Live data from Hacker News

Little Snitch Mini

obdev.at

71–80 of 276 posts

Re: Little Snitch Mini

#71
post #66
post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Price seems fair, honestly. The full blown app is like $70, plus upgrades when those come.

I’d gladly pay 70$ for this, for myself and maybe a couple of friends, if it were a one-time purchase. As a subscription, I just closed the page. Several apps on the Mac App Store have both subscription and lifetime pricing. I’ve bought several.

The non-Mini version of Little Snitch is a one-time purchase.

Re: Little Snitch Mini

#73
I bought Little Snitch long ago but managed to squander my license a couple of years later. Mini is unfortunately a subscription app, which is something I these days consider a hostile/unfriendly business pattern. I won't be going back. LuLu is a free alternative.

Re: Little Snitch Mini

#74
post #59
post #46

I would happily pay $20 or $30 for a version of this, but I will absolutely not pay a subscription fee for extra features. I have too many subscriptions... I want to support this developer but not this way. Uninstalling :(

It's so cheap, why do you care?

It's sort of unfriendly to corner customers into having to buy the application over and over each year.

Re: Little Snitch Mini

#75
post #71
post #66

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I’d gladly pay 70$ for this, for myself and maybe a couple of friends, if it were a one-time purchase. As a subscription, I just closed the page. Several apps on the Mac App Store have both subscription and lifetime pricing. I’ve bought several.

The non-Mini version of Little Snitch is a one-time purchase.

The non-Mini version was such a hassle to maintain¹ that I stopped using it². This looked like a great middle ground, until the subscription part.

¹ I don’t want to become a networking expert and babysit everything. I already practice good security regarding what I install and run, I just want a little more control.

² And if it was a bother for me, there’s zero chance any of my non-technical friends would last an hour.

Re: Little Snitch Mini

#76
post #32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Completely agree. Occasionally I run Charles Proxy[1] on my iPhone to analyze network activity and am disturbed by what I see. Software shouldn't be able to open arbitrary network connections without user consent/control, but we're not there yet to a large enough degree on mobile unfortunately. [1] https://www.charlesproxy.com/documentation/ios/

The reality is that this sort of control would only be attractive to a very very small fraction of users, and no, not just because ‘people don’t care about privacy’ or whatever. There are just very few situations where someone is going to be able to look at this sort of data and do anything meaningful with it, especially when a) most apps are justifiably internet-connected, and b) the homogeneity of public cloud infr…

[deleted]

Re: Little Snitch Mini

#77

I bought Little Snitch long ago but managed to squander my license a couple of years later. Mini is unfortunately a subscription app, which is something I these days consider a hostile/unfriendly business pattern. I won't be going back. LuLu is a free alternative.

Using LuLu for so long I actually forgot that I have it running! +1 for LuLu.

Re: Little Snitch Mini

#78
post #46

I would happily pay $20 or $30 for a version of this, but I will absolutely not pay a subscription fee for extra features. I have too many subscriptions... I want to support this developer but not this way. Uninstalling :(

It's surreal, to pay for the internet on a monthly basis, ...

and then pay for parts of your computer to NOT talk to the internet on a monthly basis!

Re: Little Snitch Mini

#79

I bought Little Snitch long ago but managed to squander my license a couple of years later. Mini is unfortunately a subscription app, which is something I these days consider a hostile/unfriendly business pattern. I won't be going back. LuLu is a free alternative.

I generally agree with you so I looked it up.

  In-App Purchases:

    Yearly Subscription $13.49
    Monthly Subscription $1.49
That's surprisingly modest. 3-4 years of subscription approximately being equal to a license sounds reasonable.

The real question is, is little snitch rent seeking? Given what happened after Catalina, I am giving them the benefit of the doubt at the moment. Paying for updates before receiving them definitely creates a conflict of interest.

Having looked at their website and seeing SKU-ification (Cutting a product different ways to try to hit different price points) and other business over product decisions, I am definitely feeling shaky about the future of little snitch. SKU-ification is 10x the red flag that a subscription model is.

It's worth considering that viruses now days will check and see if programs like this are running and then delete themselves rather than execute the payload.

Re: Little Snitch Mini

#80
post #59
post #46

I would happily pay $20 or $30 for a version of this, but I will absolutely not pay a subscription fee for extra features. I have too many subscriptions... I want to support this developer but not this way. Uninstalling :(

It's so cheap, why do you care?

Subscriptions add up. And there’s no guarantee they won’t jack up the price at the most inconvenient time and leave you hanging (LastPass, for example, has done that). For users, a subscription mean loss of control.
Post reply on HN