Live data from Hacker News

I don't want streaming music, I just want to stream my music

coryd.dev

381–390 of 421 posts

Re: I don't want streaming music, I just want to stream my music

#381

It's funny Youtube Music was mentioned because Google Play Music was actually great for listening to your music and having a curated library of stuff you uploaded along with the music on the service. When they killed that in favor of Youtube Music I noticed the "library" experience there is seemingly intentionally hobbled. The artist page is sorted by the "artist" field not "album artist" and then on top of that inst…

[deleted]

Re: I don't want streaming music, I just want to stream my music

#382
post #348
post #10

I paid for plex, I stream my own music from anywhere via the callback into my home net. I can chromecast, play in-car, whatever. If I have IP "it just works" Its backed on an RPI-4 NAS I built, running the plex arm linux code. I have another RPI-3 in the living room as a headless music source to an amp. In the past I've used HDMI to VGA+audio splitters to scatter output to devices. This is my music, on my disks, unde…

I wish Plex or Jellyfin would get support for audiobooks. I can keep my music library on my phone but my audiobook library is much larger and sometimes I get an itch to listen to something I don't have on me.

Plex has a setting at the library level that tells it to remember your last spot in an audio track. So if you set up your audiobooks as if they're music, this will allow you to listen to them reasonably through plex/plexamp.

That's not really a satisfying solution - you're missing out on the metadata matching features of the system. But it does get you there.

There's another app, audiobookshelf[1], that does this better. There's a server component analogous to plex server, as well as a web app or a mobile app for playback. The user experience is way better, but organizing the audio files is rather a pain.

[1] https://www.audiobookshelf.org/

Re: I don't want streaming music, I just want to stream my music

#383
post #305

I use Jellyfin, it's about the same thing as Plex, but free. I host it on my homelab along with a half dozen other services, and I can stream any of my media from anywhere. There's even pretty nice third-party clients. I use finamp on android, it's specifically a music player frontend for jellyfin, and has options to download your files and play offline. So far, the biggest problem is simply learning how to find musi…

I've found out the best places to find new music are the ones on the illegal side of things. There are still torrent sites with amazing communities, recommendation systems and all the possible music available in all qualities. Too bad it's not really OK to mention them by name, but if you dig a bit, you can find them.

when w.cd died I lost a part of my life :'(

Re: I don't want streaming music, I just want to stream my music

#384
post #314

OK, serious question - why stream the music? Why not just sync between your computer and phone once a day or week or however often you obtain new music? Then if you don’t have a network connection, you can still listen to all of your music. Is the issue storage space? I did this with an iPod for years before the iPhone came out and it worked really well.

I have a small mp3 (sandisk). About 16GB, around 4000 songs. I carry it with all the time (when travelling, when doing sports, when running, etc). The best thing is that it's small, so I can just hang it anywhere on my clothes and call it a day. I still download mp3s from here and there like in the old days (and have backups as well). Why not using my smartphone? I don't carry it when doing sports, for instance (it's…

Same. I keep a small playlist of mp3 files in Google Drive and sync when I update it. SanDisk is cheap and great for exercising. I hate lugging around my phone and letting it distract me.

Re: I don't want streaming music, I just want to stream my music

#386
post #39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's technically still streaming, it's just the latency is next to negligible because the source is local.

No one who says streaming music means loading a file locally, I think you're hallucinating your own definition.

Streaming is nothing more than opening a file and processing the resultant stream(!) of data.

Whether you grab your MP3 off of local storage (eg: HDD), off of LAN storage (eg: NAS), or off of WAN storage (eg: Youtube), you're streaming.

Re: I don't want streaming music, I just want to stream my music

#387
post #385

Lots of good suggestions here. One option i haven't seen mentioned yet is Vox: https://vox.rocks/ It's a paid service that seems fairly well polished with apps for different platforms, including mobile. Wondering if anyone's using it and what the feedback is.

It's mentioned in the article

Re: I don't want streaming music, I just want to stream my music

#388

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No one who says streaming music means loading a file locally, I think you're hallucinating your own definition.

Streaming is nothing more than opening a file and processing the resultant stream(!) of data. Whether you grab your MP3 off of local storage (eg: HDD), off of LAN storage (eg: NAS), or off of WAN storage (eg: Youtube), you're streaming.

When anyone talks about streaming music or video they are talking about downloading it as they're watching it. You are hallucinating a definition that no one uses. Try to understand the context if you can.

Re: I don't want streaming music, I just want to stream my music

#389

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Emby, a (somewhat) open source C# project, is not a fork of Plex Media Server, a closed source C/C++ project. Emby was forked as Jellyfin however, as a reaction to Emby becoming more and more of a closed source project.

Plex was forked from XBMC which is renamed to KODI an open source project. Think the fork was around version 8 or 9. KODI is up to 20. Downside to KODI is it does not have streaming built in like Plex. But has built in emulation again like earlier version of XBMC.

what do you mean by "KODI ... does not have streaming"? I have rpi with KODI on my son's TV and it streams everything over CIFS from my NAS - the NAS doesn't transcode or otherwise do anything but host the cifs share.

Re: I don't want streaming music, I just want to stream my music

#390
post #357
post #310

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The page does not make it clear how it works. This is how a technically inclined but maybe less so than your current users may see this: Like its a kind of Dropbox? With folders and whatnot? But with a Music player App to play the music on various devices, which will stream the music from that drop box? So it’s like a Spotify, except it takes the music from this drop box like thing instead of their server? For which…

Thanks for the feedback. Agreed it's not presented well. It's kind of like Dropbox. You can upload files from your browser, and you can also listen to your music in your browser. It supports an open protocol called Subsonic. There are Subsonic apps for various OSs. But, we don't have our own native app. I definitely need screenshots / open demo page.

Thanks for the answer! How about a paragraph like this:

Inter.tube let’s you easily store your music collection in your own cloud and listen to it on all your devices. It's kind of like Dropbox, but focused on storing and streaming music. You can upload files (mp3, Flac, …) from your browser, and you can listen to your music either with your browser or via music apps. We don’t have our own native music playing App. You can use any music playing app that supports an open protocol called “Subsonic”. There are Subsonic apps for various OSs, including Android and iOS. See our list of recommended apps [here].

Post reply on HN