Live data from Hacker News

Fide Women’s Grand Prix Collapses into “Chaos” as Players Withdraw

lichess.org

1–10 of 108 posts

Re: Fide Women’s Grand Prix Collapses into “Chaos” as Players Withdraw

#2
Is there a TL;DR, or is this just a complex clusterfuck? I was expecting standard Ukraine vs Russia issues, but the article goes on to describe what looks like a personal vendetta between two top Kazakh players, safety concerns about travel in Delhi, etc etc.

Re: Fide Women’s Grand Prix Collapses into “Chaos” as Players Withdraw

#3

Is there a TL;DR, or is this just a complex clusterfuck? I was expecting standard Ukraine vs Russia issues, but the article goes on to describe what looks like a personal vendetta between two top Kazakh players, safety concerns about travel in Delhi, etc etc.

There is one on r/chess: https://old.reddit.com/r/chess/comments/122wakh/fide_womens_...

Re: Fide Women’s Grand Prix Collapses into “Chaos” as Players Withdraw

#4

Is there a TL;DR, or is this just a complex clusterfuck? I was expecting standard Ukraine vs Russia issues, but the article goes on to describe what looks like a personal vendetta between two top Kazakh players, safety concerns about travel in Delhi, etc etc.

[deleted]

Re: Fide Women’s Grand Prix Collapses into “Chaos” as Players Withdraw

#6
post #3

Is there a TL;DR, or is this just a complex clusterfuck? I was expecting standard Ukraine vs Russia issues, but the article goes on to describe what looks like a personal vendetta between two top Kazakh players, safety concerns about travel in Delhi, etc etc.

There is one on r/chess: https://old.reddit.com/r/chess/comments/122wakh/fide_womens_...

Are these chess tournos usually this dramatic or was this just an atypical combination of geopolitics seeping into sport and other issues gaining purchase out of the sum of the chaos?

Re: Fide Women’s Grand Prix Collapses into “Chaos” as Players Withdraw

#8
post #6
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There is one on r/chess: https://old.reddit.com/r/chess/comments/122wakh/fide_womens_...

Are these chess tournos usually this dramatic or was this just an atypical combination of geopolitics seeping into sport and other issues gaining purchase out of the sum of the chaos?

Chess, like any other highly competitive international sport has a lot of drama.

One of the big problems with it is that white is heavily advantaged, there's a large incentive for incumbents to play for a draw, and playing back-to-back matches is incredibly exhausting. Any attempts at correcting for this can result in an unfair set of rules for someone.

Re: Fide Women’s Grand Prix Collapses into “Chaos” as Players Withdraw

#9
post #7

Hopefully it finishes, so women chess can retain a modicum of reputation

Women’s chess will be fine in any case. FIDE will take a hit.

Doesn't look like FIDE's fault in any of the 4 or 5 withdrawals.

Even if the President apologized to appease them.

Re: Fide Women’s Grand Prix Collapses into “Chaos” as Players Withdraw

#10
post #6
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There is one on r/chess: https://old.reddit.com/r/chess/comments/122wakh/fide_womens_...

Are these chess tournos usually this dramatic or was this just an atypical combination of geopolitics seeping into sport and other issues gaining purchase out of the sum of the chaos?

Definitely not that atypical. Go read about Fischer v. Spassky, for instance.
Post reply on HN