Live data from Hacker News

Harvard Statistics 110: Introduction to Probability, on iTunes

itunes.apple.com

21–30 of 47 posts

Re: Harvard Statistics 110: Introduction to Probability, on iTunes

#21

Is there any way to watch this without iTunes? I don't use it and have no desire to join Apple's 'ecosystem'.

If you are using GNU/Linux then there is an alternative http://tunesviewer.sourceforge.net/

This works on Ubuntu 11.10. There is a lot of quality content on ITunes and using Ubuntu as my main OS meant I couldn't access it. But this is awesome! I can finally download those lecture videos. Thank you!

Re: Harvard Statistics 110: Introduction to Probability, on iTunes

#22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This storm in a teacup fear mongering stuff has to stop. It's silly to suggest this is locking in content, or even bad for anyone, and it's obvious why they use this distribution method over hosting the content themselves. 1. It's not in a proprietary format, the documents are PDF, the videos are AAC/H264. (I give up the h264 debate for today). Having to run iTunes to access the store is hardly "lock in". You might a…

1) As posted in my other comment - I'm currently at the airport with my android, and no way to get this content. If it's not locked in, how do I access the data? When I get home I'll have to install itunes. Which will add the apple updater + bonjour to my system as well. 2-4) I agree completely with your arguments regarding the benefits to Harvard. You're saying the same thing in three different ways though, Harvard…

Your definition of lock-in needs a reality check.

If my pocket calculator can't access the internet, it doesn't make the internet 'lock-in'.

Re: Harvard Statistics 110: Introduction to Probability, on iTunes

#23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

1) As posted in my other comment - I'm currently at the airport with my android, and no way to get this content. If it's not locked in, how do I access the data? When I get home I'll have to install itunes. Which will add the apple updater + bonjour to my system as well. 2-4) I agree completely with your arguments regarding the benefits to Harvard. You're saying the same thing in three different ways though, Harvard…

Your definition of lock-in needs a reality check. If my pocket calculator can't access the internet, it doesn't make the internet 'lock-in'.

Pocket calculator designers can implement internet support. Android developers cannot legally implement an iTunes store (I hastily assume).

Re: Harvard Statistics 110: Introduction to Probability, on iTunes

#24
I think it is great that Harvard and Stanford open their course material on the internet but can someone explain to me why they would do it? I mean, what is in it for them - a bit of PR and friendly headlines aside? Their name and status alone is enough to stay "in business".

Re: Harvard Statistics 110: Introduction to Probability, on iTunes

#25
post #24

I think it is great that Harvard and Stanford open their course material on the internet but can someone explain to me why they would do it? I mean, what is in it for them - a bit of PR and friendly headlines aside? Their name and status alone is enough to stay "in business".

Harvard and Stanford (and other big name universities) are in the business of "selling" diplomas, not content. You cannot put on your resume that you "aced" a Harvard iTunes course, but only that you graduated from Harvard. I applaud these institutions for realizing it and allowing others to benefit from the content. Think of it as the public library model -- you can certainly pick up Tocqueville or Newton writing and read it, but it offers no guarantee of your mastery of the material. The diploma (supposedly) gives you that badge.

Re: Harvard Statistics 110: Introduction to Probability, on iTunes

#26
post #25
post #24

I think it is great that Harvard and Stanford open their course material on the internet but can someone explain to me why they would do it? I mean, what is in it for them - a bit of PR and friendly headlines aside? Their name and status alone is enough to stay "in business".

Harvard and Stanford (and other big name universities) are in the business of "selling" diplomas, not content. You cannot put on your resume that you "aced" a Harvard iTunes course, but only that you graduated from Harvard. I applaud these institutions for realizing it and allowing others to benefit from the content. Think of it as the public library model -- you can certainly pick up Tocqueville or Newton writing an…

Yes, I understand that but the question then still is... why would they spend time, money and resources to give you all that material for free? Other institutions in the "diploma business" will surely peek and try to keep up and I do not see or understand the benefit for Harvard, Stanford et al. if we are not talking altruistic purposes.

Don't get me wrong, I think it is fantastic they do it and I applaud them - it is just really surprising and I am wondering about their motives, just my own (economic) curiosity.

Re: Harvard Statistics 110: Introduction to Probability, on iTunes

#27
post #26
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Harvard and Stanford (and other big name universities) are in the business of "selling" diplomas, not content. You cannot put on your resume that you "aced" a Harvard iTunes course, but only that you graduated from Harvard. I applaud these institutions for realizing it and allowing others to benefit from the content. Think of it as the public library model -- you can certainly pick up Tocqueville or Newton writing an…

Yes, I understand that but the question then still is... why would they spend time, money and resources to give you all that material for free? Other institutions in the "diploma business" will surely peek and try to keep up and I do not see or understand the benefit for Harvard, Stanford et al. if we are not talking altruistic purposes. Don't get me wrong, I think it is fantastic they do it and I applaud them - it i…

I think the prestige of a university is tied more to the quality of their research, their legacy as an institution and the reputation of instructors they attract (which need not have anything to do with actual ability to instruct) than the quality of the content or instruction. I don't think the other institutions in the "diploma business" can replicate that as easily.

Re: Harvard Statistics 110: Introduction to Probability, on iTunes

#28
post #24

I think it is great that Harvard and Stanford open their course material on the internet but can someone explain to me why they would do it? I mean, what is in it for them - a bit of PR and friendly headlines aside? Their name and status alone is enough to stay "in business".

Showing off.

Re: Harvard Statistics 110: Introduction to Probability, on iTunes

#29
post #26
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Harvard and Stanford (and other big name universities) are in the business of "selling" diplomas, not content. You cannot put on your resume that you "aced" a Harvard iTunes course, but only that you graduated from Harvard. I applaud these institutions for realizing it and allowing others to benefit from the content. Think of it as the public library model -- you can certainly pick up Tocqueville or Newton writing an…

Yes, I understand that but the question then still is... why would they spend time, money and resources to give you all that material for free? Other institutions in the "diploma business" will surely peek and try to keep up and I do not see or understand the benefit for Harvard, Stanford et al. if we are not talking altruistic purposes. Don't get me wrong, I think it is fantastic they do it and I applaud them - it i…

I believe that it is about being adopters to new technology. Some of these things will be incorporated into the future of learning.

No Ivy League school is suffering from profits and, as was posted, the degree from the school holds the most value. It also would help future potential students be aware of what is demanded of them in these academic institutions and potentially give them a chance to learn more should they choose to do so.

Re: Harvard Statistics 110: Introduction to Probability, on iTunes

#30
post #27
post #26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, I understand that but the question then still is... why would they spend time, money and resources to give you all that material for free? Other institutions in the "diploma business" will surely peek and try to keep up and I do not see or understand the benefit for Harvard, Stanford et al. if we are not talking altruistic purposes. Don't get me wrong, I think it is fantastic they do it and I applaud them - it i…

I think the prestige of a university is tied more to the quality of their research, their legacy as an institution and the reputation of instructors they attract (which need not have anything to do with actual ability to instruct) than the quality of the content or instruction. I don't think the other institutions in the "diploma business" can replicate that as easily.

And these are all good points why it does not HURT them to do that.

But my question was... why DID they do it?

Post reply on HN