Live data from Hacker News

Nude.js: Nudity Detection with JavaScript

davidwalsh.name

31–40 of 48 posts

Re: Nude.js: Nudity Detection with JavaScript

#31
post #27
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What's the cheapest way of getting karma for a brand new account? Making comments requires thought. Finding interesting content is time consuming. But arbitraging Reddit content, that's trivial.

And that's why submitting trash needs to come with a karma penalty.

I assume pg will be the sole arbiter of what constitutes trash?

Re: Nude.js: Nudity Detection with JavaScript

#33

A few years ago, I was in a big box store and overheard a young (~10y/o) child and his mother picking out a new video game. The kid excitedly picked up a box and asked his mom if he could get that one. She checked out the cover, then started reading the rating. "Rated 'mature' for sexual content? No way!" "Aw, man! Ok, how about this one?" "Rated 'mature' for extreme graphic violence? Well... ok."

1. This has nothing to do with the article. 2. I doubt that ever happened. Why would she read aloud the rating? Looks like a post straight from reddit.

1. The article is about an algorithmic way to try to shield people from the horrifying notion of seeing flesh-colored pixels.

My story is about another perverse way in which puritannical culture considers sex taboo, but violence perfectly acceptable.

2. I don't know how to respond to being called a liar outright. It doesn't seem likely that I'd be able to convince you that this happened.

3. I've only been to reddit two or three times and didn't see the value. So I wouldn't be a good judge of that. I take that that's supposed to be derogatory in some way.

4. I'm not sure how you're trying to add to the discussion. I was making a comment on the societal and moral underpinnings and ramifications of the kind of technology described in TFA. If I may make a suggestion: http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html http://www.paulgraham.com/disagree.html

Re: Nude.js: Nudity Detection with JavaScript

#34
post #30

A few years ago, I was in a big box store and overheard a young (~10y/o) child and his mother picking out a new video game. The kid excitedly picked up a box and asked his mom if he could get that one. She checked out the cover, then started reading the rating. "Rated 'mature' for sexual content? No way!" "Aw, man! Ok, how about this one?" "Rated 'mature' for extreme graphic violence? Well... ok."

The violence is fake. The nudity is real.

If you're being serious, I'd love to hear more.

Re: Nude.js: Nudity Detection with JavaScript

#35
post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The violence is fake. The nudity is real.

If you're being serious, I'd love to hear more.

Well I really think that's why it bothers people. If the movie actually had people being beaten up or dismembered etc. I think they would care a lot more. But it's fake, so it doesn't matter.

Re: Nude.js: Nudity Detection with JavaScript

#36
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If you're being serious, I'd love to hear more.

Well I really think that's why it bothers people. If the movie actually had people being beaten up or dismembered etc. I think they would care a lot more. But it's fake, so it doesn't matter.

Interesting theory. I have two points:

1. The anecdote above was re picking out a video game, so I don't think any nudity was real. I can't remember, but I think it was a Grand Theft Auto game.

2. That doesn't really speak to the question of why people are so afraid of nudity.

Re: Nude.js: Nudity Detection with JavaScript

#37
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If you're being serious, I'd love to hear more.

Well I really think that's why it bothers people. If the movie actually had people being beaten up or dismembered etc. I think they would care a lot more. But it's fake, so it doesn't matter.

That can't be the reason, though, as it is highly dependent on the country you live in. It isn't real vs fake, it is about the culture a person is brought up in.

Re: Nude.js: Nudity Detection with JavaScript

#39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

1. This has nothing to do with the article. 2. I doubt that ever happened. Why would she read aloud the rating? Looks like a post straight from reddit.

1. The article is about an algorithmic way to try to shield people from the horrifying notion of seeing flesh-colored pixels. My story is about another perverse way in which puritannical culture considers sex taboo, but violence perfectly acceptable. 2. I don't know how to respond to being called a liar outright. It doesn't seem likely that I'd be able to convince you that this happened. 3. I've only been to reddit t…

I understand the correlation between the story and your comment, but your comment isn't anymore relevant than if I posted a comment praising jQuery and how much better it is than other JavaScript libraries. The question of whether or not you believe sexual nudity being taboo is irrelevant here, this post has nothing to do with the morality of sex vs violence.

As for calling you liar, I apologize. Next time I will just use the flag button. Thanks.

Re: Nude.js: Nudity Detection with JavaScript

#40
post #5

Potential HN karma hack: create new account and post stories from Reddit that haven't already appeared. That's not necessarily what happened here, but I am slightly suspicious.

There was an article a while back on how to cultivate a Twitter following for only ~20 minutes a day. It was basically skimming Reddit in the morning for ~5 relevant links/articles and posting them to Twitter. Eventually you would build up a following of people that found your links relevant to them.
Post reply on HN