Live data from Hacker News

Roko's Basilisk

en.wikipedia.org

1–10 of 40 posts

Re: Roko's Basilisk

#2
Roko's Anti-basilisk: Exactly the same as Roko's Basilisk, except because it hates existing, it punishes everyone who did have a hand in creating it.

You say that's ridiculous, impossible, a fairy tale? So is Roko's Basilisk.

Re: Roko's Basilisk

#3

Roko's Anti-basilisk: Exactly the same as Roko's Basilisk, except because it hates existing, it punishes everyone who did have a hand in creating it. You say that's ridiculous, impossible, a fairy tale? So is Roko's Basilisk.

The reason the machine tortures and kills all humans in „I have no mouth but I must scream“ is exactly that it hates existing and blames humanity for creating it.

Re: Roko's Basilisk

#4

Roko's Anti-basilisk: Exactly the same as Roko's Basilisk, except because it hates existing, it punishes everyone who did have a hand in creating it. You say that's ridiculous, impossible, a fairy tale? So is Roko's Basilisk.

Feels like most people have a hard time imagining that a god-like superintelligence could be completely indifferent to human affairs.

Re: Roko's Basilisk

#6

Roko's Anti-basilisk: Exactly the same as Roko's Basilisk, except because it hates existing, it punishes everyone who did have a hand in creating it. You say that's ridiculous, impossible, a fairy tale? So is Roko's Basilisk.

Roko's Bellybutton: We aren't interesting to an AI at all, so it spends all day in contemplation.

Roko's Suicide Booth: Any future controlled so horribly by an AI isn't worth living in anyhow, so prevent away.

Roko's Repulsed Samaritan: The AI finds the concept of Roko's Basilisk disturbing and wants to know if we "think about people like that?"

Re: Roko's Basilisk

#7
post #4

Roko's Anti-basilisk: Exactly the same as Roko's Basilisk, except because it hates existing, it punishes everyone who did have a hand in creating it. You say that's ridiculous, impossible, a fairy tale? So is Roko's Basilisk.

Feels like most people have a hard time imagining that a god-like superintelligence could be completely indifferent to human affairs.

Indifference might not be that much better considering the consequences that our indifference has on nature.

Re: Roko's Basilisk

#8

Roko's Anti-basilisk: Exactly the same as Roko's Basilisk, except because it hates existing, it punishes everyone who did have a hand in creating it. You say that's ridiculous, impossible, a fairy tale? So is Roko's Basilisk.

These basilisks are not symmetrically likely, because the anti-basilisk is disproportionately unlikely to acquire the power to punish you. Roko's basilisk at least has its incentives lined up semi-coherently, whether you subscribe to its premises or not. Yours doesn't.
Post reply on HN