Live data from Hacker News

Help! Is This Arabic?

isthisarabic.com

101–110 of 304 posts

Re: Help! Is This Arabic?

#101
post #94

Crazy how there’s “two billion people” who can read Arabic and seemingly 0 of them are making serious contributions to Arabic text rendering except this one specific guy. Weird.

There is 99% chance the software you are reading text on right now uses HarfBuzz to lay out the text, a library written mainly by a Persian person. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HarfBuzz

I believe that’s the specific guy that was referenced.

Re: Help! Is This Arabic?

#102
post #9

naive question. Is there an arabic equiv of a 7 segment display? It looks like a writing system that is very amenable to that sort of digitization. Always a center line, and then up to two strokes going {up, down, diagonal, curved} intersecting at the {left, middle right} of the main line, followed by some dots to further specify a sub-category. Seems like a small finite set of graphical components being composed tog…

us patent 4647924 (1987)

https://patentimages.storage.googleapis.com/a5/dc/27/34d036c...

Re: Help! Is This Arabic?

#103
I wrote a note in GMail the other day where I needed a Latin phrase. For accuracy I pasted it from the web page where I found the original. It screwed up the “x height” of the text that followed. And offended my sense of correct typesetting. I had to do the paste via third app maneuver to get my email right. So this is just QoI between two European-biased applications using two European languages that use the same basic writing. So I am disappointed by poor Arabic handling but not surprised.

Re: Help! Is This Arabic?

#104

I wrote a note in GMail the other day where I needed a Latin phrase. For accuracy I pasted it from the web page where I found the original. It screwed up the “x height” of the text that followed. And offended my sense of correct typesetting. I had to do the paste via third app maneuver to get my email right. So this is just QoI between two European-biased applications using two European languages that use the same ba…

Hold shift while pasting (chrome) to paste the text only, no formatting.

Re: Help! Is This Arabic?

#105
post #94

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There is 99% chance the software you are reading text on right now uses HarfBuzz to lay out the text, a library written mainly by a Persian person. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HarfBuzz

I believe that’s the specific guy that was referenced.

That is not the point I’m making, rather a single person is responsible for how most of software render text in most of the world writing systems and no one is wondering how 6 billion people on this planet so much depend on the work of “this one guy”. It is because text layout is something 99% of software developers can’t do right if their lives depended on it (same for anything that involves the irregularities of human nature, software developers are not cut for this).

Re: Help! Is This Arabic?

#106
post #104

I wrote a note in GMail the other day where I needed a Latin phrase. For accuracy I pasted it from the web page where I found the original. It screwed up the “x height” of the text that followed. And offended my sense of correct typesetting. I had to do the paste via third app maneuver to get my email right. So this is just QoI between two European-biased applications using two European languages that use the same ba…

Hold shift while pasting (chrome) to paste the text only, no formatting.

Or just copypasta through Notepad (or your favorite Linux equivalent) for a universal formatting-stripping solution.

Re: Help! Is This Arabic?

#107
post #28

Probably a good place to ask: I want to add an arabic translation to a webpage I operate. My text editor is a bit confused by the unicode symbols. Obviously the text editor displays left-to-right no matter what as it's made for programming. What's the right way to handle this?

I recommend using gedit for this use case (available for linux and mac) it has the best support for arabic, right to left script and bidi (that's mixing rtl and ltr in the same sentence) I've ever seen

Re: Help! Is This Arabic?

#108
post #79

> Photoshop breaks Arabic. We even have a website that will break our Arabic so that Photoshop breaks it back to normal. Yes, Adobe is aware. No, they do not care. Photoshop since time immemorial had a Middle East edition (ME) which supported RTL and used to curb piracy I don’t know how it’s with their new pseudo-sass but I think they integrated it into their main product

Photoshop relatively recently consolidated its text layout into a single layout engine (based on HarfBuzz) and Arabic support no longer an opt-in (which was the source of the trouble, you had to know you need to opt-in Arabic support before installing the application)

https://helpx.adobe.com/lv/photoshop/using/unified-text-engi...

Re: Help! Is This Arabic?

#109
The main thing here is knowledge of the language. Given how widespread Arabic is (though perhaps not so much in the gaming ecosystem which is Rami's area), it makes sense to have someone on the team knowledgeable about the language while doing translations.

I encountered a (sort of) similar problem while rendering Devanagari text and wouldn't have realised If I couldn't read the text https://stackoverflow.com/questions/44254171/devanagari-text...

Re: Help! Is This Arabic?

#110
post #107
post #28

Probably a good place to ask: I want to add an arabic translation to a webpage I operate. My text editor is a bit confused by the unicode symbols. Obviously the text editor displays left-to-right no matter what as it's made for programming. What's the right way to handle this?

I recommend using gedit for this use case (available for linux and mac) it has the best support for arabic, right to left script and bidi (that's mixing rtl and ltr in the same sentence) I've ever seen

also I would be happy to help you support arabic in your webpage. send me an email slim@pirate.tn
Post reply on HN