Live data from Hacker News

PhpBB 3.3.10

phpbb.com

11–20 of 203 posts

Re: PhpBB 3.3.10

#11

I'm surprised it's still around. They did a good job on the software, but discussion forums seemed to go belly-up, after Facebook took off (MySpace, too, I guess). Maybe they will make a comeback?

Forums were doing just fine during the golden age of Facebook, at least in my generation. I thought what made forums go belly-up was reddit. Once reddit became a mainstream social media, there was no need for niche forums as anyone could just create a subreddit.

Re: PhpBB 3.3.10

#12

I'm surprised it's still around. They did a good job on the software, but discussion forums seemed to go belly-up, after Facebook took off (MySpace, too, I guess). Maybe they will make a comeback?

Yeah I remember using lots of phpBB forums back in the mid 2000s but it seems like Discord is now the replacement.

The few forums that I still use seem to run vBulletin or Invision (both PHP bulletin boards but both paid software).

Re: PhpBB 3.3.10

#13
post #5

This goes on to prove that PHP is still relevant today. No matter how many new frameworks come up, we all know PHP anyways.

I think this applies mainly because of WordPress, not PhpBB and any other project.

I think MediaWiki is another seminal PHP project.

Re: PhpBB 3.3.10

#14

I'm surprised it's still around. They did a good job on the software, but discussion forums seemed to go belly-up, after Facebook took off (MySpace, too, I guess). Maybe they will make a comeback?

Forums were doing just fine during the golden age of Facebook, at least in my generation. I thought what made forums go belly-up was reddit. Once reddit became a mainstream social media, there was no need for niche forums as anyone could just create a subreddit.

Could be - at least the communities I used to participate in seem to use Discord now.

Re: PhpBB 3.3.10

#15

Forum software of phpBB's era got so many things right that we get wrong today. I'm glad it's still chugging along. It's valuable software, even if that value is contained to small islands outside of the continents that are the mega-platforms of social media.

One bad thing about old forum threads is a lot of the images are lost. Disk space and bandwidth were still expensive back then. The free image hosts mostly disappeared or started charging (so many forums have dead photobucket links).

Re: PhpBB 3.3.10

#16
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Drupal is up there, maybe not as a household name like WordPress, but in some big organizations.

Drupal's been on the heavy decline over the past 10 years. Drupal 8/9/10 might turn it around now that Drupal 7 is set to officially retire eventually but it's not had the staying power in the way Wordpress has. Drupal doesn't really seem to have an ecosystem left anymore.

It had some decent developers and ecosystem around it a few years ago, but honestly a lot of bureaucracy and drama killed a lot of the enthusiasm in the project and contributed modules for many.

Re: PhpBB 3.3.10

#17
post #9

Every time I see hype about Mastodon and the fediverse I miss the phpBB days. There was something special about the interlocking network of forums that didn't need to "federate" in any formal capacity. We just joined communities we liked and formed overlapping networks like normal people do and always have done. No one at the time felt any need to try to accommodate the whole world in one venue. As someone who never…

One definining characteristic of internet media is where they rank on the "transience" spectrum.

The most extreme end probably being some old school chat apps and IRC on one side, and encylopedic wiki's (not the only kind) on the other. And while both forums and Usenet were closely rooted in current conversation, they had a more long-standing meaning, too. Where you could follow whole discussions even years later and where the writing style recognized this, often having single posts that more closely resemble articles.

Twitter and Mastodon seem a lot more ephemeral. As do sites like this or reddit, after all, they're concerned with "news".

StackOverflow seems closer to the forums of olden time out of most of the contemporary outlets.

So apart from the UI, you might miss that different conversational character resulting out of this.

As a final note, I do miss Wikis like the original one, where you had a lot of long-standing information, but with a conversational bent.

Re: PhpBB 3.3.10

#18

I'm surprised it's still around. They did a good job on the software, but discussion forums seemed to go belly-up, after Facebook took off (MySpace, too, I guess). Maybe they will make a comeback?

Forums were doing just fine during the golden age of Facebook, at least in my generation. I thought what made forums go belly-up was reddit. Once reddit became a mainstream social media, there was no need for niche forums as anyone could just create a subreddit.

Facebook did kill off some forums, where the built-in ability to invite or ad-target a very specific audience to a group in Facebook could grow a FB group quickly. Also, no friction of signup and verify email, etc.

Re: PhpBB 3.3.10

#19
post #17
post #9

Every time I see hype about Mastodon and the fediverse I miss the phpBB days. There was something special about the interlocking network of forums that didn't need to "federate" in any formal capacity. We just joined communities we liked and formed overlapping networks like normal people do and always have done. No one at the time felt any need to try to accommodate the whole world in one venue. As someone who never…

One definining characteristic of internet media is where they rank on the "transience" spectrum. The most extreme end probably being some old school chat apps and IRC on one side, and encylopedic wiki's (not the only kind) on the other. And while both forums and Usenet were closely rooted in current conversation, they had a more long-standing meaning, too. Where you could follow whole discussions even years later and…

It’s not about what’s written, it’s about engagement and advertising. The more ephemeral the better! Then that fomo kicks in and engagement is through the roof. That is, until some rich guy buys it and runs it into the ground.

Re: PhpBB 3.3.10

#20
post #9

Every time I see hype about Mastodon and the fediverse I miss the phpBB days. There was something special about the interlocking network of forums that didn't need to "federate" in any formal capacity. We just joined communities we liked and formed overlapping networks like normal people do and always have done. No one at the time felt any need to try to accommodate the whole world in one venue. As someone who never…

As someone who never understood the appeal of Twitter or Facebook, the new wave of FOSS social apps feels very alien to me.

Forums felt like writing emails in the open.

Twitter felt like texting in the open.

Not sure what the next thing will be! I say this as someone with 1k+ posts on multiple forums (essentially archived at this point).

Post reply on HN