Live data from Hacker News

Google and Amazon Struggle to Lay Off Workers in Europe Due to Labor Laws

bloomberg.com

31–40 of 72 posts

Re: Google and Amazon Struggle to Lay Off Workers in Europe Due to Labor Laws

#31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Strong worker protections are a major reason that big tech and many other industries have a much smaller presence in Europe and pay far less to Europeans. You're worth less if you might be absent on parental leave for a year at a time. You're higher risk to hire if you can't be fired easily etc. Protections have a cost. My friends that moved to UK/Europe get half their former salary and have much higher living expens…

Maybe if you're from FAANG land. I took 10k cut (90k to 80k) from my salary leaving Seattle but gained a union, 20 more days of vacation, a 8% holiday bonus, 90% cheaper insurance, and 500$ less in rent per month in Amsterdam

Yeah, and much lower costs of childcare, schooling?. Much lower chances of gun violence, and exteremeness of inequality in the society.

As most things, the comparison is dependent on what state of life you’re at and your preferences.

Re: Google and Amazon Struggle to Lay Off Workers in Europe Due to Labor Laws

#33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They level out both the upside and the downside. If you can never fire people, you're going to be very very cautious about who you hire in the first place. That makes it much harder to get companies into a bidding war that'll actually raise your wages. I've had a few European teammates, and they usually come to the U.S. because they can make 3-5x what they could in Europe. You'll see that a lot in HN comments, where…

You're assuming that the differences in wages between US and Europe are solely due to labor laws, which is quite a stretch, in my opinion.

I think it's interesting to compare Switzerland with the neighbouring countries (e.g. France and Germany). I don't know about other companies, but Google Zürich pays much more than Google Paris or Google Berlin/Munich.

I think it's likely that the difference in labour laws is a contributing factor. Switzerland has very little by way of worker protection, instead placing a significant emphasis on unemployment insurance (Arbeitslosenversicherung).

Re: Google and Amazon Struggle to Lay Off Workers in Europe Due to Labor Laws

#34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Strong worker protections are a major reason that big tech and many other industries have a much smaller presence in Europe and pay far less to Europeans. You're worth less if you might be absent on parental leave for a year at a time. You're higher risk to hire if you can't be fired easily etc. Protections have a cost. My friends that moved to UK/Europe get half their former salary and have much higher living expens…

It all depends on what you value. Dutch labour laws are not written for highly educated tech bros but designed to protect everyone. Wealth inequality for instance is something that permeates political discourse. Americans don't give a shit about it at all. Making society nicer for everyone and not leaving anyone behind.

>Making society nicer for everyone and not leaving anyone behind.

In the short term, Europe is much better at this than the US, but the long term sustainability of the European welfare state will be under serious threat over the next 50 years due to the horrible demographics of most European countries

Re: Google and Amazon Struggle to Lay Off Workers in Europe Due to Labor Laws

#35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Maybe it's related, maybe it's due to the fact that the cost of almost everything in the US is higher. There's many factors in this conversation

So companies just pay you out of the goodness of their heart because you need the money?

I have no idea how you know from what I said to that. All I said is that available data does not allow you to conclude that the entirety of the difference in pay is due to difference in labor laws. It's not an extraordinary claim, it's quite tame in fact, I would self evident.

Re: Google and Amazon Struggle to Lay Off Workers in Europe Due to Labor Laws

#36
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You're assuming that the differences in wages between US and Europe are solely due to labor laws, which is quite a stretch, in my opinion.

I think it's interesting to compare Switzerland with the neighbouring countries (e.g. France and Germany). I don't know about other companies, but Google Zürich pays much more than Google Paris or Google Berlin/Munich. I think it's likely that the difference in labour laws is a contributing factor. Switzerland has very little by way of worker protection, instead placing a significant emphasis on unemployment insuranc…

Cost of Living is much higher in Switzerland.

Re: Google and Amazon Struggle to Lay Off Workers in Europe Due to Labor Laws

#37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Strong worker protections are a major reason that big tech and many other industries have a much smaller presence in Europe and pay far less to Europeans. You're worth less if you might be absent on parental leave for a year at a time. You're higher risk to hire if you can't be fired easily etc. Protections have a cost. My friends that moved to UK/Europe get half their former salary and have much higher living expens…

Maybe if you're from FAANG land. I took 10k cut (90k to 80k) from my salary leaving Seattle but gained a union, 20 more days of vacation, a 8% holiday bonus, 90% cheaper insurance, and 500$ less in rent per month in Amsterdam

"There are only two kinds of people I hate.. people who are intolerant of other people's cultures.. and the Dutch!"

Re: Google and Amazon Struggle to Lay Off Workers in Europe Due to Labor Laws

#38
post #36
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think it's interesting to compare Switzerland with the neighbouring countries (e.g. France and Germany). I don't know about other companies, but Google Zürich pays much more than Google Paris or Google Berlin/Munich. I think it's likely that the difference in labour laws is a contributing factor. Switzerland has very little by way of worker protection, instead placing a significant emphasis on unemployment insuranc…

Cost of Living is much higher in Switzerland.

Cost of living is usually higher in areas with higher wages, because it means that residents have more money to spend on living.

Re: Google and Amazon Struggle to Lay Off Workers in Europe Due to Labor Laws

#39
post #36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Cost of Living is much higher in Switzerland.

Cost of living is usually higher in areas with higher wages, because it means that residents have more money to spend on living.

Right, and Google explicitly doesn't model for cost of living in its comp philosophy.

Re: Google and Amazon Struggle to Lay Off Workers in Europe Due to Labor Laws

#40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They level out both the upside and the downside. If you can never fire people, you're going to be very very cautious about who you hire in the first place. That makes it much harder to get companies into a bidding war that'll actually raise your wages. I've had a few European teammates, and they usually come to the U.S. because they can make 3-5x what they could in Europe. You'll see that a lot in HN comments, where…

You're assuming that the differences in wages between US and Europe are solely due to labor laws, which is quite a stretch, in my opinion.

I don't see the "assuming... solely" in their post at all. Seems like they are just pointing out a factor, could be one of many.
Post reply on HN