Live data from Hacker News

Little Snitch Mini

obdev.at

31–40 of 276 posts

Re: Little Snitch Mini

#31
post #8

How is this different from the traditional version of Little Snitch?

They have a comparison page: https://obdev.at/products/littlesnitch-mini/compare.html

It's remarkably difficult to compare the two with how they describe them in totally different ways.

It really makes my wish they had one of those side-by-side charts that tells you which features are in what.

Re: Little Snitch Mini

#32
post #29
post #10

People are probably going to be confused between this and the "full" version of Little Snitch. My take on it is that Little Snitch Mini is something you can install on a non-technical friend or family member's computer whereas power users may want to stick with the existing offering. I say this as a long time heavy user of Little Snitch. It's very annoying when you first get it installed, but it provides really usefu…

I've always thought this should be a feature in an OS for advanced users. Combined with some OS level security optimizations it could be quite a powerful security feature for the paranoid and at-risk. I haven't tried mini but there's probably plenty of UX gains in between the standard Little Snitch fine control approach and the UBlock Origin style community curated defaults where control/customization is optional/on-…

Completely agree. Occasionally I run Charles Proxy[1] on my iPhone to analyze network activity and am disturbed by what I see. Software shouldn't be able to open arbitrary network connections without user consent/control, but we're not there yet to a large enough degree on mobile unfortunately.

[1] https://www.charlesproxy.com/documentation/ios/

Re: Little Snitch Mini

#33
post #18
post #14

Is there a Little Snitch alternative for Windows?

simplewall[0] is my #1 install on a new machine. Little different, but it'll still alert you to the requests, allow for timers, per application/route rules etc. [0]: https://github.com/henrypp/simplewall

Can recommend simplewall - only only is it free, it's completely opensource. Works wonderfully - highly recommended.

Re: Little Snitch Mini

#34
I use LS. Mini wouldn't work for me at work or home. It's probably targeted and useful for non-developer users.

I also use Objective See's LuLu, OverSight, ReiKey, and RansomWhere.

https://objective-see.org

LuLu + LS makes any app using telemetry shriekingly obvious and selectively denyable.

Work additionally deploys YARA, MS MDE, Malware Bytes, and an MDM. There are other internal tools for password projection, DLP (anti-exfil), and pre-execution binary allow/denylisting.

Re: Little Snitch Mini

#35
So, from a user's viewpoint, if your app talks to blah.serv.direct.data.com how do you know whether it actually needs that server for its main functionality or not?

I don't see how this snitch tool will not just generate a lot of noise.

Re: Little Snitch Mini

#36
Smart move to go for the more casual user, it suggests Obdev has been doing their homework and proactively talking to regular users, rather than just blindly building feature requests. Tools like this so often get sucked into serving the loud minority of expert users with ever more esoteric use cases, which leads to a death spiral of audience capture where the tool gets more and more complicated and harder to approach for casuals.

Little Snitch Mini looks great, I'm going to recommend it to friends!

Re: Little Snitch Mini

#38
Not liking the direction Apple took with OS X user interfaces and stuff in the later years, I generally stuck with Mojave on my macs. I wish I could try this without upgrading to ah, what was it, Monterey? but alas, alas.

Re: Little Snitch Mini

#39
Why does factorio literally perform better on my laptop than websites like these?

Is this just firefox on linux being bad at hardware rendering? Is it some crappy API people are forced to use to do these animations? I don't get it.

Re: Little Snitch Mini

#40
post #35

So, from a user's viewpoint, if your app talks to blah.serv.direct.data.com how do you know whether it actually needs that server for its main functionality or not? I don't see how this snitch tool will not just generate a lot of noise.

Block the request and see what breaks.
Post reply on HN