Live data from Hacker News

Rejected emoji proposals

charlottebuff.com

91–100 of 151 posts

Re: Rejected emoji proposals

#91

I have made a conscious commitment to stop all use of emojis. They seem innocent enough, but ultimately they're debasing language and limiting the range of free expression. For example, in 2018, most major platforms changed their revolver emojis to water gun icons, in an apparent attempt to "do something" about gun violence. This would be a laughable proposition if it didn't border on dystopian. We should not allow t…

What would be the emoji equivalent of old man shaking fist at cloud?

Re: Rejected emoji proposals

#93

It’s quite upsetting to know we had to opportunity to get a Frowning Pile of Poo emoji and it was rejected! The current poo emoji is too happy!

Indeed, anyone with an infant knows bowel movements run the entire emotional gamut. Everything from the sad face to the party hat, from the exploding head to the dollar sign eyes.

Re: Rejected emoji proposals

#94
post #55

I feel like the entire emoji block should be made part of the supplementary/private use or similar. Leave what gets implemented up to Microsoft/ Apple/ Google to agree on. It's fallen completely out of scope of unicode's purpose of documenting used symbols and into a sort of editorialized control of what can cannot be said.

I still don't understand how so many people are in favor of this whole emoji system being a part of unicode. Most people I interact with seem to end up using application specific emojis anyway.

Aren't people afraid that if there's too much stuff in a standard then people will stop using the standard?

Re: Rejected emoji proposals

#95
post #7

I guess I should feel relieved that I don't at least have my work discussions littered with these ones. But they're not too different from the set of infantilizing pictograms that did make their way into the standard & that grown-ups are now expected to deal with.

I think they're nice and help to add tone and context in an increasingly online workplace. The world is better because the director of my billion dollar project is able to heart react in the chat, not worse.

They were able to heart react before emojis were added to Unicode too. Custom emoticons were a thing a long time ago.

Re: Rejected emoji proposals

#96
post #7

I guess I should feel relieved that I don't at least have my work discussions littered with these ones. But they're not too different from the set of infantilizing pictograms that did make their way into the standard & that grown-ups are now expected to deal with.

Wouldn’t it have been interesting to be a fly on the wall during the annual convening of the ancient Egyptian’s hieroglyphics committee?

“This year’s proposals for new entries into the standard hieroglyphic dictionary include: slave being whipped, bearded slave being whipped, woman being humped by a donkey, and bearded donkey being ridden by a pregnant cat.”

Re: Rejected emoji proposals

#97

I have made a conscious commitment to stop all use of emojis. They seem innocent enough, but ultimately they're debasing language and limiting the range of free expression. For example, in 2018, most major platforms changed their revolver emojis to water gun icons, in an apparent attempt to "do something" about gun violence. This would be a laughable proposition if it didn't border on dystopian. We should not allow t…

> They seem innocent enough, but ultimately they're debasing language and limiting the range of free expression.

Whatever they do, it’s not that. Emojis allow for multivalence and useful ambiguity in ways that few words still have left in them.

From the perspectives of both communication and poetry, they’re a major boon to what’s now possible in written form.

Rage all you want, though. Talking about them like this helps sharpen our understanding of what they actually do.

Re: Rejected emoji proposals

#99

I like the bloated balloon one and a period/pre-period emojis would be good. A few women in my life (managers/directors/executives) are terrified to talk about their periods because it could be used against them. I'm going to risk turning this into one of those "Normalize " tweets.. But cramps, bloating, irritability, pain, any number of other things. I want a status emoji for headaches and "didn't sleep well". Somet…

The problem with normalising things is that it tends to become an expectation. An environment where people are open about their personal well being is challenging for someone who needs privacy. The one who takes unexplained time off risks appearing insincere. I feel it's more inclusive to insist on not discussing personal situations in public. If you need time off, just take time off. Every person is different and will have their own needs and situations. I don't need to know why and even if I did, it is has zero bearing on the matter, unless we share a personal relationship.
Post reply on HN