Live data from Hacker News

Do iOS apps crash more than Android?

forbes.com

11–20 of 47 posts

Re: Do iOS apps crash more than Android?

#11
post #9
post #2

I have almost never had an iOS app crash on me. I get crashes in Android apps almost weekly. I honestly don't know where those guys are getting their data, but I really don't believe it. It's true, it's a lot easier for developers on Android to fix bugs and quickly update their apps because of the lack of an approval process, but that also lowers the bar a great deal on the quality of apps (a lot of which never get u…

I get iOS app crashes all the time -- and not just third party applications. The app store seems particularly buggy and in the 5 months since I've had my iPhone; crashing on multiple occasions. The worst problem I've ever had is some kind of corruption in the photos app. I thought perhaps it was a corrupt file but I couldn't launch the Photos app to delete it. I couldn't launch the camera app either. There's no way t…

wow, that's quite a bad experience. is your iPhone jailbroken ?

Re: Do iOS apps crash more than Android?

#12
My anecdotal evidence co-incides with this, I used to use Android and had barely any crashes (the only ones were generally specifically reproducable bugs), and now I use iOS and I see a lot more.

I always attributed it to memory management - manual memory management is simply a lot easier to f' up than garbage collection. Meanwhile Android apps are slower and probably consume more memory. It's all tradeoffs.

Re: Do iOS apps crash more than Android?

#13

It really irks me when crashes are made out to be the result of user actions, or some inescapable act of god. Excepting the very rare hardware fault, crashes are caused by a programmer error . PERIOD. That is all that really matters from the user's perspective. There may be some way to work around the bug by tinkering with things, but nothing the user does can ever cause a crash. Also, it wouldn't surprise me if iOS…

When an Android app runs of memory it also crashes, with an OutOfMemory error.

Re: Do iOS apps crash more than Android?

#14

It really irks me when crashes are made out to be the result of user actions, or some inescapable act of god. Excepting the very rare hardware fault, crashes are caused by a programmer error . PERIOD. That is all that really matters from the user's perspective. There may be some way to work around the bug by tinkering with things, but nothing the user does can ever cause a crash. Also, it wouldn't surprise me if iOS…

[deleted]

Re: Do iOS apps crash more than Android?

#15
post #13

It really irks me when crashes are made out to be the result of user actions, or some inescapable act of god. Excepting the very rare hardware fault, crashes are caused by a programmer error . PERIOD. That is all that really matters from the user's perspective. There may be some way to work around the bug by tinkering with things, but nothing the user does can ever cause a crash. Also, it wouldn't surprise me if iOS…

When an Android app runs of memory it also crashes, with an OutOfMemory error.

So it does.

Though it also has garbage collection, which likely prevents the kind of memory leaks that crash most iOS apps in the first place. And does it let the browser use swap? Because iOS doesn't, so web pages can crash it about as easily as apps can.

Re: Do iOS apps crash more than Android?

#17
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

When an Android app runs of memory it also crashes, with an OutOfMemory error.

So it does. Though it also has garbage collection, which likely prevents the kind of memory leaks that crash most iOS apps in the first place. And does it let the browser use swap? Because iOS doesn't, so web pages can crash it about as easily as apps can.

[deleted]

Re: Do iOS apps crash more than Android?

#19
I suspect that 75% of the crashes on iOS are from poor memory management due to naïve app programmers. Android app developers don't need to worry about memory management, because Java takes care of this automatically. I suspect with iOS-5's new automatic reference counting, iOS crashes will decrease.

Re: Do iOS apps crash more than Android?

#20
post #2

I have almost never had an iOS app crash on me. I get crashes in Android apps almost weekly. I honestly don't know where those guys are getting their data, but I really don't believe it. It's true, it's a lot easier for developers on Android to fix bugs and quickly update their apps because of the lack of an approval process, but that also lowers the bar a great deal on the quality of apps (a lot of which never get u…

You honestly don't believe their data solely because it doesn't match your personal experience? You are just one user after all!

Personally I see crashes on iOS a couple of times a week, and I hardly use third-party apps. Most of my crashes are Safari!

Post reply on HN