Live data from Hacker News

A manifesto on shower temperature control

benholmen.com

61–70 of 176 posts

Re: A manifesto on shower temperature control

#61
The amount of water wasted waiting for the water to warm up must be astronomical. In my place it can take three or four minutes of the water running to get warm - if not longer - and I don't think that's atypical.

Multiply this by 7 days a week by everyone who showers in California alone and it seems like an issue that should get some serious attention.

Re: A manifesto on shower temperature control

#62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So we need like a capacitor for hot water at the shower head.

Or just active control? Set a desired output water temp, and let a computer constantly fiddle with the valves slightly to keep the output constant. Monitoring the current temp of the input lines would help but not be necessary. I mostly don't like that every few minutes, I have to turn down the cold water a smidge, as fresher colder water from the ground comes up through the pipe. My shower has two valves for hot and…

Interestingly, control valves employed in this way tend to wear out very quickly or else they are slow and expensive so that they can be made more durable. Anybody working on this needs to hit that "good, fast and cheap" triple point.

This is why wax motors are commonly used as valve actuators since the only calibrations are the wax mixture, the mechanical force applicator, and the thermal resistance of various components in contact with each other

Re: A manifesto on shower temperature control

#63

On a FIRST robot, we needed something similar. There's "full reverse", "full forward" and "I need fine control", and the original mapping of joystick to wheel motors was linear. It didn't work well for "fine control". We ended up with motor = joystick³ (or some other odd, greater than 1 power; it might have been ⁵). Then you fix, via coefficients, the endpoints of the equation such that the lowest joystick value hits…

When my wife and I met she lived in an apartment with an amazing shower. The pressure was good but the temperature was fantastic. I had never had an apartment shower with water that got so hot. I barely even went half-way on the knob before I was turning it down. I asked about it and her response was "oh yeah I complained to my dad and he looked at the heater, there was something on it that he broke off." Turns out there was some piece of plastic or something put on by the landlord to limit the top temperature of the water, so he took it off.

It didn't keep the hot water from running out but when you had it, it was great.

Re: A manifesto on shower temperature control

#64
I'm obsessed with showers and also wonder why we are so spectacularly bad at making consistently good showerheads with consistently good pressure and temperature control.

One issue the author overlooks is that we have minimal control over the temperature of the cold water, and this temperature fluctuates throughout the year (at least here in NY, not so much where I lived in SF). As a result, the range of the dial I use changes from summer to winter. There are hot parts of the dial I use everyday in the winter that would simply burn me if I used them in the summer.

Temperature can even change during the course of the shower! I notice this mostly in the winter. I speculate this is due to the cold water in my building pipes being used up and then replaced by the truly cold water from underground. I once tried to shower with that icy water when the hot water went out (just before a big trip) and I managed to completely numb my lower body (I did not have the fortitude to try and shower my upper body too).

Re: A manifesto on shower temperature control

#65

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So we need like a capacitor for hot water at the shower head.

Or just active control? Set a desired output water temp, and let a computer constantly fiddle with the valves slightly to keep the output constant. Monitoring the current temp of the input lines would help but not be necessary. I mostly don't like that every few minutes, I have to turn down the cold water a smidge, as fresher colder water from the ground comes up through the pipe. My shower has two valves for hot and…

You don't need a computer, or even electricity. Thermostatic shower valves are 100% mechanical, and work beautifully. There are models available that will automatically compensate for both temperature and pressure changes, keeping the output temperature constant.

Re: A manifesto on shower temperature control

#66
post #4

I have one of these grohe thermostatic valves. You can set the temperature and then use a push button to turn the shower on. The temperature is always set correctly as the on/off is separate from the temperature control. A majority of the range of the dial is usable. We still use cold water for cleaning the shower, or when you want a cold shower. During the shower, I have it set to hot, then slowly turn up the heat.…

I have a Gröhe thermostatic valve which came with the house. It's somehow broken such that you can't get the water as hot as advertised unless the dishwasher is running (?). And it's installed behind tile, so we can't just get a plumber to come in and replace it; we have to also line up someone to re-tile the shower immediately afterward.

We also have a pair of Gröhe sinks. We had to replace all four expensive, proprietary faucet hoses one-by-one as they ruptured. And then a couple more. It turns out they're short enough that it's hard to install them without kinking, and that eventually causes them to rupture.

I'm not a Gröhe fan.

(It also takes several minutes for the water to come to temperature in that particular shower, though it's only about 10 feet away from the water heater. I think the sink fixtures are affected too which suggests it's not all the shower valve's fault. It might be that we have pipes that are indirect and/or way too high-capacity, such that the total volume of water to drain between the water heater and the bathroom is excessive, and this is particularly obvious when using a low-flow shower-head.)

Re: A manifesto on shower temperature control

#67

On a FIRST robot, we needed something similar. There's "full reverse", "full forward" and "I need fine control", and the original mapping of joystick to wheel motors was linear. It didn't work well for "fine control". We ended up with motor = joystick³ (or some other odd, greater than 1 power; it might have been ⁵). Then you fix, via coefficients, the endpoints of the equation such that the lowest joystick value hits…

>(And, apparently, as I learned, there's a mixing valve at the hot water heater: i.e., the hot to the shower is not direct from the water heater, like I had imagined. We raised the temp there, slightly.)

When we changed from instant hot water to water tank + heat pump, the guy said the tempering valve was a safety thing (IIRC ours was set to 60 degrees Celsius by default, but could go up or down about 10 degree either way). That is, if you accidentally step in the shower with only hot water on you'll still hurt yourself but the damage will be limited to "strong profanity and aloe vera" instead of "you've won a stay in the burn ward".

Although saying this, I did a quick bit of research and found that 60 may still be too high [1]. I have an IR thermometer so I think I'll measure the temperature of my shower (after any loss from pipes etc.) and see if the tempering valve needs adjusting down.

[1] mild nsfw - image of scalded foot https://whywait.com.au/a-serious-hot-water-burn-occurs-in-on...

Re: A manifesto on shower temperature control

#68
post #8

> † The author acknowledges the recent trend of "cold showers" and considers them (a) a trend, (b) undignified, (c) a waste of some life-sustaining solidary time. Hear, hear!

I always end my showers with cool water because it works wonders for preventing dryness and itchiness on my skin. I use actually cold water to rinse my scalp.

This is all very different than a shower with no hot water mixed in whatsoever. Deepening on the climate and season, water that cold can cause physical harm. In other words, I'm betting most of these "cold showerers" are actually use cool water, not anything as dramatically cold as they might want us to infer.

Re: A manifesto on shower temperature control

#70
Our shower has two dials: temperature and pressure. The temperature dial has a specific temperature that it will "snap" to. (When increasing temperature, it will stop there unless you hold in a button. It doesn't snap when decreasing the temperature.) Generally, I find the temperature it snaps to quite pleasant, so I just put it at the snap temperature and then open for the water with the other dial.
Post reply on HN