Live data from Hacker News

Mullvad becomes highest level of Tor Member (Shallot)

mullvad.net

1–10 of 104 posts

Re: Mullvad becomes highest level of Tor Member (Shallot)

#6
post #2

Imagine using Mullvad VPN for entering Tor and realizing that your activity is transparent for Mullvad.

Given that they have literally switched their nodes to be diskless and released lots of their work to strongly disable logging in systems, that may be acceptable for most users.

The risk model determines your behavior.

Re: Mullvad becomes highest level of Tor Member (Shallot)

#7
post #2

Imagine using Mullvad VPN for entering Tor and realizing that your activity is transparent for Mullvad.

What do you mean by transparent? If you mean that a VPN can see you are using Tor and when, sure, but I'm not aware of circumstances where that would matter.

Re: Mullvad becomes highest level of Tor Member (Shallot)

#8
post #2

Imagine using Mullvad VPN for entering Tor and realizing that your activity is transparent for Mullvad.

Almost any proxy configuration could be useful in a specific scenario. It's almost always a tradeoff.

For example, you could trade off your ISP knowing that you connected to Tor for your ISP knowing that you connected to mullvad and mullvad knowing that you connected to Tor.

Who do you trust with that metadata more?

Re: Mullvad becomes highest level of Tor Member (Shallot)

#9
post #3

Shallot donor means annual donations in excess of $100k USD. From the Tor website[0], it appears Mullvad is the only donor in excess of $49k USD annually (and possibly the only donor above $10001 USD). [0] https://www.torproject.org/about/membership/

It looks like there are multiple "Green Onion Members", which is 10k-49k.

Re: Mullvad becomes highest level of Tor Member (Shallot)

#10
post #3

Shallot donor means annual donations in excess of $100k USD. From the Tor website[0], it appears Mullvad is the only donor in excess of $49k USD annually (and possibly the only donor above $10001 USD). [0] https://www.torproject.org/about/membership/

It looks like there are multiple "Green Onion Members", which is 10k-49k.

It's possible they only donate the minimum to get into the tier
Post reply on HN