Live data from Hacker News

US aircraft shoots down new airborne object over Canada

bbc.com

41–50 of 526 posts

Re: US aircraft shoots down new airborne object over Canada

#41
post #19

So the F-22 is now 3-0 against balloons? And people had the audacity to call this plane a "failure"!

Who called the F-22 a failure? Are you thinking of the F-35?

And anyway, isn't the F-22 due to be retired before the end of the decade, so wouldn't debating its merits be beating a dead horse?

Re: US aircraft shoots down new airborne object over Canada

#42

Surely this is not the world's slowest declaration of war? Whoever country is sending whatever these artificial objects are, what can they possibly gain from this?

War? Chill with the historonics. Surveillance is not war.

Shooting missiles at aircraft can be though.

Re: US aircraft shoots down new airborne object over Canada

#43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't see how China would willfully continue send these balloons without expecting a symmetrical escalation. Sure, they managed to send a few relatively undetected until the past recent weeks, but continued attempts would surely produce a physical response from NATO states, whether that's sending balloons of their own or overflying Chinese territory with other aircraft, or increased signals intelligence operations.

>symmetrical escalation So like what, a similar but bigger balloon?

"Mr. President, we must not allow a balloon gap!"

Re: US aircraft shoots down new airborne object over Canada

#45
post #14

How much if this is just awareness bias, where the media reports commonplace events that were previously ignored?

Based on quick search, these have been happening also before.

"an official revealed during a briefing on Saturday that the U.S. was aware of three other instances during the prior administration and one instance earlier in the Biden administration that such an apparatus “transited” the country."

[1] https://thehill.com/policy/defense/3844511-chinese-balloons-...

Re: US aircraft shoots down new airborne object over Canada

#46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The last two objects shot down were not balloons.

Source for that?

The press conference yesterday, the WH spokesman explicitly corrected someone who called the second object a balloon. They're being a bit cagey about whatever it actually is

Re: US aircraft shoots down new airborne object over Canada

#47
post #10
post #3

are Canada’s air forces non existent?

Their F-18s can't fly as high (without doing zoom climbs) as the F-22 (which has very large control surfaces which help with this).

Does the plane have to be at the same altitude to launch the missiles?

Re: US aircraft shoots down new airborne object over Canada

#49
post #5

Surely this is not the world's slowest declaration of war? Whoever country is sending whatever these artificial objects are, what can they possibly gain from this?

usa vs canada! it has happened before.

Pig War 2.0!

Re: US aircraft shoots down new airborne object over Canada

#50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I was joking in the other thread, that soon people will be buying weather baloons and setting them off "for the lulz" (youtube videos, tiktok, or whatever) :)

I would watch a TikTok of "F22 shoots down my balloon."

TikTok is like a spy balloon in your own phone (assuming the 100% clipboard-exfiltration-at-all-times and other data harvesting reports are true).

Ironic if people are being spied upon by TikTok whilst watching a spy balloon video.

Post reply on HN