Live data from Hacker News

Electricity Prices by Country

electricrate.com

61–70 of 312 posts

Re: Electricity Prices by Country

#61

France seems to be in a sweet spot: low electricity price and low CO2 emissions, thanks to nuclear power?

Thanks to that indeed, but the future doesn't look great, as little has been done in the last 20 years. So France will have to do a lot in the next decade, and that may change our prices.

Re: Electricity Prices by Country

#62
post #54
post #51

If you are asking yourself why prices in Germany are so high: It's mostly the price surge of natural gas after Russia cut off deliveries in retaliation to sanctions in the wake of the war against Ukraine. About 50% of the price per kw/h in Germany is set by an auction system. Electricity providers are bidding at any given point in time to provide energy for the grid. The lowest price per kw/h wins. BUT: because no on…

To think there were nuclear reactors already built and running perfectly fine in Germany. That were closed down presumably for ecological reasons. Burning coal and natural gas instead.

They werent that many to begin with they growing increasingly expensive to run, were coming to the end of their lifespan and Fukushima was a risk that was hard to ignore.

It's interesting how Poland's electricity mix has been 80% coal for decades and this passes without comment, but what really enrages some people is a few nuclear power plants in Germany being mostly swapped out with solar and wind energy.

Doesnt seem like environmentalism is really the core issue driving this.

Re: Electricity Prices by Country

#63
post #51

If you are asking yourself why prices in Germany are so high: It's mostly the price surge of natural gas after Russia cut off deliveries in retaliation to sanctions in the wake of the war against Ukraine. About 50% of the price per kw/h in Germany is set by an auction system. Electricity providers are bidding at any given point in time to provide energy for the grid. The lowest price per kw/h wins. BUT: because no on…

[flagged]

Re: Electricity Prices by Country

#64
post #54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

To think there were nuclear reactors already built and running perfectly fine in Germany. That were closed down presumably for ecological reasons. Burning coal and natural gas instead.

Not just any coal, but lignite, the nastiest, dirtiest kind of coal. Definitely greener than nuclear. /s

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/3/3b/En...

Re: Electricity Prices by Country

#65

Prices of anything "by country" should be normalized by local average income. Ideally, for a fairer comparison, a good metric is "how many hours of work of a median citizen for each unity" of such a good. EDIT: article does something similar to that: https://www.electricrate.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/coun...

That speaks to affordability, but not to why some countries just don't seem to be able to do it effectively, costing an order of magnitude more in some countries than others.

Re: Electricity Prices by Country

#66
post #51

If you are asking yourself why prices in Germany are so high: It's mostly the price surge of natural gas after Russia cut off deliveries in retaliation to sanctions in the wake of the war against Ukraine. About 50% of the price per kw/h in Germany is set by an auction system. Electricity providers are bidding at any given point in time to provide energy for the grid. The lowest price per kw/h wins. BUT: because no on…

You describe the auction system as a bad thing.

But actually it's a good thing.

The providers who (through investment and/or technological superiority) are able to provide cheaper electricity, make more money.

Capitalist progress engine at its finest!

Re: Electricity Prices by Country

#67

France seems to be in a sweet spot: low electricity price and low CO2 emissions, thanks to nuclear power?

There's a important lesson about using nuclear power as an energy source in there. Contrast that with Germany which is shuttering their nuclear power plants in favor of renewables.

Re: Electricity Prices by Country

#68

France seems to be in a sweet spot: low electricity price and low CO2 emissions, thanks to nuclear power?

Household prices are meaningless in this context, because they are artificially kept low in France and sometimes are affected by taxes and fees elsewhere.

Here are spot marked prices: https://tradingeconomics.com/france/electricity-price https://tradingeconomics.com/germany/electricity-price

Re: Electricity Prices by Country

#69

France seems to be in a sweet spot: low electricity price and low CO2 emissions, thanks to nuclear power?

There's a important lesson about using nuclear power as an energy source in there. Contrast that with Germany which is shuttering their nuclear power plants in favor of renewables.

There is no such lesson. EDF is going bankrupt, France is spending billions trying to replace reactors aging out and about 20% or so of the ~70 billion decommissioning costs are funded.

The important lesson here should be that retail prices != prices.

Re: Electricity Prices by Country

#70

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Toronto Hydro† also has time-of-use rates: * https://www.torontohydro.com/for-home/rates † Mostly due to historical reason of early generator stations being hydro-electric (water falls), electricity is called "hydro" in many parts of Canada.

In Ontario the published rates also omit the 'delivery' fees and additional charges added on top (per kWh) which are unavoidable. The real rate actually paid is typically double the supposed rate. Factoring in the actual price people really pay, the rate is more like that of Barbados, Greece etc, right towards to most expensive end of the table. Despite the essentially unlimited hydro generation possible thanks to th…

Ontario is mostly nuclear in installed capacity. “Hydro” has been a misnomer for a while.

https://ieso.ca/

While we are definitely overpaying for wind and solar capacity, there isn’t enough of it to really justify the prices we pay (and arguably, solar performs best when demand is highest, so its cost-benefit isn’t as bad as many believe)

Post reply on HN