their usage of it. Your papers, please.

https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Your_papers,_please

Post reply on HN