Live data from Hacker News

New React docs pretend SPAs don't exist anymore

wasp-lang.dev

71–80 of 225 posts

Re: New React docs pretend SPAs don't exist anymore

#71
post #32

This comment thread is a little funny because every single HN thread outside of this one rants super aggressively about webpages that don't show any content before JS loads, but this thread has managed to collect the opposite group together for once because React's docs have updated to stop actively recommending tools that force that problem to happen.

This is the most interesting observation here

Re: New React docs pretend SPAs don't exist anymore

#72
post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why do I hear so much about htmx and so little about unpolly, which seems everything htmx promise but with additional high level primitives for the common task?

Unpoly dev is german nobody cares about abd doesnt go on podcasts vs htmx author is american that does marketing well. Same goes for alpine js where the author is “famous” dev. Pretty typical with open source projects tbh. Many of them win thanks to marketing more than anything else.

Also Htmx got picked up early by the Django community

Re: New React docs pretend SPAs don't exist anymore

#73
Integrating React into an MPA is quite awkward, surprised this is the target audience for it.

I love the potential of web development but of recent, it's been infected by hype-marketing and blog-engineering.

I get that it's become very accessible to write web applications and that's good for the growth of the platform - but it almost feels like this accessibility has led it to squander its potential in pursuit of unsophisticated and unambitious objectives.

Web developers today are distracted by premature over-optimisations (ignoring effective low effort optimisations) and language+platform features that are a great, but kinda useless from a project development standpoint (time/money/complexity/collaborative capacity cost).

As a result, platform developers are distracted implementing features that don't innovate the platform - so we sit and wait for the truly groundbreaking things that never come because we gotta discuss the pipe operator, or adding types to the JavaScript language specification.

Meanwhile projects that can't wait for the platform to evolve flood us with Electron apps that everyone hate.

I have hope, kinda...

Re: New React docs pretend SPAs don't exist anymore

#74
sveltekit is the same, ssr first, i am so sad react now becomes ssr first too, i am forced back to vue,which still has a CSR SPA first, add ssr if you need it approach.

no i dont need ssr at all, internal tools,dashboards,embedded devices,etc etc have nothing to do with ssr,nothing at all

Re: New React docs pretend SPAs don't exist anymore

#78
Obligatory "front end is a mess" comment. I taught at a bootcamp for 6 months, it was a great experience but when we moved on to react after vanilla JS the amount of incidental complexity was a huge step up, even with create-react-app. Now they push people towards adding a server side framework at the same time, right off the bat? I think there's a real danger with new engineers entering the industry that they have no chance to develop a proper mental model of the underlying tech stack the way so many libraries, frameworks, packages, bundlers are thrown together just to get something working. You think the docs should just start with using plain React, and then branch off in to SPA Vs SSR later.

Re: New React docs pretend SPAs don't exist anymore

#79
post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why do I hear so much about htmx and so little about unpolly, which seems everything htmx promise but with additional high level primitives for the common task?

Unpoly dev is german nobody cares about abd doesnt go on podcasts vs htmx author is american that does marketing well. Same goes for alpine js where the author is “famous” dev. Pretty typical with open source projects tbh. Many of them win thanks to marketing more than anything else.

Don't why you have been downvoted, while there are famous dev outside of the US, american identity and marketting does sell better than the german one.

Re: New React docs pretend SPAs don't exist anymore

#80

So after graphql, micro services, nosql and serverless, the SPA + "libs not framework" crowd join the "woooops!" club. Ignoring the noise is really becoming a key skill to survive as a programmer.

Honestly, the signal is just to avoid whatever full-time JS developers are getting into.
Post reply on HN