Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Universal Summarizer

labs.kagi.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

81–90 of 172 posts

Re: Universal Summarizer

#81

Post by alexashka »

When I link it to a well known piece of text, does it go to its wikipedia page (or something of the sort) and summarize that, instead of analyzing the actual text?

For example I linked to Thus Spoke Zarathustra by Nietzsche - I got a summary that highly resembles something a wiki page would say about the text and quite unlike what I'd expect from reading the text itself.

I've gotten a very similar feeling giving it Plato's Republic.

Update: I've linked it to The Idiot by Dostoevsky and it didn't do well at all. Strange piece of technology - reminiscent of ChatGPT.

Re: Universal Summarizer

#82

Post by rdhyee »

rdhyee wrote: post #79

Not sure what to make of its summary of Moby Dick (as presented in the Project Gutenberg text version) -- https://labs.kagi.com/ai/sum?url=https://www.gutenberg.org/f... . The summary is full of platitudes. I'm wondering how they were generated. Did they actually arise directly from the text itself or from outside commentary of Moby Dick that Kagi had ingested? > The story follows the adventures of a whaling crew led…

Compare the summary of the book to the summary of the Wikipedia article on Moby Dick (https://labs.kagi.com/ai/sum?url=https://en.wikipedia.org/wi...)

> Moby-Dick is a novel by Herman Melville about the obsessive quest of Ahab, captain of the whaling ship Pequod, for revenge on the white sperm whale Moby Dick, which crippled him on the ship's previous voyage. The novel follows Ishmael, a sailor on the Pequod, as he narrates the story of Ahab's monomaniacal pursuit of Moby Dick. Along the way, Ishmael and his fellow crew members encounter a variety of characters and situations, including the mysterious Fedallah, a harpooner who prophesies Ahab's death; Pip, a young African American cabin-boy who jumps in panic from Stubb's whale boat; and the Delight, a whaling ship that is badly damaged and with five of her crew left dead by Moby Dick. The novel also contains a variety of themes, including the nature of evil, the power of fate, and the search for identity. Ultimately, the novel suggests that while revenge may be a powerful motivator, it can also lead to destruction and death.

Re: Universal Summarizer

#83

Post by rdhyee »

One of the things I find myself doing a lot is trying to make sense of a given HN discussion -- so I fed an archived version of this discussion to the summarizer: (https://labs.kagi.com/ai/sum?url=https://archive.is/HdWx7):

> Universal Summarizer is a tool developed by Kagi that is able to quickly and accurately summarize articles, videos, and other texts. It is able to pick out unique and interesting details from the text, such as Ratz having a prosthetic arm in the bar in the novel Catch 22. It is also able to summarize technical documentation and Moby Dick, as well as provide a summary of the themes in Walden. It is able to summarize videos as well, and is a useful tool for developers to familiarize themselves with academic papers. It is also able to provide summaries in multiple languages, and is able to detect jokes and humorous elements in the text. It is an impressive tool that is sure to be a hit with developers and researchers alike.

Re: Universal Summarizer

#84

Post by freediver »

rkagerer wrote: post #72

I asked it to summarize this HN comment page, and all it talks about are the Turner Diaries. Any idea why it's fixated on impalallama's comment? https://labs.kagi.com/ai/sum?url=https://archive.ph/3JDtf

It is because of the cache, as someone probably summarized the page very early on.

Current summary straight from the API:

"Universal Summarizer is a tool developed by Kagi that is able to quickly and accurately summarize articles, videos, and other texts. It is able to pick out unique and interesting details from the text, such as the fact that a character in a book has a prosthetic arm, or that a certain card is legal in Legacy but not in Modern or Historic. It is also able to provide summaries of complex texts, such as Herman Melville's Moby Dick, and even provide summaries of technical documentation. It is also able to summarize texts in different languages, such as Spanish. The tool is also able to provide summaries of videos, and is able to provide summaries of texts that are difficult to summarize, such as the allegories and humor in the Tao of Programming. It is an impressive tool that is sure to be a great asset to the Kagi search engine, and could be used to improve the results and UI of the main search product."

Re: Universal Summarizer

#85

Post by freediver »

imbnwa wrote: post #48

Anybody else's first instinct was to get the summary of the Christian Bible? Isn't able to complete the task in case you're interested with the source[0] I submitted. [0] http://triggs.djvu.org/djvu-editions.com/BIBLES/DRV/Download...

It can ! We set the timeout lower as this got on HN to make sure it worked for everyone. Ran this document in backened directly and it worked. It is 1600 pages of text and it took about 3 mins, but it did produce a summary! To see what, check tomorrow as we lift the timeout restriction :)

Re: Universal Summarizer

#86

Post by dannywarner »

GaggiX wrote: post #80
dannywarner wrote: post #77

Fwiw I use AndiSearch and they already have a great summarizer integrated directly into search results that they launched last week. There is a Summarize button on every result card that can show a summary. The summaries are much faster. And they are clearly much higher quality. Unlike Kagi, they don't spam every HN post that mentions search with shill comments. And unlike Kagi, it is free and anyone can use it. It d…

I have never used AndiSearch, how can I summarize a video, book or pdf with it like Kagi's "universal" summarizer?

I find it does well with ebooks. I haven't tried with pdfs or videos. The quality of the AndiSearch summaries for the things I use every day like articles, Wikipedia and technical documentation is very good.

The Summarize button is on the search results, therefore you don't need to visit a separate site and paste in the url. Additionally, you already know when a summary is available as the button only shows when it is. It is new but already I feel that it changes how you use a search engine having this feature available right there on the results.

The Kagi one said 'No summary available at this moment, please try again later.' for many of the urls I tried.

Re: Universal Summarizer

#87

Post by dannywarner »

GaggiX wrote: post #80
dannywarner wrote: post #77

Fwiw I use AndiSearch and they already have a great summarizer integrated directly into search results that they launched last week. There is a Summarize button on every result card that can show a summary. The summaries are much faster. And they are clearly much higher quality. Unlike Kagi, they don't spam every HN post that mentions search with shill comments. And unlike Kagi, it is free and anyone can use it. It d…

I have never used AndiSearch, how can I summarize a video, book or pdf with it like Kagi's "universal" summarizer?

Also, being realistic, I do not believe that many normal people try to summarize the full text of old public domain ebooks. If you search for Moby Dick, much better resources come up, and that is what you want a summary for. People want a summary when they are searching to know if they should read more.

Re: Universal Summarizer

#89

Post by imbnwa »

freediver wrote: post #85
imbnwa wrote: post #48

Anybody else's first instinct was to get the summary of the Christian Bible? Isn't able to complete the task in case you're interested with the source[0] I submitted. [0] http://triggs.djvu.org/djvu-editions.com/BIBLES/DRV/Download...

It can ! We set the timeout lower as this got on HN to make sure it worked for everyone. Ran this document in backened directly and it worked. It is 1600 pages of text and it took about 3 mins, but it did produce a summary! To see what, check tomorrow as we lift the timeout restriction :)

OK, now we're talking.

Re: Universal Summarizer

#90

Post by GaggiX »

dannywarner wrote: post #86
GaggiX wrote: post #80

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have never used AndiSearch, how can I summarize a video, book or pdf with it like Kagi's "universal" summarizer?

I find it does well with ebooks. I haven't tried with pdfs or videos. The quality of the AndiSearch summaries for the things I use every day like articles, Wikipedia and technical documentation is very good. The Summarize button is on the search results, therefore you don't need to visit a separate site and paste in the url. Additionally, you already know when a summary is available as the button only shows when it i…

>I haven't tried with pdfs or videos

It does seem it's not able to do that.

>The Kagi one said 'No summary available at this moment, please try again later.' for many of the urls I tried.

I honestly find AndiSearch more finicky in not showing the "Summarize" button or giving error.

Post reply on HN