Live data from Hacker News

Chat with Historical Figures Using AI – Learn from the Past in a Fun New Way

apps.apple.com

11–20 of 38 posts

Re: Chat with Historical Figures Using AI – Learn from the Past in a Fun New Way

#11

This is probably how children in the future will study. It's much easier to forget what one reads in books than to forget 1-1 conversations with people. Just add deepfake video/audio and VR/AR as well.

Like when Captain Janeway went to the holodeck to have a chat with the holographic synthetic Leonardo Da Vinci.

Re: Chat with Historical Figures Using AI – Learn from the Past in a Fun New Way

#12
post #4

This is not "talk to historic figures", this sounds like "talk to a machine that writes stylised after historic figures". I highly doubt Shakespeare spoke in sonnets.

The Socrates and Sir Isaac Newton models actually talked basically the same so not sure it is even trying to stylize the text. Overall it barely works, I tried it and a lot of my questions got no response at all

Re: Chat with Historical Figures Using AI – Learn from the Past in a Fun New Way

#14
post #3

I don't like the framing of 'learn something new' because you are very likely to have falsehoods presented to you as reliable facts. Its fun to ask Marie Curie what she thinks about blockchains, but anything you ask about her own life and work is just as likely to be fiction as whatever she says about blockchains.

See, for instance, the conversations in this thread with figures like Henry Ford, Ronald Reagan, and Lyndon Johnson: https://twitter.com/ZaneGTCooper/status/1615577714836275200

Re: Chat with Historical Figures Using AI – Learn from the Past in a Fun New Way

#15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You’re about to get ragged on because you posted this to a site full of people who know the limitations of your technology. But that said, assuming this was a low-cost/low-risk demo project for your firm, it’s a classic entry in building a little carriage store on the gold rush routes. People (but not HN people) are looking for stuff like this and will have fun with it. It’ll help people better understand the limitat…

honestly, the $20/month subscription fee made me raise an eyebrow, especially considering that the likely implementation is "add a prompt that took 5 seconds to write and 20 seconds to tweak to the top of every request".

If the bot needs to retain conversation memory, it will cost around 4 cents per message once the conversation gets long enough. I guess they are also inspired by chat gpt plus prices.

Source: I am building a competitor

Re: Chat with Historical Figures Using AI – Learn from the Past in a Fun New Way

#17
post #3

I don't like the framing of 'learn something new' because you are very likely to have falsehoods presented to you as reliable facts. Its fun to ask Marie Curie what she thinks about blockchains, but anything you ask about her own life and work is just as likely to be fiction as whatever she says about blockchains.

See, for instance, the conversations in this thread with figures like Henry Ford, Ronald Reagan, and Lyndon Johnson: https://twitter.com/ZaneGTCooper/status/1615577714836275200

The limitations of using pre trained data with a simple prompt. The bot will get inspired by the prompt a little, but most of its text comes from the training which is adjusted to sound as neutral and "generally acceptable human"like as possible.

This means that for most cases the personality disappears.

Re: Chat with Historical Figures Using AI – Learn from the Past in a Fun New Way

#18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

See, for instance, the conversations in this thread with figures like Henry Ford, Ronald Reagan, and Lyndon Johnson: https://twitter.com/ZaneGTCooper/status/1615577714836275200

The limitations of using pre trained data with a simple prompt. The bot will get inspired by the prompt a little, but most of its text comes from the training which is adjusted to sound as neutral and "generally acceptable human"like as possible. This means that for most cases the personality disappears.

To add: if the training and fine tuning comes from how the subject actually responded, spoke and reasoned, then that would be quite scarily accurate.

Re: Chat with Historical Figures Using AI – Learn from the Past in a Fun New Way

#19
post #3

I don't like the framing of 'learn something new' because you are very likely to have falsehoods presented to you as reliable facts. Its fun to ask Marie Curie what she thinks about blockchains, but anything you ask about her own life and work is just as likely to be fiction as whatever she says about blockchains.

See, for instance, the conversations in this thread with figures like Henry Ford, Ronald Reagan, and Lyndon Johnson: https://twitter.com/ZaneGTCooper/status/1615577714836275200

tbf, Reagan insisting that he did the best he could with the AIDs crisis is quite plausible.

That's the other problem with the theory of understanding historical figures by chatting with them: even if the simulation was realistic or we were able to reincarnate the actual historical figures they'd lie, dissemble and make excuses a lot...

Re: Chat with Historical Figures Using AI – Learn from the Past in a Fun New Way

#20
post #5

Introducing TalkTo AI, the app that lets you chat with historical figures using cutting-edge AI technology. Want to ask Socrates what he thinks of modern politics? Or get Marie Curie's thoughts on the latest scientific breakthroughs? With TalkTo AI, you can have conversations with famous historical figures like never before. Our app uses advanced machine learning algorithms to create realistic, engaging conversations…

„Advanced machine learning algorithms“ such as HTTP calls to ChatGPT with two sentences of prompt instructing it to pretend to be some historical figure..?

To be fair, GPT is an advanced machine learning algorithm, that the product is enabling access to, for the lay person.
Post reply on HN