Live data from Hacker News

American colleges in crisis with enrollment decline largest on record

fortune.com

91–100 of 102 posts

Re: American colleges in crisis with enrollment decline largest on record

#91

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It hurts me to read this. Because actually learning is inherently fun, or used to be. Why do kids have fun playing? Because they learn this way. Playing is learning. Or it used to, until the philosophy settled in, that playing is meant for wasting time (and you surely can waste time playing as most modern games are made for time killing) and learning has to be intentionally hard. The most effective way to learn new t…

> The most effective way to learn new things for me, is still to play around with them. Whether it is compilers or a new graphical framework. Compilers and UI APIs are easy to learn. I did it too. Education is the problem of teaching people much harder things. > It hurts me to read this Hey man, look, I was a great student and graduated from a good college with a 4.0 GPA with a math and CS degree, and now I've made a…

[deleted]

Re: American colleges in crisis with enrollment decline largest on record

#92

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It hurts me to read this. Because actually learning is inherently fun, or used to be. Why do kids have fun playing? Because they learn this way. Playing is learning. Or it used to, until the philosophy settled in, that playing is meant for wasting time (and you surely can waste time playing as most modern games are made for time killing) and learning has to be intentionally hard. The most effective way to learn new t…

> The most effective way to learn new things for me, is still to play around with them. Whether it is compilers or a new graphical framework. Compilers and UI APIs are easy to learn. I did it too. Education is the problem of teaching people much harder things. > It hurts me to read this Hey man, look, I was a great student and graduated from a good college with a 4.0 GPA with a math and CS degree, and now I've made a…

> Play-based learning is a fad designed to satisfy liberal white women.

After more research about the history of alternative education, I don't think this was accurate. I feel bad for resorting to stereotype.

"Liberal" is absolutely correct here, see https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alternative_education

"White" is iffy. In my experience in the U.S., thinking about alternative education is a luxury that only some can afford to do. Therefore, it is an issue of affluence.

"Women" was out of line. This is not an issue of gender, not role, and I think it was harmful to reinforce certain traditional roles here.

I lied about my GPA btw, it was around 3.8. Math is hard. And I only went to a mid-tier state school. It was only "good" in that I enjoyed it and learned a lot. It was difficult for me to find a job even in the bull market of 2009-2020. But even though my personal outcome wasn't completely ideal, I still believe in the value of structured education with its grades, sorting, ranking, etc. because, at its best, it drives you to separate the learning from the intrinsic reward (which is necessary to learn the boring things you need to), and to simply be accountable for yourself. I don't think another human (besides Thoreau), or play, can provide that;

these lessons must come from the heartless industrial machine.

Re: American colleges in crisis with enrollment decline largest on record

#93

The admin bloat ought to be cut in order to qualify for federal student loans. I'm always baffled how much tuition was at my public university, yet teacher and TA salaries are so low. It's like everything except academics attached itself to drain money from students

If the top executives of the university aren't making 10s of millions of dollars, then it can't be a very good university. We should pay them more, much more, as its the only way to improve post-secondary education. There should only be a single tenured faculty position and every one else is an adjunct or post-doc who gets paid $500 to teach a course. These adjuncts and post-docs have to work very hard for decades fo…

that works for companies too! Imagine how much better run they are now than in the '60s when CEOs only got 12x worker salaries.

/s

Re: American colleges in crisis with enrollment decline largest on record

#94

I remember from some video on youtube that colleges in US used to be cheaper because government gave a lot of money to subsidise education. It stopped when government figured out that it was essentially paying to create citizens with progressive ideas and critical thought. There may be a lot of things wrong with colleges but they are essential and should be saved.

[deleted]

Re: American colleges in crisis with enrollment decline largest on record

#95

I remember from some video on youtube that colleges in US used to be cheaper because government gave a lot of money to subsidise education. It stopped when government figured out that it was essentially paying to create citizens with progressive ideas and critical thought. There may be a lot of things wrong with colleges but they are essential and should be saved.

>” It stopped when government figured out that it was essentially paying to create citizens with progressive ideas and critical thought.” I have no idea what that video is basing this on. The government continues to substantially subsidize college education through guaranteed loans, Pell grants, tax breaks, and research grants. And, colleges/universities had a reputation for “progressive ideas” since the 1960’s and i…

I'm not able to find the video, but here's what was discussed in it

https://theintercept.com/2022/08/25/student-loans-debt-reaga...

“We are in danger of producing an educated proletariat. That’s dynamite! We have to be selective on who we allow to go through higher education.” -- 1970, Roger Freeman, a Hoover Institution economist and a key educational adviser to Nixon

https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ684842.pdf

Once elected, Mr. Reagan set the educational tone for his administration by

• calling for an end to free tuition for state college and university students

• annually demanding 20 percent across-the-board cuts in higher education funding

• repeatedly slashing construction funds for state campuses

• engineering the firing of Clark Kerr, the highly respected president of the University of California

• declaring that the state “should not subsidize intellectual curiosity"

Reagan also tried to end department of education

https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1985-01-29-mn-13948-...

Re: American colleges in crisis with enrollment decline largest on record

#96

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Interesting how this only goes one way. Would it have the same effect if at a sorority there was a sign that read "Thank you for your sons"?

What percentage of men vs women get raped? These what-ifs are so fucking odious because they’re completely divorced from what actually happens in the real world.

Should certain crimes be taken less seriously based on who it happens to more often?

The problem with the rape of men is it's never taken seriously or seen as a non-issue because women are raped more often, case in point: your comment

Re: American colleges in crisis with enrollment decline largest on record

#97
post #49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Absolutely not true. Try being a proponent of israel at Berkeley. No healthy debate is possible.

I imagine it's eerily similar to being a proponent of Apartheid south Africa at Berkeley in 1982.

Yes it is.

If you are a Jew you are killed on site in Gaza and the West Bank. Palestinians are not allowed to sell their homes to Jews. They target Jewish children and teach their children to hate Jews.

OTOH Israel has 2.5M Palestinians living in peace with equal rights, including voting rights.

Yet the whole world watches and is outraged that Israel defends its citizens.

Re: American colleges in crisis with enrollment decline largest on record

#98
post #54

This works for now, but what happens next recession when all those degree requirements return? This isn't meant as judgemental, but people only employable due to the labour shortage and only accepted into their field due to the labour shortage are also the people who will struggle most come a lack of a labour shortage.

Those who have work experience usually skip degree requirements.

In some companies. Then there are others...

I know someone who has been acting as her boss's replacement since her boss left the company. But the company refuses to promote her into that job because she doesn't have a degree. 20 years of employment with the company, plus demonstrated ability by actively doing the boss's job, doesn't count as much as an old piece of paper.

To emphasize: This company has a degree requirement not just for hiring inexperienced candidates (of unknown quality), but also for promoting experienced employees (of known quality). Stupidest thing I've ever seen.

Re: American colleges in crisis with enrollment decline largest on record

#99
post #54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Those who have work experience usually skip degree requirements.

In some companies. Then there are others... I know someone who has been acting as her boss's replacement since her boss left the company. But the company refuses to promote her into that job because she doesn't have a degree. 20 years of employment with the company, plus demonstrated ability by actively doing the boss's job, doesn't count as much as an old piece of paper. To emphasize: This company has a degree requi…

Natural selection applies to companies too.

Re: American colleges in crisis with enrollment decline largest on record

#100

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I hope so. You can learn from youtube same as a professors lecturing.

Most people cannot. Not only are retention and learning radically different, the vast majority of people do not have the self discipline to go through the same amount of content. If a class isn't something you're immediately interested in and no one's forcing you to go, most people end up abandoning or skipping it. Watching only the fun parts or only the parts that seem to you to be immediately relevant to your curre…

Most people can’t even do what you are proposing. They just load up before a test and dump it afterwards because they haven’t created any sustainable system for remembering it past their exam.
Post reply on HN