Live data from Hacker News

Review my startup - Plura Processing: Web Traffic = Grid Computer

pluraprocessing.com

1–10 of 58 posts

Re: Review my startup - Plura Processing: Web Traffic = Grid Computer

#2
Hey guys, we just launched our private beta for Plura.

I submitted our game page as the HN link, but www.pluraprocessing.com has more general information.

Take a look and tell me what you think. We've been paying our alpha affiliates for months now and are ready to take on a much larger pool of affiliates in our beta. "Affiliates" are the people that put Plura on their site, browser game, or other content (even download apps) and get paid for their user time.

Re: Review my startup - Plura Processing: Web Traffic = Grid Computer

#6
This could be huge!

  There is no question there will be plenty of affiliates/CPU time (re)sellers.
  The real question is whether there is big enough demand from those who need grid computing. 
You had a quote from some quant guy, I suppose sciences is another market, not sure about others.

Re: Review my startup - Plura Processing: Web Traffic = Grid Computer

#8
Are there ample warnings to, or explicit agreement with the user that his/her CPU time is going to be used by non-game functions? This seems suspiciously like theft of services.

When I run any process I expect it to restrict all its actions to servicing direct functions related to that process. Plura is expressly unrelated to ANY process/game it is bundled with.

I would personally be annoyed/angry that a program I was using, web-based or not, was using my computer's resources to make money without my knowledge. In fact, you're not just using my computer's resources, you're also drawing more power from my electrical grid, because a processor doing more work consumes more electricity. That's something that directly costs me, the end user, more money. So I would absolutely classify this as theft of service unless the user explicitly agrees to have Plura running in the background.

If there is ample warning to the user, I am fine with this, and would consider it a good idea. Otherwise, it feels really sleazy and wrong.

Re: Review my startup - Plura Processing: Web Traffic = Grid Computer

#9
post #8

Are there ample warnings to, or explicit agreement with the user that his/her CPU time is going to be used by non-game functions? This seems suspiciously like theft of services. When I run any process I expect it to restrict all its actions to servicing direct functions related to that process. Plura is expressly unrelated to ANY process/game it is bundled with. I would personally be annoyed/angry that a program I wa…

Or you could just notice that the game is fun and that you agreed to the TOS and not even care about a few extra cycles.

Re: Review my startup - Plura Processing: Web Traffic = Grid Computer

#10
I think this is an innovative approach to getting more people involved with grid computing for major computations and a clever way to market it in general. However, I agree with some other people here, there has got to be some sort of licensing issue. As much as the whole "you clicked okay to the TOS, you gave us permission." is a tank in court, it still seems to risky. If nothing else, it would risk users no longer using the games from the providers using that service if they found out that their computer slowed down at all during playing that game because it was doing things it wasn't supposed to. Not that I would likely have a problem with it, but lets face it...the general public is slap happy with lawsuits.

Also privacy issues in the entire concept. I didn't notice any (note: I didn't go out of my way to find one either) way for the end users to directly go and see exactly what kind of materials were being processed and what data, if any, was being collected from the user's machine. That might also be a source of trouble in the long run.

Post reply on HN