Live data from Hacker News

I Changed My Mind on Social Media and Teen Depression

richardhanania.substack.com

21–30 of 34 posts

Re: I Changed My Mind on Social Media and Teen Depression

#21
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Is there more context to share?

Yes, read the other talking points this applause cow for conservative viewpoints is peddling. It has nothing to do with thinking for himself and everything with jumping the bandwagon.

As someone not familiar, I'm just getting a sense of ad hominem. I didn't think 'social media = bad' was a conservative view as all my peers (a good mix across the political spectrum) are mostly in agreement that social media sucks.

Re: I Changed My Mind on Social Media and Teen Depression

#22

> A final reason I didn’t want to believe in the social media hypothesis was that I’d much rather blame wokeness … it’s annoying to me that intellectuals won’t even consider the possibility that radical new ideas about race and sex might be to blame, and the fact that the most liberal demographics, that is women and LGBT adolescents, are having the most mental problems indicates that there is something to the theory…

“I want to believe something is true so therefore it is true”. I actually respect the honesty here. Most people think this way but would never admit it.

“Cogito ergo est”

Re: I Changed My Mind on Social Media and Teen Depression

#23

> A final reason I didn’t want to believe in the social media hypothesis was that I’d much rather blame wokeness … it’s annoying to me that intellectuals won’t even consider the possibility that radical new ideas about race and sex might be to blame, and the fact that the most liberal demographics, that is women and LGBT adolescents, are having the most mental problems indicates that there is something to the theory…

I see woke as tolerance, open to each other and acceptance. Yes it's over done sometimes but it's hard to see how he would connect wokeness with depression. Or does people understand under wokeness something different than I do? Like great that black kids get heroes in cinema!

I see woke as being viscerally intolerant not only of differing opinions, but also of the people who have them.

Re: I Changed My Mind on Social Media and Teen Depression

#25
post #9

No one cares about middle aged people. They are also depressed

Come on now. That's like screaming "white lives matter too!" at a black lives matter protest.

No one is arguing that depression is great for older people or for men, just because they are taking a focused look on what might cause a sharp rise in the rate of depression of young females.

Re: I Changed My Mind on Social Media and Teen Depression

#26
I think there's ample lived experience showing that larger groups of adolescent human beings can be hateful towards people who are different in any way.

In the past, young people were unable to escape this while at school, but once the school day was over they at least had a reprieve until the next school day.

With social media, there is no longer any down time. You are vulnerable to harassment all the time.

I think there is a reason that Bill Gates, Steve Jobs, Sundar Pichai, and others limited screen time for their own kids.

Re: I Changed My Mind on Social Media and Teen Depression

#27
post #24

If the sharp rise since 2012 in female teenage depression in USA is caused by social media. Why isn't the same sharp rise seen in Europe, where female teenagers also use social media?

Kinder Eggs and/or lower legal drinking age?

I was about to just make that joke, then realized that actually social media might be worse than alcohol…

Re: I Changed My Mind on Social Media and Teen Depression

#28

> A final reason I didn’t want to believe in the social media hypothesis was that I’d much rather blame wokeness … it’s annoying to me that intellectuals won’t even consider the possibility that radical new ideas about race and sex might be to blame, and the fact that the most liberal demographics, that is women and LGBT adolescents, are having the most mental problems indicates that there is something to the theory…

I see woke as tolerance, open to each other and acceptance. Yes it's over done sometimes but it's hard to see how he would connect wokeness with depression. Or does people understand under wokeness something different than I do? Like great that black kids get heroes in cinema!

[deleted]

Re: I Changed My Mind on Social Media and Teen Depression

#29
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Is there more context to share?

Yes, read the other talking points this applause cow for conservative viewpoints is peddling. It has nothing to do with thinking for himself and everything with jumping the bandwagon.

I think it's a bit much to accuse him of being an "applause cow" for conservative viewpoints. He's written at length about how conservatives on the whole are the low IQ and low information party. Not exactly something you say to garner applause from a conservative audience.

I can see why people would find him grating though.

Re: I Changed My Mind on Social Media and Teen Depression

#30
post #24

If the sharp rise since 2012 in female teenage depression in USA is caused by social media. Why isn't the same sharp rise seen in Europe, where female teenagers also use social media?

Suicide rates amongst female European teenagers are rising as well. I'd encourage you to consult the literature before making assertions like that.

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00431-021-04240-7

Post reply on HN