Live data from Hacker News

Windows 11 is collecting more user data than you know

windowsreport.com

41–50 of 71 posts

Re: Windows 11 is collecting more user data than you know

#41

I've got a macbook nearing end of life and frustration with apple (the company, not the hardware which I'm happy with) has been pushing me to consider windows. It's good to get these reminders of how smarmy Microsoft is. I think I'll probably grit my teeth and buy another mac

Any reasons not to consider Linux laptops? I have exactly the same predicament as you and feel like I'm finally ready to hop into the light side (Linux is by far the best desktop os these days).

Re: Windows 11 is collecting more user data than you know

#43
post #31
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I switched to Ubuntu recently. Never looking back. There are still minor painpoints, but they pale in comparison with the mess that has become Windows.

Since this is really just a gaming PC I really don't feel comfortable going the linux route for it. I know there is proton, but at the end of the day what matters for me is that my games work, I can record and stream. I know Linux Gaming has come a long way but until all of my games are running natively, I don't want to make the switch. Its the same reason I don't just have a nice Mac.

Indeed. Linux is a no go for me. I don't use Steam, also I use DosBox a lot and tinker with a ton of stuff related to games.

When it comes to gaming, nothing compares to Windows by a long shot. Unfortunately.

Re: Windows 11 is collecting more user data than you know

#44
post #16

I recently rebuilt my computer and figured I would just go with Windows 11 to have all the new features and compatibility. I have been seriously debating on reinstalling and going back to 10. Just yesterday "gaming services" just decided it no longer wanted to run. With the talk of how much data this thing collects it really makes me uneasy. Even though I only use it for gaming (I use my Mac for everything else)... I…

Everybody should know by now that Windows 11 is a vastly inferior product compared to 10. Do not use it!!

I am not really sure if I could go so far as to say "vastly inferior". Windows 11 has its major issues but it also has some advantages when it comes to gaming and the xbox app.

Things seem to be more integrated (however clearly not fully given my issue I mentioned) on that front which for me is a good thing since this is a gaming pc.

Going with Windows 11 should have been an easy decision, but clearly they are screwing that up.

Re: Windows 11 is collecting more user data than you know

#45

I've got a macbook nearing end of life and frustration with apple (the company, not the hardware which I'm happy with) has been pushing me to consider windows. It's good to get these reminders of how smarmy Microsoft is. I think I'll probably grit my teeth and buy another mac

Go with Linux and don't look back. Preferably mint, which is quite similar to the Windows look. The only issue I've faced is MS Office, but that's what I have my Mac for.

Latest Mac (M2) hardware is just too good. My 2 year old desktop PC, which had top tier CPU, is now worse. It runs Linux but I can do the same stuff with Mac too. I even save with electricity bill by using Mac.

Re: Windows 11 is collecting more user data than you know

#46
post #31
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I switched to Ubuntu recently. Never looking back. There are still minor painpoints, but they pale in comparison with the mess that has become Windows.

Since this is really just a gaming PC I really don't feel comfortable going the linux route for it. I know there is proton, but at the end of the day what matters for me is that my games work, I can record and stream. I know Linux Gaming has come a long way but until all of my games are running natively, I don't want to make the switch. Its the same reason I don't just have a nice Mac.

Given your gaming background, I can see why you don't want a Mac. But Linux? I have two kids, aged 7 and 10. They would be very much 'not amused' if I'd propose them 'tux racer' or the likes... Steam works pretty much out of the box, and there's proton as you mentioned.

Perhaps you could install a second hard disk in your machine, and make it dual-boot? Just as a POC, and to get an idea of the state of Linux gaming.

Re: Windows 11 is collecting more user data than you know

#48
Microsoft knows they have 85+% of the consumer desktop/laptop market in the bag, and they're looking to build up an ad business through this telemetry.

Enterprise users are a captive audience - pay through the nose with year over year price hikes, or good luck with Linux. Microsoft's position is increasingly take it or leave it. When Microsoft lets Panos Panay ('head' of Windows) run these insane UI / UX experiments and foists it on Enterprise users via Windows 11/12, Microsoft is playing with fire. It's ridiculous to ask front line workers relearn tasks because some designer at Microsoft had too much caffeine and in a manic state decided to design some insane UX regression in Windows 11.

I would pay extra (more than a Windows 11 Pro license) to have a stripped down, Windows 2000 / NT Microsoft supported theme (I'm not installing UI/UX customizations from Stardock, sorry) that runs on the latest Windows kernel.

Other Enterprises want the same thing - UI / UX stability, running on the current Windows kernel.

Re: Windows 11 is collecting more user data than you know

#49
post #16

I recently rebuilt my computer and figured I would just go with Windows 11 to have all the new features and compatibility. I have been seriously debating on reinstalling and going back to 10. Just yesterday "gaming services" just decided it no longer wanted to run. With the talk of how much data this thing collects it really makes me uneasy. Even though I only use it for gaming (I use my Mac for everything else)... I…

I mean is windows 10 collecting less data? I doubt it.

I remember seeing the same articles coming out when 10 came out. At the time there was also mention that they back ported the same collection schemes into win 7 updates.

Re: Windows 11 is collecting more user data than you know

#50
post #31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Since this is really just a gaming PC I really don't feel comfortable going the linux route for it. I know there is proton, but at the end of the day what matters for me is that my games work, I can record and stream. I know Linux Gaming has come a long way but until all of my games are running natively, I don't want to make the switch. Its the same reason I don't just have a nice Mac.

Indeed. Linux is a no go for me. I don't use Steam, also I use DosBox a lot and tinker with a ton of stuff related to games. When it comes to gaming, nothing compares to Windows by a long shot. Unfortunately.

I think you would be surprised. Certainly DosBox will continue to work exactly the same way on Linux as you are used to on Windows.
Post reply on HN