Live data from Hacker News

Iran installs cameras in public places to identify, penalise unveiled women

reuters.com

181–190 of 217 posts

Re: Iran installs cameras in public places to identify, penalise unveiled women

#181

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The US is arguably the only country in the world where a significant % of citizens possess firearms. If US army decided to commit genocide against even some subset of those citizens, do you really think said firearms would help much? (Edit: more curiously, has there actually been an example of a democractically-elected government committing genocide?)

> If US army decided to commit genocide against even some subset of those citizens, do you really think said firearms would help much? It worked well for Afghanistan, also Vietnam.

Do you really believe either was an example of attempted genocide? I don't think anyone believes the US lost in Vietnam because local citizens had access to firearms.

Re: Iran installs cameras in public places to identify, penalise unveiled women

#182
post #84

Earlier quoted context omitted.

These anecdotes are completely useless. It is far too common to see some conservative somewhere trot out anecdotes such as this, claiming some stupidity being said by someone they don’t like. Frankly I do not believe you, no matter how taboo it is the say so. To use a phrase that seems to have lost favor: link, or it didn’t happen.

I’m not conservative and I’m not recording sensitive private conversations for the amusement of internet strangers. I’m relating my first hand experience using my real name, you can choose to believe whatever you want.

The burden of proof is on you. Absent such your claim is rightfully judged false.

Re: Iran installs cameras in public places to identify, penalise unveiled women

#183
post #43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's real simple: "Don't take away my choice to wear what I want." For whatever reason, fragile people get real offended by what other people wear.

Do the people which get offended by nazi uniforms are fragile as well ? The topic is much more complicated than "fragility" as you are dismissively trying to portray it. We wear clothes in civilised societies for a reason, and different types of clothes have different types of societal effects. Your freedom ends where the the freedom of the next person's begins.

[deleted]

Re: Iran installs cameras in public places to identify, penalise unveiled women

#184
post #43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's real simple: "Don't take away my choice to wear what I want." For whatever reason, fragile people get real offended by what other people wear.

Do the people which get offended by nazi uniforms are fragile as well ? The topic is much more complicated than "fragility" as you are dismissively trying to portray it. We wear clothes in civilised societies for a reason, and different types of clothes have different types of societal effects. Your freedom ends where the the freedom of the next person's begins.

[deleted]

Re: Iran installs cameras in public places to identify, penalise unveiled women

#185

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It is the opposite. Feminists are fundamentally anti religion and anti establishment. If govt is railing against what women can do, feminists are the first to fight. If religion is dictating what women can/should do, feminists will be the first to fight. Feminists are to authority like atheists are to religion.

I had a conversation with a young progressive atheist woman about first hand accounts with women of Muslim backgrounds wearing the mandated clothing out of fear. She had a hard time accepting that what people said and how they acted publicly wasn’t the whole story. I used to smoke weed with some people that included some Muslim girls who would talk openly about what they were afraid of and the family pressures. If yo…

I have known Muslim women who have had to fight their own family members to wear the clothing, and had to fight the fundamentalist stereotypes associated with women who veil. And then I have also come across Muslim women who were pressured to wear out of tradition. Rarely have I come across any women rebels. But that’s also because I am selective of the company I keep, like I don’t go anywhere near drugs.

Our experiences are a result of who we associate with. The Muslim women who fought to wear the scarf did so out of having dedication and focus in their lives to studies and discipline (they were med students, engineers, architects).

Re: Iran installs cameras in public places to identify, penalise unveiled women

#186
post #79

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It is the opposite. Feminists are fundamentally anti religion and anti establishment. If govt is railing against what women can do, feminists are the first to fight. If religion is dictating what women can/should do, feminists will be the first to fight. Feminists are to authority like atheists are to religion.

This has been my experience, especially given the predominance of governments that are to some degree controlled by fundamentalist sects. It goes against the unspoken orthodoxy of what feminism is, though, so I do not expect your opinion to be a popular one here. I would say that there is a lot of overlap between atheism and feminism though.

No kidding. I didn’t think I would get 5 down points. But here we are.

Re: Iran installs cameras in public places to identify, penalise unveiled women

#187

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can start with https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wounded_Knee_Massacre and follow with a middle school history book about Germany, China or about a dozen other nations.

China never had a citizenry widely armed with firearms. Germany was also never widely armed prior to Hitler. This is an urban myth. Only a handful of societies have ever had widespread civilian armament. Certainly not enough to make any kind of causal inference about the general effects of firearms on revolutionary or counter-revolutionary activity. And Wounded Knee? This was a continuation of a policy of Manifest De…

PRC had massive public firearms ownership stemming from people's war, villages were settling beef with home made artillery into the 90s until gov crackdown.

Re: Iran installs cameras in public places to identify, penalise unveiled women

#188

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Perhaps, that doesn't make it true though...

Causality in global geopolitics is complicated, multifactorial, and generally very difficult to pin down. The original comment was talking about the perceptions of Iranians, and my comments speaks to the perceptions I have seen. US-Iran relations post-WW2 and why some Iranians see the US as a causal factor for the current repressive regime is a fascinating topic! If you want to explore, here are a few starting points…

At what point do we allow people (in this case the Iranian regime) to have free will / self agency? And also - we usually don't allow ourselves to go 50 years back to explain someone's behavior. At least in court - that kind of testimony wouldn't have much value.

Re: Iran installs cameras in public places to identify, penalise unveiled women

#189

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Causality in global geopolitics is complicated, multifactorial, and generally very difficult to pin down. The original comment was talking about the perceptions of Iranians, and my comments speaks to the perceptions I have seen. US-Iran relations post-WW2 and why some Iranians see the US as a causal factor for the current repressive regime is a fascinating topic! If you want to explore, here are a few starting points…

At what point do we allow people (in this case the Iranian regime) to have free will / self agency? And also - we usually don't allow ourselves to go 50 years back to explain someone's behavior. At least in court - that kind of testimony wouldn't have much value.

US Courts (and others) will lock up or send to death row some on evidence that they killed someone 50 years ago (and more) .. murder has no statute of limitations.

US actions set the conditions (a foreign puppet ruler) for a people's overthrow which itself was usurped by the worst form of theocrats (your "Iranian Regime") who maintain power by murder (public hangings in squares, etc) .. and act which, again, US Courts have no time limitation on the consideration of.

Re: Iran installs cameras in public places to identify, penalise unveiled women

#190

I wish they'd share exactly the reason of these cameras Is it really for spying unveiled women? Or is it for public safety? considering the recent poisoning of young female students [1] + the killing of scientists by the mossad [2] The fact that reuters jumps to conclusions makes me believe there is something fishy going in with Iran and its neighbor Israel Why isn't the press investigating? Maybe that's the question…

Is this a parody? The press has investigated, thats the Reuters article you're reading.

Parody? if you weren't disrespectful i would have argumented further, instead i'll just wish you a happy easter :)
Post reply on HN