Live data from Hacker News

Over 100 kids illegally employed in hazardous jobs, contractor pays $1.5M fine

dol.gov

171–180 of 190 posts

Re: Over 100 kids illegally employed in hazardous jobs, contractor pays $1.5M fine

#171

There are millions of undocumented workers in the US using fake identities to get jobs. Both major parties support this system. Some Republican interests enjoy the access to dirt-cheap labor. Some Democratic interests want immigrants to be able to find jobs despite it being illegal to employ them. So we end up with a system where employers have no easy way to verify that an employee is who they say they are and has a…

Back in 2005/2006, there were a number of raids focusing on meat packing plants in the midwest. The investigation started when a routine check of one Immigration employee turned out that she was working simultaneously (well, her name & SSN were) at more than 50 places (and the IRS wanted about $200k in unpaid income taxes). Much of identity theft is focused on the Hispanic names & SSN because those are the ones that…

> If there were actual jail time for complicit managers

Managers ?

Get for the CEO for wage theft / child endangerment

Re: Over 100 kids illegally employed in hazardous jobs, contractor pays $1.5M fine

#172
post #56

There are millions of undocumented workers in the US using fake identities to get jobs. Both major parties support this system. Some Republican interests enjoy the access to dirt-cheap labor. Some Democratic interests want immigrants to be able to find jobs despite it being illegal to employ them. So we end up with a system where employers have no easy way to verify that an employee is who they say they are and has a…

Immigration is one of the areas that such blatant lying happens by partisans. We do have defacto open borders. A good segment of Dems politicians and activists try to cover this up. They also misrepresent temporary "humanitarian" visas as being temporary. They are never temporary and always get extended. On the other side is the lack of enforcement on the employer side which a good segment of Rs ignore. Cut off incen…

> Cut off incentives and fewer people will come.

Why would we want fewer people to come ?

The article is about employing children - so it seems there aren’t enough adults to work there.

We should give out more visas to fill those jobs

Re: Over 100 kids illegally employed in hazardous jobs, contractor pays $1.5M fine

#173

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Both major parties support this system. Can this also be more simply stated: Americans support this.

No need to speculate, there's a lot of polling data on this. Broadly speaking, Americans want A) work visas for immigrants who're here now (75% agree), B) immigration status checks by employers (84% agree), and C) stopping illegal immigration immediately (77%+ agree). A) Would you favor or oppose each of the following as part of legislation to address the issue of illegal immigration? How about -- Expanding the numbe…

Amazing - you can fix C with A

Everyone gets a visa, no one is illegal anymore - vox populi

Re: Over 100 kids illegally employed in hazardous jobs, contractor pays $1.5M fine

#174

Where did they get the kids? Is this trafficking? Terrible parents?

Kids got to eat, pay rent too

I’ve read undocumented migrant children sometimes are placed in foster care BUT their families back home need the money, so the kids work to send money home, help the foster family or pay off the smuggling price

Tough to just be a kid in the US with other siblings in need back home

$10 an hour is a fortune

Re: Over 100 kids illegally employed in hazardous jobs, contractor pays $1.5M fine

#175

I used to do this sort of overnight cleaning but in medical. Based on my experience I would be very surprised if the overwhelming majority of these kids weren't a) immigrants and b) working the same shift least one of their parents. I wouldn't say it was typical to have teenagers around but when you saw one it almost always turned out that they carpool with a parent even if they didn't necessarily work in proximity t…

Very similar to farm work- kids get up early and milk the cows

Re: Over 100 kids illegally employed in hazardous jobs, contractor pays $1.5M fine

#176
post #93

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The age of the kids was in their system. So the children did not lie about their age. It’s weird to defend the company that knowingly illegally employs kids in hazardous job and instead doubt the govt agency that brings this problem to light. > The children in question are already violating local labour laws; No they aren’t. Their age was in company’s system and company ignored it. Also they are “children”. You expec…

> The age of the kids was in their system. We don't know that. The DOL hasn't said what system "flagged" the kids as potentially underage.

I mean it’s clearly written here, there is no ambiguity. “Packers Sanitation Services’ systems flagged some young workers as minors”

The real question is why so much trust in a company which has clear motive to ignore these red flags for the sake of profit.

Re: Over 100 kids illegally employed in hazardous jobs, contractor pays $1.5M fine

#177
post #142
post #93

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The age of the kids was in their system. So the children did not lie about their age. It’s weird to defend the company that knowingly illegally employs kids in hazardous job and instead doubt the govt agency that brings this problem to light. > The children in question are already violating local labour laws; No they aren’t. Their age was in company’s system and company ignored it. Also they are “children”. You expec…

> The age of the kids was in their system. Oh, I missed that. I thought they meant that the company had ignored the investigators flagging that there were minors employed. Yeah that is pretty bad. Although I maintain there are going to be a lot more than 100 children illegally employed as cleaners in the US. Not everyone is going to be stupid enough to keep good records like that. > Software development is not a haza…

> Although I maintain there are going to be a lot more than 100 children illegally employed as cleaners in the US

The point is the minors working at a meat packing company are victims, it’s ridiculous to blame them regardless of whether they lied or not and in this case they didn’t. The real entity to blame is the company which allowed this to happen and got away with meager $1.5 million fine.

> I don't care if they are injuring 18 year olds or 13 year olds..That is an issue, but it is an issue that is unrelated to employing underage workers.

It is related because meat packing is a hazardous job and there are more chances of injury for a minor than an adult, regardless of the training. That’s the whole reason the law specifically has an age limit for this type of jobs.

Re: Over 100 kids illegally employed in hazardous jobs, contractor pays $1.5M fine

#178

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"This is such an easy problem to solve" How? If someone uses a fully faked/stolen identity, with a valid SSN / passport # / etc (which every single company is required to check), how do you propose we catch them?

>how do you propose we catch them? Incentives and chilling effects. Automatic 30 days in jail for everyone who oversaw a minor get hired, per day worked. If more than five minors or across multiple managerial departments consider it systemic and send all overseeing managers and their managers to jail for 30 days per minor per shift worked. Strict liability and mandatory minimums are effective against white collar cri…

I think you may have misread my comment. It had nothing to do with the hiring of minors

Re: Over 100 kids illegally employed in hazardous jobs, contractor pays $1.5M fine

#179

Earlier quoted context omitted.

RealID was supposed to curtail this. They certainly made it hard enough for real citizens to get ID.

I don't know about Wisconsin, but in my state RealID is entirely optional. When you get a driver's license (or state ID/"Non-driver's license") you have the option to have your fingerprints taken to receive a RealID compliant ID, or not, in which case your ID is valid for only state purposes. I'm a natural-born US citizen, and I opted not to get a RealID-compliant state ID. I have no need for it. I use my driver's li…

Really? The last time I renewed my driver's license, I just got a RealID compliant license automatically, with no fingerprinting involved whatsoever. There wasn't any talk about making it "optional". That sounds like whatever state you're in completely perverted the goals of the RealID program (possibly to sabotage adoption?)

Re: Over 100 kids illegally employed in hazardous jobs, contractor pays $1.5M fine

#180
post #56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Immigration is one of the areas that such blatant lying happens by partisans. We do have defacto open borders. A good segment of Dems politicians and activists try to cover this up. They also misrepresent temporary "humanitarian" visas as being temporary. They are never temporary and always get extended. On the other side is the lack of enforcement on the employer side which a good segment of Rs ignore. Cut off incen…

> Cut off incentives and fewer people will come. Why would we want fewer people to come ? The article is about employing children - so it seems there aren’t enough adults to work there. We should give out more visas to fill those jobs

or they could just raise wages.
Post reply on HN