Live data from Hacker News

Is Nerd Culture Dying?

samkriss.substack.com

31–40 of 117 posts

Re: Is Nerd Culture Dying?

#31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> has just gone mainstream Care to provide some examples? Most "nerd" interests like SciFi have been neutered if not completely bent out of shape while going mainstream.

The term "MCU" being in the common cultral lexicon.

except since phase 4 MCU is now definitely a synonym for "boring, neutered, ill-concived, weak, pale shadow of former self, stuff°

Kudos to Disney that was able to completely ruin it in just a decade.

Re: Is Nerd Culture Dying?

#32
Geek culture is things like comic books, video games and Star Wars. Nerd culture is things like recreational mathematics, model trains, and editing Wikipedia.

Re: Is Nerd Culture Dying?

#34

I think that nerd culture has just gone mainstream. It's far from dying.

Indeed. And "real" nerd culture has just became deeper, and more specialized. Back in the day, a lot of the nerds were into the same type of things, while now there are sub-groups. Some nerds are anime-nerds, others are programming-nerds, and not every programming-nerd is an anime-nerd, and vice-versa. And the amount of nerd-sub groups is huge, every quarter or so I encounter a nerdy topic and sub-group I had no idea…

Being from a small rural Australian town, it was amazing when I found my nerds in the big city. You do end up a bit pigeonholed when everything gets too specific. I think that is why I like makerspaces and things like that. You get all sorts.

Re: Is Nerd Culture Dying?

#37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The term "MCU" being in the common cultral lexicon.

except since phase 4 MCU is now definitely a synonym for "boring, neutered, ill-concived, weak, pale shadow of former self, stuff° Kudos to Disney that was able to completely ruin it in just a decade.

This only proves the point.

Re: Is Nerd Culture Dying?

#38

I believe there is no counter culture in the west anymore. It is mainstream to be subversive, and so there is little to no subversiveness left

This was already being talked about in the mid-naughties in "The Rebel Sell: How The Counter Culture Became Consumer Culture" by Heath and Potter. Had a big influence on me as a teenager.

Re: Is Nerd Culture Dying?

#39
Nerds of the 90s grew up and became a nice (more often than not) affluent market. Industry shifted to accomodate for that. I for one, enjoy it while it lasts.

Because of this, a lot of cultural products made sure that the "nerds" felt the heroes of their own stories, making them cool in pop culture.

That being said, I always considered a crucial characteristic of a nerd the inability to interact fluently with the social environment, instead focusing their energy online or in very specific niches that shielded them from this social "anxiety".

This very much remains, cool kids do "cool" stuff and eloquently interact with their social environment. "Cool stuff" now is probably more "nerdy" than it was 20y ago but the divide is there, I think the author (and me probably) are too old to really see what "nerds" to today.

Re: Is Nerd Culture Dying?

#40

I think that nerd culture has just gone mainstream. It's far from dying.

> has just gone mainstream Care to provide some examples? Most "nerd" interests like SciFi have been neutered if not completely bent out of shape while going mainstream.

Personal computing has gone mainstream.

Video games have gone mainstream.

Internet has gone mainstream.

Anime has gone mainstream.

"AI" has gone mainstream.

I think it's fair to say that nerd culture does, has, and always will exist, but what nerd culture is changes with the passing sands of time. The nerds of today are not the nerds of yesteryear (read: us).

Post reply on HN