Live data from Hacker News

AI’s Instagram Problem

deeplearning.ai

51–60 of 99 posts

Re: AI’s Instagram Problem

#51

Stuff does happen though. - Facebook enters the geolocation game (dowalla/foursquare/instagram) - Google releases reviews to maps (yelp & co) - Amazon starts it's own airline (Fedex) - Microsoft adds ChatGPT to search (Kagi, Duckduckgo, etc..) Sometimes it's hard to recover your startup when a big player does something to fill the void you were targeting.

all those companies are part of a botnet and you should not be training their AI models with your data.

Re: AI’s Instagram Problem

#52

Aren't we maybe jumping the gun here a little? Human creations are far better still than AI ones. People seem to (very understandably) conflate "impressive because of the technology" with "good," but either way thats not going to last forever, even for the most passionate AI-heads. We will take this stuff for granted pretty soon here, and then inevitability remember again what actually enjoying and connecting with a…

Right, I'm sure you went down to the blacksmith to have some artisan made cutlery for your kitchen when you needed some new forks?

Re: AI’s Instagram Problem

#53

Stuff does happen though. - Facebook enters the geolocation game (dowalla/foursquare/instagram) - Google releases reviews to maps (yelp & co) - Amazon starts it's own airline (Fedex) - Microsoft adds ChatGPT to search (Kagi, Duckduckgo, etc..) Sometimes it's hard to recover your startup when a big player does something to fill the void you were targeting.

all those companies are part of a botnet and you should not be training their AI models with your data.

Good luck not giving your data to those companies.

Re: AI’s Instagram Problem

#54
post #3

> AI develops so quickly that waves of new ideas keep coming: quantum AI, self-supervised learning, transformers, diffusion models, large language models, and on and on. I wonder what’s wrong with us as a species. We love to run into one direction all together chasing the next big thing just until the next big trend comes along. Quantum AI crypto LLMs for the win!

If you think we as a species are all together chased/chasing crypto or AI/LLMs, you really need to step outside of the echo chamber.

> OpenAI, is estimated to have reached 100 million monthly active users in January

That's 1.3% of the estimated population of our species. It's only 1/3 of US population.

Re: AI’s Instagram Problem

#55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The viewpoint described in the article, particularly the emotion of envy. I have been working on this stuff since 2005 or so and I can do more than I ever did and if there is one thing I am certain of it is that other people are going to research things and publish even better models in the future that I'm going to download from huggingface or whatever comes next. (On the other hand the fact that I know how to pose w…

how do you convince clients to improve data collection?

These people wanted an audiovisual matching engine a bit beyond the state of the art. The only way they were going to get that then (or now for that matter) is hiring people to label the data. They were funded and had a lot of traction and I think I could have talked them into it if I’d been thinking a little bit.

Re: AI’s Instagram Problem

#56
post #52

Aren't we maybe jumping the gun here a little? Human creations are far better still than AI ones. People seem to (very understandably) conflate "impressive because of the technology" with "good," but either way thats not going to last forever, even for the most passionate AI-heads. We will take this stuff for granted pretty soon here, and then inevitability remember again what actually enjoying and connecting with a…

Right, I'm sure you went down to the blacksmith to have some artisan made cutlery for your kitchen when you needed some new forks?

Maybe, if you have the time, do me a favor: read the (very short) piece I am responding to, its the link at the very top of the page. If you still have a thoughtful or even snarkey comment to make to me after that, then please go ahead. But you're not really giving me anything to work with here, and around here we do strive to have real conversations. I just know you have some good points to make to me!

Maybe chopsticks?

Re: AI’s Instagram Problem

#57

All AI projects are valuable, but it's annoying and demotivating to work hard on a unique and useful project and have no one read/use it because it doesn't stand out in the extremely rapidly-evolving ecosystem. Most of my AI text-generation and image-generation projects and tools have already become obsolete by technology released in the past few months, and I've almost given up competing.

I've called this the rapidly shrinking innovation-disruption-adaption cycles. It quickly becomes the new rat race.

"It will be unlikely we will be able to plan for the disruption as it will simply happen before anyone can reason about what is likely to happen next or what to do about it. Any such planning efforts will be obsolete before they begin"

https://dakara.substack.com/p/ai-and-the-end-to-all-things

Re: AI’s Instagram Problem

#58

Aren't we maybe jumping the gun here a little? Human creations are far better still than AI ones. People seem to (very understandably) conflate "impressive because of the technology" with "good," but either way thats not going to last forever, even for the most passionate AI-heads. We will take this stuff for granted pretty soon here, and then inevitability remember again what actually enjoying and connecting with a…

I've spent a lot of time thinking about this as well. I think you have some valid points. For better discussions, I'm thinking we really need to begin to differentiate AI art on the values of utility, creativity, meaning, craft and visual appeal as I think very different answers are appropriate for each.

I've written a fairly long piece with some related content, the most relevant portion is the section "AI owns creativity". Would be interested in your point of view.

https://dakara.substack.com/p/ai-and-the-end-to-all-things

Re: AI’s Instagram Problem

#59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

One advise I'll never forget (from an interview with late mathematician Maryam Mirzakhani) is that you don't have to race faster than everyone else (although if you can, that's great!). You can just run in a direction no one is running toward (and hopefully be persistent). Then you're only racing yourself and speed is largely irrelevant. I myself know I'm very slow, specially developing projects. So I don't try to ra…

Problem is that's not how academic funding works. Grants are generally not given to possible dead ends.

[dead]

Re: AI’s Instagram Problem

#60

All AI projects are valuable, but it's annoying and demotivating to work hard on a unique and useful project and have no one read/use it because it doesn't stand out in the extremely rapidly-evolving ecosystem. Most of my AI text-generation and image-generation projects and tools have already become obsolete by technology released in the past few months, and I've almost given up competing.

One advise I'll never forget (from an interview with late mathematician Maryam Mirzakhani) is that you don't have to race faster than everyone else (although if you can, that's great!). You can just run in a direction no one is running toward (and hopefully be persistent). Then you're only racing yourself and speed is largely irrelevant. I myself know I'm very slow, specially developing projects. So I don't try to ra…

“Run in the other direction” is so generic that it isn’t helpful. No one else going in that direction is, at best, unrelated to the quality of the idea and, at worst, a heuristic that the idea is bad.
Post reply on HN