Live data from Hacker News

The fashion for passion

economist.com

21–30 of 44 posts

Re: The fashion for passion

#21
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Whilst I don't disagree - there are definitely things I'm happy to do for 16 hours(!) - I think the point (at least based on my understanding) is more that you'll never love something all the time. You could be a famous actor or a rockstar and still resent the fact you have to come in to dub over voices, do the press tour, or play the show that didn't sell out where the monitors don't work properly. You could love to…

Regarding the monetized thing: there's a special point with that. You can have all the passion in the world for a thing, but is your passion about how OTHER PEOPLE react to that? If so, monetizing can be your passion, but the way other people react to a thing is not that thing, it's a separate thing. I know that in my line of work I can get passionate about plenty of ideas, but there's no real correlation between wha…

Indeed. I've can absolutely familiarise with that kind of burnout. So much effort and nothing lands. Lots of lessons and hindsight is wonderful thing. But at the time it becomes very demotivating and pointless.

Re: The fashion for passion

#22
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There are definitely things I love which I would classify as useful work. I can do them basically 16 hours a day. So while I would not say that this is bad advice in general, I think it definitely is dangerous advice for those with a passion. Why would you spend your life doing something else than what you know you love?

Whilst I don't disagree - there are definitely things I'm happy to do for 16 hours(!) - I think the point (at least based on my understanding) is more that you'll never love something all the time. You could be a famous actor or a rockstar and still resent the fact you have to come in to dub over voices, do the press tour, or play the show that didn't sell out where the monitors don't work properly. You could love to…

I think it is good advice as long as you don't have a REAL passion. Once you have one, it is spectacularly bad advice, because in this case there is just no way you cannot follow it, and trying to do so is just hurting yourself. Of course your passion always also involves things you might not cherish as much, such as marketing, sales, etc., but you'll endure that if that stays just a tolerable part of what you do.

Re: The fashion for passion

#23
I love what I do, but most folks here probably think I'm crazy (and they may have a point).

I work (very hard –possibly harder than I ever have, in my life) for free. I'm grateful to have the means to do that. I got those means by working on stuff I didn't like working on.

I love coding. I love solving problems. I love shipping. I love writing user interfaces. I love writing device control code.

But I have found that working at the whim of others, does not end well (for me).

It's worth it, to me, to be in a position, where others don't dictate what I do, and where I'm not dependent upon others.

I am currently working for a nonprofit, on a team, where I'm doing the lions' share of the work. It's a fairly robust social media/resource location application that consists of a few backend servers, a couple of SDKs, a whole bunch of dependencies (almost all ones that I wrote), and an iOS/iPadOS app.

I've been working on it for a couple of years. That's a long time, for me. I can usually bang something like this out, in a month or two.

The reason is that I want to bring the team along. It's a big learning experience for most of them. They are a lot younger than me, and, for most of them, this is the first time that they've ever been involved in a soup-to-nuts software deliverable. They didn't really know what they wanted, in the beginning, and we had to spend a great deal of time, prototyping various user experiences, before finally settling on the final one.

Now, we're in the home stretch. Once we had consolidated the project into a concrete workflow and user experience, we brought in a designer, I rewrote the core of the app into a platform-independent engine, and we're writing it from the ground up. It won't take that long (but still, longer than I usually do, on my own).

It's fun. I have learned a great deal, myself, during the process, and, to add a cherry on top, the software will be used to help people to rebuild fairly shattered lives, so it's all good.

Re: The fashion for passion

#24
post #14

"Most workers want to do a job they love" I forget where I read/heard it, but some of the best career advice I ever heard was (paraphrasing here): if you keep searching for the job you love you'll never be happy. Find a job you are, for the most part, tolerant of doing every day. There will always be ups and downs, but if you can't even face starting in the morning you're definitely going to spend life unhappy.

There was self-help type book (quite a good one, but its name escapes me) that talks about the Passion Mindset and the Craftsman Mindset.

The Craftsman derives joy from mastering their craft, learning from past failures and improving every day.

You can be a Craftsman in any career which allows for outlier performance - public speaking, writing books, trading, academia, entrepreneurship, software engineering.

The Passion mindset is about finding your strongest passion and then working in that area. The problem with this is that most people don't really know what they will be passionate about from the start. And worse, it's even harder to know if the current thing is what you are most passionate about! You also may not have a skills edge in what you are passionate about.

Re: The fashion for passion

#25
I understand the pragmatism but....it took me around a decade+ of doing crap jobs, that I hated, in order to subsidize the pursuit of "my passion" Its now been 6 years where I have been able to make a living doing what I love and I have to say, it was worth the risk. Do I recommend putting all your eggs in one basket, and going through life without a 'Plan B' - no...but the twist is, the maniac dreamers, whose passion run into the gamut of iconoclasm - those people simply will not (or more realistically) cannot abide by pragmatism.. but this obsessive nature is usually symptomatic of greater 'issues' (that then may bear fruit) and everyone who forges their own path in such a way must pay the toll and suffer the consequences (think starving artists, alienated high functioning individuals, persons inhabiting or transgressive practices, etc)

Re: The fashion for passion

#27
Reminded of advice my former boss, who spent a decade plus leading an elite military unit, received as he set out in his career:

“Be careful how much you give this organization, because we’ll take it.”

Re: The fashion for passion

#28
I screwed up by staying with a company I thought appreciated me going above and beyond. Now, once I'm 6 months into any job, I just start putting out resumes as it'll take 6 months to find the next role I really want.

Re: The fashion for passion

#29
post #10

I feel the topic of having a passion is becoming a contentious issue. When that investor letter to Google ceo came out, I unfortunately suggested that maybe for a company like Google, too high salaries would bring people in who "work for money and not passion". I never even dreamed of seeing so many people taking issue with what I said. Many were saying that it's just a job and people should not be passionate about G…

>I unfortunately suggested that maybe for a company like Google, too high salaries would bring people in who "work for money and not passion".

I mean, that is literally the argument for education, social work, elder care, domestic abuse advocates, CASA, and any other number of social services fields. Why not google? Why shouldn't that argument apply to google as well?

Also:

>Still, trends like Quiet Quiting seem like the worst response.

How so? How is that the worst response?

Post reply on HN