Live data from Hacker News

Facebook LLAMA is being openly distributed via torrents

github.com

251–260 of 719 posts

Re: Facebook LLAMA is being openly distributed via torrents

#251
post #164
post #93

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For anyone curious, it took 2048 A100 GPUs to train LLaMa, each GPU costs roughly $15k, facebook probably gets some sort of discount. That's a $30Mil if you want to train at that scale. Also IIRC it took 23 days to train the biggest model. Someone else can do the power consumption cost calculations.

Electricity costs are basically irrelevant because the cards are so expensive. A100 cards consume 250w each, with datacenter overheads we will call it 1000 kilowatts for all 2048 cards. 23 days is 552 hours, or 552,000 kilowatt hours total. Most dataceneters are between 7 and 10 cents per kilowatt hour for electricity. Some are below 4. At 10 cents, that's $53,000 in electricity costs, which is nothing next to $30 mi…

The comparison would be renting, not buying the GPUs

I believe capex opex is more 1:1 nowadays, so something feels off here...

Re: Facebook LLAMA is being openly distributed via torrents

#252
Maybe this is an intentional leak to damage OpenAI.

A supposedly better model by some accounts that strikes right at the heart of their business plan of selling access for $250k/year. One month of access to their service could buy a machine capable of running this leaked model.

Facebook nerfs a potential upstart competitor to keep current big-tech cartel stable.

Maybe this is a bit conspiratorial, but we live in the age big-tech and big-conspiracy.

Re: Facebook LLAMA is being openly distributed via torrents

#253
post #57

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hell, I'd love to be able to buy a $30k server to run these models. I think to run BLOOM required something more along the lines of a $200k server.

True, and that's why there is a project that is using volunteered, distributed GPUs to run BLOOM/BLOOMZ: https://github.com/bigscience-workshop/petals , http://chat.petals.ml .

I've tried this but compared to ChatGPT... let's just say it's in a different league.

Re: Facebook LLAMA is being openly distributed via torrents

#254

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I posit to a friend that: a) As these AI constructs become more advanced (especially around memory and personalization), we will eventually be able to treat them as people b) Some business will eventually sell an off-the-shelf product (hardware and/or software) that is an AI you can bring into your home, that you can treat as a friend, confidant and partner c) Someone will eventually lose their AI friend of many mont…

This is pretty much the premise of the movie "Her".

The upgrade killed "Her" in the movie. lol

Re: Facebook LLAMA is being openly distributed via torrents

#255

FWIW this information was already freely available via DHT scrapers like btdig [1] I think everyone at Facebook knows that torrents aren't secret and the Google form is basically a legal tool to shield them from liability while making litigation against anyone misusing the model easier. [1]: https://btdig.com/b8287ebfa04f879b048d4d4404108cf3e8014352/l...

Note that this is the leaked copy, not the original -- see 'llama.sh'.

Re: Facebook LLAMA is being openly distributed via torrents

#257

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The original 4chan thread seems to indicate that the leaker verified that his hashes matched with another person who had access to the weights, to make sure that the weights aren't watermarked [0] 0: https://boards.4channel.org/g/thread/91848262#p91849855

The leaker accidentally doxxed themselves by adding the original download script to the torrent: https://boards.4channel.org/g/thread/91848262#p91850503

knowing those guys, that could very well be planted as a practical joke on a friend of theirs :P

Re: Facebook LLAMA is being openly distributed via torrents

#258
post #41

It’s interesting that these models are both massively expensive to produce and self-contained to a degree that you can distribute the end product in a torrent. This has not been the case for most commercial software for the past 20 years, during the cloud era. If you could steal a dump of random Facebook source code, it would be 99% useless because it’s so closely tied to the infrastructure. There’s almost nothing yo…

Is the current model capable of updating itself? Or will the user be fed answers from a static model that never learns anything new?

Re: Facebook LLAMA is being openly distributed via torrents

#259
post #53
post #50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

But ML models generally can execute arbitrary code Is it the case if we're only talking about weights? I thought the rest is actually "open".

My understanding is that weights are normally stored as pickled python blobs, which means arbitrary code execution as they are unpickled.

You're right! You should probably use Trail of Bits Fickling tool to investigate. https://github.com/trailofbits/fickling

Re: Facebook LLAMA is being openly distributed via torrents

#260

I'm not surprised-- I recently suggested that someone might try to pull an Aaron Swartz with the LLAMA weights (i.e., release them in an uncontrolled way similar to how Aaron attempted to release the JSTOR database). It's quite misleading for FB to claim that they are being so open, but then hoard the weights and only release it to a few academics. If the paper is to be believed, this is a major development, allowing…

Probably done with meta's blessing. Pretty obvious the scientists wanted to release it and legal stopped them.
Post reply on HN