Live data from Hacker News

Rejected emoji proposals

charlottebuff.com

121–130 of 151 posts

Re: Rejected emoji proposals

#121

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My problem with emojis is finding them. No, I dont want to search hundrets of tiny images for making a point. No, I dont want to learn another alphabet with thousands of symbols. Just _write_ is so much easier. Or link it with a unicode name to be able to refer to it without searching

Uh, just use the picker which has search buld-in? Windows+. On windows OSX was something like ctrl-space or something. I rarely chat on Mac so I don't recall.

Or one of the many applications that support the :emoji_name: autocomplete.

Re: Rejected emoji proposals

#122

I have made a conscious commitment to stop all use of emojis. They seem innocent enough, but ultimately they're debasing language and limiting the range of free expression. For example, in 2018, most major platforms changed their revolver emojis to water gun icons, in an apparent attempt to "do something" about gun violence. This would be a laughable proposition if it didn't border on dystopian. We should not allow t…

In simple emoji fashion, I would use the "rolling eyes" emoji to express my discontent with your post.

Re: Rejected emoji proposals

#123
post #74

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"It is time for the UTC to own up to their mistakes. This whole ordeal has gone on for way too long. I am not asking for much; the solution to this problem is laughably easy. The current gender situation in Unicode is discriminatory, end of discussion. It excludes transgender people by pretending that only women can get pregnant. It excludes non-binary people by treating the third gender option as secondary to male a…

> “by pretending that only women can get pregnant.” Only women can be impregnated. Stating otherwise does not make it so.

It's hilarious that you're using words to convey this argument. Good one

Re: Rejected emoji proposals

#124
post #60

there's still no leek / scallion emoji despite the family being the 2nd most used vegetable in SEA cooking.

I noticed proposals use google/bing search results (in english) to show support for an emoji. If they used multiple languages to show popularity (at least english, spanish, french, and mandarin) it would look different.

In general emoji are very us-centric, for example the police car emoji doesn't look like a police car to many cultures.

Re: Rejected emoji proposals

#125
post #62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I didn't know that. That said, considering that adopting Unicode was a decision in and of itself, would expanding that space really be such a burden? I'm also now surprised to see that Wales and Scotland get a flag but Northern Ireland does not. Aren't they on the same standing? I always thought it followed UN membership but that Wales and Scotland got an exception. I know Palestine and Kosovo have emojis also. Are t…

>would expanding that space really be such a burden? It would require dropping UTF-16, which is the limiting factor. That, or defining planes that aren't available to all encodings. Don't hold your breath. I don't know who is using UTF-16 or UTF-32. It seems like most of the world has adopted UTF-8. So, maybe one day UTF-16 and UTF-32 will be dropped and more planes will be defined. That's a big maybe. If it happens…

> I don't know who is using UTF-16 or UTF-32.

Java, JavaScript, Win32's "wide" API, C#, and many more. As for actual file storage, UTF-8 is indeed the most common, but UTF-16 still lingers on.

Re: Rejected emoji proposals

#127

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Right. Because the system is to have woman, man, and neutral for everything. Saves debate for more important things.

The party in power wins by default on the little stuff. The opposition must "save their debate for more important things."

I don't know who is opposed other than those that want to pretend that pregnant transmen don't exist.

Re: Rejected emoji proposals

#128
post #67

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not on Telegram and Discord. They have custom emojis.

Discord handles emojis better than any other chat platform I've used; I think this is one of the main reasons people like to use it. Telegram's up there with Skype for being one of the absolute worst at handling them. I type :flushed: and it gives me smiling blushing face instead of :flushed:. I type :o (which has always meant surprised pikachu face, since before the surprised pikachu face was even a meme) and it giv…

Telegram's custom emojis are fairly recent. They've not yet implemented super deep contextual recommendation, but I appreciate the little convenient things Telegram has. For example, writing 'stonks' on Telegram would recommend you the statistics chart emoji. Or typing 'haha' would suggest relevant emojis. I don't remember discord doing that (I stopped using it long ago).

Also, Telegram's sticker support is unmatched. Not a single app even comes close to it.

Re: Rejected emoji proposals

#129

Would have been nice if they did US state flags.

The US is far from the only country in which states/provinces/regions/etc have their own flags. Australia's six states (and its two self-governing mainland territories) each have their own flag. Canada's ten provinces and three territories have flags too. Mexico has 31 states, but only 7 have official flags. Germany has 16 states, all of which have a flag. Austria has 9 states, which all have flags. Switzerland has 2…

England, Scotland, and Wales all have Unicode flags. So do British Overseas territories (e.g UK Virgin Islands) and crown dependencies (e.g. Jersey). As do US Territories (e.g. Puerto Rico).

America had a much stronger flag culture than, say, Jersey. We see local and state flags flown at private residences.

I’d certainly use my state if it was in Unicode.

Re: Rejected emoji proposals

#130

I have made a conscious commitment to stop all use of emojis. They seem innocent enough, but ultimately they're debasing language and limiting the range of free expression. For example, in 2018, most major platforms changed their revolver emojis to water gun icons, in an apparent attempt to "do something" about gun violence. This would be a laughable proposition if it didn't border on dystopian. We should not allow t…

In simple emoji fashion, I would use the "rolling eyes" emoji to express my discontent with your post.

Do you think that would be more or less respectful than using your words to communicate in polite discourse?
Post reply on HN