Live data from Hacker News

Fullscreen apps above the MacBook notch

notes.alinpanaitiu.com

11–20 of 82 posts

Re: Fullscreen apps above the MacBook notch

#11

I've actually been debating getting a 14 MBP M1 for about $1500 on open box stores etc (woot), or on sale or what not but cannot justify spending 1.5k on a laptop lol. I have a desktop and a Thinkpad T430 if I need to go somewhere. Also have a tablet and such. I definitely do need a "better" laptop but my justification is that I'm not outside the house often enough for me to buy the MBP. Which, realistically, is true…

I spent 3.4k on my m1 64gb and tbh its some of the best money ive ever spent

Re: Fullscreen apps above the MacBook notch

#12

My 16" MBP would be a perfect device if they could either put the webcam/sensor array behind the glass or just get rid of it. If I want to FaceTime I can use an iPad or iPhone as a peripheral attachment. At this point, virtually perfect hardware is being ruined by a notch. :( It's a reminder every time that there are still design limitations to overcome and engineering feats to be achieved for the next 1,000 years. 8…

well, at least you've given a very generous timespan for them to resolve it

Re: Fullscreen apps above the MacBook notch

#13

I've actually been debating getting a 14 MBP M1 for about $1500 on open box stores etc (woot), or on sale or what not but cannot justify spending 1.5k on a laptop lol. I have a desktop and a Thinkpad T430 if I need to go somewhere. Also have a tablet and such. I definitely do need a "better" laptop but my justification is that I'm not outside the house often enough for me to buy the MBP. Which, realistically, is true…

If you're price-sensitive and not already doing so, include the M2 MBA (or, hell, even the M1 MBA) in your calculations. Great machines, way more than sufficient for most. Though there are some nice, fun luxury (again, for most) features on the MBPs, too.

Re: Fullscreen apps above the MacBook notch

#14

My 16" MBP would be a perfect device if they could either put the webcam/sensor array behind the glass or just get rid of it. If I want to FaceTime I can use an iPad or iPhone as a peripheral attachment. At this point, virtually perfect hardware is being ruined by a notch. :( It's a reminder every time that there are still design limitations to overcome and engineering feats to be achieved for the next 1,000 years. 8…

I imagine this will come to iPhone first, then MacBook’s (maybe limited to the Pro’s?) a year or two later.

Re: Fullscreen apps above the MacBook notch

#15
post #7

I've been looking on and off for a way to do this for years. Surprised more people aren't bothered by not being able to use the space next to the notch... it's not even consistent with the iPhone which does allow rendering apps around the notch.

I basically never do full screen, so for that reason I'm not bothered. (In fact, now I'm _less_ bothered, since I somehow no longer feel like the menu bar is "wasting" space.)

I never use the "fullscreen" mode either, and don't understand the point of it. But you don't ever have a window that spans the full vertical space of the screen?

You can hide the menu bar and have it only appear on mouseover, thus not wasting space. Except on non-notch Macs you can place windows where the menu bar used to be, and on notched Macs you can't

Re: Fullscreen apps above the MacBook notch

#16
post #4

I've been looking on and off for a way to do this for years. Surprised more people aren't bothered by not being able to use the space next to the notch... it's not even consistent with the iPhone which does allow rendering apps around the notch.

Not to say you can’t be bothered, but I look at it this way. I’m honestly only really looking at a small amount of my screen at a time…. I suspect I use that space very little.

So why ever get a larger screen?

Maybe you feel that way, but it's not a commonly shared belief. There is a marginal value to having additional screen space, and its silly to block use of it via software gates.

Re: Fullscreen apps above the MacBook notch

#17

I've actually been debating getting a 14 MBP M1 for about $1500 on open box stores etc (woot), or on sale or what not but cannot justify spending 1.5k on a laptop lol. I have a desktop and a Thinkpad T430 if I need to go somewhere. Also have a tablet and such. I definitely do need a "better" laptop but my justification is that I'm not outside the house often enough for me to buy the MBP. Which, realistically, is true…

I spent 3.4k on my m1 64gb and tbh its some of the best money ive ever spent

A client of mine has just issued me an M2 MBP as a bonus, and wow. Night and day difference to my previous i9 MBP.

The battery on this is incredible - not to mention my limbs no longer get burnt.

Re: Fullscreen apps above the MacBook notch

#18

I've actually been debating getting a 14 MBP M1 for about $1500 on open box stores etc (woot), or on sale or what not but cannot justify spending 1.5k on a laptop lol. I have a desktop and a Thinkpad T430 if I need to go somewhere. Also have a tablet and such. I definitely do need a "better" laptop but my justification is that I'm not outside the house often enough for me to buy the MBP. Which, realistically, is true…

I spent 3.4k on my m1 64gb and tbh its some of the best money ive ever spent

I use mine 10+ hours a day as the primary tool in the work I do and enjoy it a lot. It's a bargain to me. Everything works and the OS stays out of my way so can completely focus on the primary apps I use. I remember the early years of work with a computer, dealing with drivers and networking and huge CRT displays and other drama. It's very rare that I notice or think about the notch, and I never use the camera.

Re: Fullscreen apps above the MacBook notch

#19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I spent 3.4k on my m1 64gb and tbh its some of the best money ive ever spent

A client of mine has just issued me an M2 MBP as a bonus, and wow. Night and day difference to my previous i9 MBP. The battery on this is incredible - not to mention my limbs no longer get burnt.

On the old ones, my fan used to run constantly at full power.

Now, my external platter drives make more noise than the laptop.

Re: Fullscreen apps above the MacBook notch

#20
post #7

I've been looking on and off for a way to do this for years. Surprised more people aren't bothered by not being able to use the space next to the notch... it's not even consistent with the iPhone which does allow rendering apps around the notch.

I basically never do full screen, so for that reason I'm not bothered. (In fact, now I'm _less_ bothered, since I somehow no longer feel like the menu bar is "wasting" space.)

Yeah.

Modern videos are so wide that a little extra vertical space barely enlarges the video if at all.

Games usually can't use the space since the notch covers their UI.

For me it's just free space for the menubar.

Post reply on HN