Live data from Hacker News

KanjiVG – SVGs of Kanji character strokes including order, shape and direction

kanjivg.tagaini.net

51–60 of 72 posts

Re: KanjiVG – SVGs of Kanji character strokes including order, shape and direction

#51
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This. Traditional Chinese and Japanese are two seemingly similar but distinctly different things (the latter is forked from the former). Simplified Chinese is a whole different beast of corruption that is a fork of Traditional Chinese but otherwise not similar to either.

Kanji were also simplified but not necessarily the same way as simplified Chinese. Simplified Chinese also sometimes uses 'old' characters. So sometimes modern Japanese is actually similar to simplified Chinese, sometimes it is similar to traditional Chinese, and sometimes it is unique. There is no simple 'fork'. For instance, 円 (yen) is simplified Japanese and uniquely Japanese. It used to be same as traditional Chi…

Sometimes Blink is similar to WebKit, sometimes it is similar to KHTML and sometimes it is unique.

I think the fork analogy still holds, no one says forks can't have convergent evolution or cross pollination

Re: KanjiVG – SVGs of Kanji character strokes including order, shape and direction

#52

Hmm, this reminds me of Jim Rose's stroke order diagram retrographer-editor[0] (SODER) from some time ago. [0]: https://archive.org/details/soder

That seems to have been uploaded on February 11 2023. I remember kanjicafe.com, which used to have a giant picture of Jim Rose's face for some reason. The site seems to have gone now.

https://web.archive.org/web/20040925183635/http://kanjicafe....

Re: KanjiVG – SVGs of Kanji character strokes including order, shape and direction

#54

KanjiVG is awesome. I used it for a free kanji app I made for iOS and Android. Figuring out how to write an SVG parser + renderer wasn't as tricky as I thought when I set out to do it. https://www.bjmalicoat.com/projects/kanjibook

Very nice. I might even get a sticker :)

One thing that IMO is missing is the audio playback option for readings. This would've greatly facilitated remembering readings. AWS Polly is very easy to integrate with and it costs next to nothing. /nudge /nudge.

Re: KanjiVG – SVGs of Kanji character strokes including order, shape and direction

#55
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Definitely not exactly the same. Kanji and Hanzi are two different character sets - they overlap a lot, but each has common everyday characters that aren't in the other, and sometimes the "same" character is in both sets but written differently in various languages (e.g. 骨).

In case anyone is wondering why different glyphs have the same unicode code point, and how an app is supposed to decide which one to render... Well I don't know the reason for the first question actually, though many people appear to have some choice comments. But as for the second question: for HTML documents, many tags have a lang attribute that decide which version of the glyph to render within that tag. Hacker Ne…

> In case anyone is wondering why different glyphs have the same unicode code point, and how an app is supposed to decide which one to render... Well I don't know the reason for the first question actually

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Han_unification

My understanding is that this is basically "white guy says all Asian writing looks the same" in standards form and is largely regarded as a terrible idea.

Re: KanjiVG – SVGs of Kanji character strokes including order, shape and direction

#56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In case anyone is wondering why different glyphs have the same unicode code point, and how an app is supposed to decide which one to render... Well I don't know the reason for the first question actually, though many people appear to have some choice comments. But as for the second question: for HTML documents, many tags have a lang attribute that decide which version of the glyph to render within that tag. Hacker Ne…

> In case anyone is wondering why different glyphs have the same unicode code point, and how an app is supposed to decide which one to render... Well I don't know the reason for the first question actually https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Han_unification My understanding is that this is basically "white guy says all Asian writing looks the same" in standards form and is largely regarded as a terrible idea.

Unicode had a builtin language tagging system to resolve glyph variants. Han unification was implemented with this in mind. Then the tagging got deprecated in a later version.

Re: KanjiVG – SVGs of Kanji character strokes including order, shape and direction

#57

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> In case anyone is wondering why different glyphs have the same unicode code point, and how an app is supposed to decide which one to render... Well I don't know the reason for the first question actually https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Han_unification My understanding is that this is basically "white guy says all Asian writing looks the same" in standards form and is largely regarded as a terrible idea.

Unicode had a builtin language tagging system to resolve glyph variants. Han unification was implemented with this in mind. Then the tagging got deprecated in a later version.

The more I learn about unicode, the more it looks like Bad Ideas: The Standard to me. The only good part of it is the UTF-8 encoding and that was just Thompson and Pike sitting down and thinking about the problem for an hour.

Re: KanjiVG – SVGs of Kanji character strokes including order, shape and direction

#59
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This. Traditional Chinese and Japanese are two seemingly similar but distinctly different things (the latter is forked from the former). Simplified Chinese is a whole different beast of corruption that is a fork of Traditional Chinese but otherwise not similar to either.

Kanji were also simplified but not necessarily the same way as simplified Chinese. Simplified Chinese also sometimes uses 'old' characters. So sometimes modern Japanese is actually similar to simplified Chinese, sometimes it is similar to traditional Chinese, and sometimes it is unique. There is no simple 'fork'. For instance, 円 (yen) is simplified Japanese and uniquely Japanese. It used to be same as traditional Chi…

To further complicate things, there are the 'kokuji" - characters that were invented in Japan, used only in Japan, and only have Japanese pronunciations - yet are still considered kanji ("Chinese characters)". Examples:

働 "work" 峠 "mountain pass"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kanji#Kokuji

Re: KanjiVG – SVGs of Kanji character strokes including order, shape and direction

#60

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Kanji were also simplified but not necessarily the same way as simplified Chinese. Simplified Chinese also sometimes uses 'old' characters. So sometimes modern Japanese is actually similar to simplified Chinese, sometimes it is similar to traditional Chinese, and sometimes it is unique. There is no simple 'fork'. For instance, 円 (yen) is simplified Japanese and uniquely Japanese. It used to be same as traditional Chi…

To further complicate things, there are the 'kokuji" - characters that were invented in Japan, used only in Japan, and only have Japanese pronunciations - yet are still considered kanji ("Chinese characters)". Examples: 働 "work" 峠 "mountain pass" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kanji#Kokuji

>峠 "mountain pass"

Incidentially, the backstory behind that kanji is hilarious.

The kanji is composed of the kanjis for "mountain" on the left side, and "up" and "down" on the upper right and lower right sides respectively.

You know what a mountain pass does? Go up and down a mountain.

Post reply on HN