Live data from Hacker News

Everything advertised on social media is overpriced junk

pluralistic.net

51–60 of 213 posts

Re: Everything advertised on social media is overpriced junk

#51

I consider this phenomenon part of what I like to call the "Amazon syndrome", even though Amazon is far from being the only culprit. As China started flooding the rest of the world with cheap but decent products mass-produced in a random factory in Shenzhen, people turned away from brands they used to trust and towards no-name options from the likes of "Kxbnheb" or "Ypknwoj" in order to save a buck. Eventually the bi…

It’s not true that established brands made cheaper products to compete. Their prices remained the same or got higher, but quality still suffered. It’s just greed, no complex reasoning required. I recently bought a gym bag from Nike. Feels super cheap, like I could have gotten it from Aliexpress. The zippers keep locking into the fabric. Feels completely disposable. Bought a pair of running shoes from Skechers early l…

There's pressure on both sides (competition to lower prices vs take profits from the reputation), but I agree with your take.

Primarily, there has been an extraction of excess profit on consumer goods rather than investment in more efficient production or better products. I have suspicions that this is because of the relative ease of growing a profitable (but easily copied) manufacturing business out of China over the last 20 years, but it really doesn't matter why.

The other example of this is Oil Majors who have very little incentive to invest in new oil production or refining (even though it may be needed for the next decade), and instead take all excess profits to pay out as stock buybacks or dividends. They are in the profit taking stage of the business not the growth and investment stage.

Re: Everything advertised on social media is overpriced junk

#52

My feeling throughout reading the article is best summed up as "Y U mad bro?" He harps on an "anti-woke" razor company that tries to market themselves as an alternative to Gillette and Harry's — the big point is "they spend 800k/month on marketing, so it drives up the cost of the razors". Does he know how much Gillette spends (saved you a search: 600M/year)? How do they fund that I wonder? He cites a study that says…

You’ve clearly never worked in direct response marketing. The cost of customer acquisition vs lifetime value of a customer is terrible compared to traditional retail. In 2007, you could print money. In 2023, you’re most likely barely breaking even buying digital ads. The OPs thesis is quite correct. I’ve been in the space for 14 years and have tens of millions, if not hundreds, in DR adspend across multiple platforms / industries.

Re: Everything advertised on social media is overpriced junk

#53
post #50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It’s not true that established brands made cheaper products to compete. Their prices remained the same or got higher, but quality still suffered. It’s just greed, no complex reasoning required. I recently bought a gym bag from Nike. Feels super cheap, like I could have gotten it from Aliexpress. The zippers keep locking into the fabric. Feels completely disposable. Bought a pair of running shoes from Skechers early l…

Running shoes are good for about 600 to 700km fyi. After that, the foam breaks down too much to provide adequate cushioning and the right sproing. Having the external hard rubber last longer than that is just unnecessary weight. You may just be in better shape than you were in college. Distance stacks up fast and running faster wears shoes out faster. sauce: I run marathons and go through about 6 pairs of running sho…

Which shoes do you use? I use ASICS GT-2000s and they usually last 350km to 400km, or a year, in my case (a couple 5k to 8k runs per week). I guess different styles of running could also cause different amounts of wear and tear.

Re: Everything advertised on social media is overpriced junk

#54

I consider this phenomenon part of what I like to call the "Amazon syndrome", even though Amazon is far from being the only culprit. As China started flooding the rest of the world with cheap but decent products mass-produced in a random factory in Shenzhen, people turned away from brands they used to trust and towards no-name options from the likes of "Kxbnheb" or "Ypknwoj" in order to save a buck. Eventually the bi…

It’s not true that established brands made cheaper products to compete. Their prices remained the same or got higher, but quality still suffered. It’s just greed, no complex reasoning required. I recently bought a gym bag from Nike. Feels super cheap, like I could have gotten it from Aliexpress. The zippers keep locking into the fabric. Feels completely disposable. Bought a pair of running shoes from Skechers early l…

[deleted]

Re: Everything advertised on social media is overpriced junk

#55

> Passing a federal privacy law would end surveillance advertising at the stroke of a pen Unlikely—breaking the laws would likely just become a business cost, and make everything even more expensive for everyone.

This. People like slapping laws on issues when the outcome is usually higher costs in the form of never shrinking burocrazys, little to no actual enforcement (unless you are rich or connected) and the red tape involved in compliance will likely make it worse. The answer is by adopting different behavior on our end. Add blockers avoiding services litterer in ads (its why i no longer use Instagram, google search, etc)

[deleted]

Re: Everything advertised on social media is overpriced junk

#57
post #50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Running shoes are good for about 600 to 700km fyi. After that, the foam breaks down too much to provide adequate cushioning and the right sproing. Having the external hard rubber last longer than that is just unnecessary weight. You may just be in better shape than you were in college. Distance stacks up fast and running faster wears shoes out faster. sauce: I run marathons and go through about 6 pairs of running sho…

Which shoes do you use? I use ASICS GT-2000s and they usually last 350km to 400km, or a year, in my case (a couple 5k to 8k runs per week). I guess different styles of running could also cause different amounts of wear and tear.

Adidas Adios stuff has worked best for me. But I’m also 56kg so they prob last longer than they would for a bigger person.

Re: Everything advertised on social media is overpriced junk

#58
If an advertising platform doesn't work well, it can only support extremely high profit margin luxury goods because cutthroat commodities can't afford ads that don't work.

The real story is social media marketing is ineffective, not that the products are trash.

Its kind of like what's advertised in spam.

Re: Everything advertised on social media is overpriced junk

#59
post #30

I hate to be one of those "you lost me at the second paragraph" kind of guys, but....you lost me at the second paragraph: > stuff that's pushed to you via targeted ads costs an average of 10 percent more, > and it significantly more likely to come from a vendor with a poor rating > from the Better Business Bureau. The BBB is pay for play organization whose ratings mean little more than "they paid their membership due…

The rest of the article is way better, and not really about this.
Post reply on HN