AI-generated image selected for a Sony World Photography Award
1–10 of 116 posts
Re: AI-generated image selected for a Sony World Photography Award
#2I think it's an awful image personally.
Re: AI-generated image selected for a Sony World Photography Award
#3Yeah, I don't get it. It doesn't look very good to me. It is also obviously AI generated, with the telltale signs of deformed limbs and hands.
Re: AI-generated image selected for a Sony World Photography Award
#4My initial reaction was "great, so this is a thing now" but then I opened the article:
> "I applied as a cheeky monkey, to find out, if the comeptitions (sic) are prepared for AI images to enter. They are not."
I withdraw my heavy sigh.
---
This did get me thinking though -- could camera manufacturers add a new tag to the EXIF data that is cryptographically signed by the camera? This could then be carried over from the RAW format to whichever format the photographer chooses to export as after their touch-ups. This could be verified by contest officiants.
Re: AI-generated image selected for a Sony World Photography Award
#5Let me guess, Sony using AI to rank the submissions?
Re: AI-generated image selected for a Sony World Photography Award
#6My initial reaction was "great, so this is a thing now" but then I opened the article: > "I applied as a cheeky monkey, to find out, if the comeptitions (sic) are prepared for AI images to enter. They are not." I withdraw my heavy sigh. --- This did get me thinking though -- could camera manufacturers add a new tag to the EXIF data that is cryptographically signed by the camera? This could then be carried over from t…
I think it needs the actual photographic data which is unique to be encoded with the camera model perhaps? Tagging is not enough, it needs to be part of the image to really work (I am guessing)
Re: AI-generated image selected for a Sony World Photography Award
#7My initial reaction was "great, so this is a thing now" but then I opened the article: > "I applied as a cheeky monkey, to find out, if the comeptitions (sic) are prepared for AI images to enter. They are not." I withdraw my heavy sigh. --- This did get me thinking though -- could camera manufacturers add a new tag to the EXIF data that is cryptographically signed by the camera? This could then be carried over from t…
> could camera manufacturers add a new tag to the EXIF data that is cryptographically signed by the camera
They could, and some already do, but this doesn't fully solve the problem. You'd still be left with the analog loophole[1]. A sufficiently advanced attacker could feed a generated image directly to the camera sensor.
Re: AI-generated image selected for a Sony World Photography Award
#8My initial reaction was "great, so this is a thing now" but then I opened the article: > "I applied as a cheeky monkey, to find out, if the comeptitions (sic) are prepared for AI images to enter. They are not." I withdraw my heavy sigh. --- This did get me thinking though -- could camera manufacturers add a new tag to the EXIF data that is cryptographically signed by the camera? This could then be carried over from t…
Could take a picture of a picture to gain the watermark.
Re: AI-generated image selected for a Sony World Photography Award
#9My initial reaction was "great, so this is a thing now" but then I opened the article: > "I applied as a cheeky monkey, to find out, if the comeptitions (sic) are prepared for AI images to enter. They are not." I withdraw my heavy sigh. --- This did get me thinking though -- could camera manufacturers add a new tag to the EXIF data that is cryptographically signed by the camera? This could then be carried over from t…
Where do you draw the line between heavy editing and fully AI-generated? Some edits have little in common with the source, so at which point is the source not relevant anymore? What if you feed an original photo through some AI-enhanced tool like Topaz?
Re: AI-generated image selected for a Sony World Photography Award
#10My initial reaction was "great, so this is a thing now" but then I opened the article: > "I applied as a cheeky monkey, to find out, if the comeptitions (sic) are prepared for AI images to enter. They are not." I withdraw my heavy sigh. --- This did get me thinking though -- could camera manufacturers add a new tag to the EXIF data that is cryptographically signed by the camera? This could then be carried over from t…
This already exists, from Sony nonetheless: https://www.sony.eu/presscentre/news/sony-unlocks-in-camera-...