Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Bing thinks Mars has 2.5B people based on an AI generated blog wrong answer

imgur.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

1–10 of 94 posts

Re: Bing thinks Mars has 2.5B people based on an AI generated blog wrong answer

#3

Post by nstart »

senttoschool wrote: post #2

Is this GPT or is this their old engine?

Their old engine. I just posted this because it’s the first instance I’ve run into in the wild where an engine gave an answer based off likely ai generated content. The content here gives the vibe of gpt 2 generated stuff.

It’s a topic of interest to me because there’s a tipping point coming where ai generated content easily outweighs the volume of non ai generated stuff. And I’m curious of the implications of that coming change

Re: Bing thinks Mars has 2.5B people based on an AI generated blog wrong answer

#5

Post by ehnto »

nstart wrote: post #3
senttoschool wrote: post #2

Is this GPT or is this their old engine?

Their old engine. I just posted this because it’s the first instance I’ve run into in the wild where an engine gave an answer based off likely ai generated content. The content here gives the vibe of gpt 2 generated stuff. It’s a topic of interest to me because there’s a tipping point coming where ai generated content easily outweighs the volume of non ai generated stuff. And I’m curious of the implications of that c…

If search engines can't find a way to filter the bad information, all the automated scraping of knowledge will become perilously untrustworthy.

I suspect we may see domain trust become significantly more important, and that may have a chilling effect on legitimate websites gaining a foot hold in search indexes. We already have this issue mind you. Most of my searches for popular topics end up with generated or scraped content in them, unless there is a domain authority with major sway that takes up the majority of results.

Maybe we will see the return of curated web directories? Or maybe the web becomes a barren wasteland as everyone flees to social applications.

Re: Bing thinks Mars has 2.5B people based on an AI generated blog wrong answer

#7

Post by karmakurtisaani »

ehnto wrote: post #5
nstart wrote: post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Their old engine. I just posted this because it’s the first instance I’ve run into in the wild where an engine gave an answer based off likely ai generated content. The content here gives the vibe of gpt 2 generated stuff. It’s a topic of interest to me because there’s a tipping point coming where ai generated content easily outweighs the volume of non ai generated stuff. And I’m curious of the implications of that c…

If search engines can't find a way to filter the bad information, all the automated scraping of knowledge will become perilously untrustworthy. I suspect we may see domain trust become significantly more important, and that may have a chilling effect on legitimate websites gaining a foot hold in search indexes. We already have this issue mind you. Most of my searches for popular topics end up with generated or scrape…

I think you're on to something here. The closest equivalent I can think of is academic publishing. There's tons and tons of total garbage among some good research, and pretty much the only way to find the good stuff is to look at what people at top institutions are doing or what the top journals are publishing.

Re: Bing thinks Mars has 2.5B people based on an AI generated blog wrong answer

#9

Post by andsoitis »

dingaling wrote: post #8
andsoitis wrote: post #6

i just asked chatgpt how many humans live in the solar system and it said none.

Bing says 21,894,974,404,480, based on a Wikipedia entry for 18th century scientist Thomas Dick.

chatgpt also claims the number of people on earth vary based on births, deaths, and migration!
Post reply on HN