Live data from Hacker News

How to get new ideas

paulgraham.com

201–210 of 222 posts

Re: How to get new ideas

#201

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can still do things like client-side prediction with streaming, but imagine if you controlled all of the clients and could always trust them. You could have the actual simulation running in a big bunker in Ohio somewhere on entirely synchronous terms ( The game concept itself can be engineered around vertical scale constraints. For instance, imagine flight routes in WoW. If the cost to take a flight was modulated…

> but imagine if you controlled all of the clients and could always trust them This will eliminate a few checks like teleporting/wall passing etc but you still can't trust the client, rest will shift to ML based cheating methods: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DlsBaQWfE58

True - you always have to deal with the final frontier. There are still very powerful statistical/hybrid systems that can be employed to mitigate cheaters.

You can combine many factors to close the last mile. Getting privileged information off the client machine is a huge part of the battle. The rest can be dealt with using clever tricks, stats, etc.

For example, imagine a game where you are using this ML aimbot to lock onto players heads. The developer could design a ramping detection system like:

  1. Statistical detection - outlier in performance. Begin deeper analysis.
  2. Review player inputs using our own ml models to determine likelihood.
  3. Escalate to active measures - in-game canaries to bait the aimbot into very unlikely, inhuman responses.

Re: How to get new ideas

#202
post #101

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You don't have to cynically exploit your customers just because that's what other businesses do. If you can make an excellent product that solves a real problem and charge a reasonable price for it you'll likely do pretty well. Sure, other people will become immensely successful by cheating or by gaming the system in some way. But what difference does that make? Just do your own thing.

> gaming the system I think this is the point. Because the game is actually the psychology around why people buy shit. I can't make myself do that. For example. I can't ride the wave of hype because I don't believe its value is real or sustainable. Well a lot of excuse, right, that's why it's my trap.

> I can't make myself do that.

Then don't. Or maybe you subconsciously don't want to do the work or have no good ideas. That's OK. But I can't see how this cynical attitude serves you otherwise.

As a reminder YC's mantra is "build something people want". There are plenty of now wealthy people on this forum that did that. Some never even had to do marketing because customers were so happy.

Re: How to get new ideas

#203
post #93
post #42

Most things are strange, missing, broken for mundane reasons that you can't do much about. The space of new ideas is huge, but almost all new ideas are bad. One strategy I really like is to think of technologies you couldn't build 5 years ago but are just barely possible today. That's where yesterday's bad ideas become today's good ideas. For example, laptops and phones produced 20 years of incremental improvements i…

> One strategy I really like is to think of technologies you couldn't build 5 years ago but are just barely possible today. Streaming gaming is something I am still laser-focused on. Our networks are only getting faster. I feel there is a gigantic opportunity here that is being passed up by efforts like Stadia. To do this thing correctly, the game engine itself needs to be developed with these concerns in mind. Expec…

Is there a medium to contact you? Otherwise, my email is in my profile. Shot me a message.

Re: How to get new ideas

#204
post #113

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Would you mind giving a high-level summary of the physiology of mental health (like one paragraph or two, however much you like)? Just the main things that are currently known/believed.

The autonomic nervous system and the glymphatic nervous system are both things I never really learned about in schools. ANS is taught as a textbook fact of homeostasis, not the constant fight-or-flight reflex that’s on every second of every day and the impacts that causes on health. The glymphatic system has only been discovered in the last 10 years but helps explain why sleep deficits explain cognitive performance d…

robg wrote: "... And still so much we don’t know like gut-brain health and neuroelectronics as for implants!"

'What do sonnomes modify when added to olgosaccaride chains ?' answer provided by [1] seems to back that up.

[1] https://ask-paulg.up.railway.app/

Re: How to get new ideas

#205

Earlier quoted context omitted.

long as it's legal/legitimate, does it really matter if can make enough $$$ to earn a living? nerf was last minute class project.

It doesn't matter. But as I said, I can't make myself do it. I can't made up beuatiful words to describe pseudo values that I can't provide. For example, I don't believe in productivity app like timer that records many activity in a day, but people do really buy it I couldn't make myself believe .. like really? So when something is obviously good to sell, and I think it's dumb, I guess I can't make myself sell the th…

existenceblinks wrote: "... Ah it's a trap."

Well, all the more reason to thing in terms of trees/heaps & not traditional loops/recursive functional loops.

Let someone else handle the mark & sweep clean up.

Re: How to get new ideas

#206

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[1] has more researched 10 list. https://inventionland.com/blog/ten-kid-inventors-that-change...

The fact that one needs to google the list and even then may still fail to answer is kind of the point. The struggle to give an answer is the actual answer. This myth that children's ideas are somehow more valuable that adult's is nonsense. If this was true, businesses would organize and act on it. Parents would be hired to bring children into brainstorming sessions. Filled idea diaries would be sold and bought in bu…

somethinggreen wrote: "... This myth that children's ideas are somehow more valuable that adult's is nonsense. ..."

And who best motiates the parents to do something / spend $$ / go in a given direction? aka commercial supplying context(s) of idea(s) to child

somethinggreen wrote: "... Because the reality is: children are great, their ideas are useless, ..."

Only until that child understands what context to put that idea(s) in to make the idea(s) usable and/or what to do / to learn to be able to use the idea in context. Adults just have a larger context node pool to draw from.

Re: How to get new ideas

#207

Earlier quoted context omitted.

long as it's legal/legitimate, does it really matter if can make enough $$$ to earn a living? nerf was last minute class project.

It doesn't matter. But as I said, I can't make myself do it. I can't made up beuatiful words to describe pseudo values that I can't provide. For example, I don't believe in productivity app like timer that records many activity in a day, but people do really buy it I couldn't make myself believe .. like really? So when something is obviously good to sell, and I think it's dumb, I guess I can't make myself sell the th…

Seems to me like you're not much of a consumer yourself.

Me neither, I'm a producer.

So I sell to other producers.

Sometimes big ones.

Then one call does it all.

Yes it has to be good.

Re: How to get new ideas

#208
post #196

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Appreciate your effort. But I would say food is not a really good example. I can relate taste via tongue, it's something very understandable. I don't think I can trust bias(reasons) after bought something. > The point is if you think everything is bullshit, your analysis is probably crap. Yes, it is crap. Because as I say I most values I can't relate .. a lot of why > But it has to meet a need That's the problem. Mos…

Sure but that's an empathy problem. If you intend to sell anything to anyone you need to change your whole perspective. For example, say someone goes buys a mac because they think the software is pretty and they like having things managed. You can't argue they are mistaken because you could get a linux machine with freedom for much less. They don't want such a thing. Conversely, say someone buys a Linux machine becau…

I don't think they make mistake. Their preferences are just mediocre. .. Thank you for trying to help fix my toxic mindset. It is hard!

Re: How to get new ideas

#209

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> gaming the system I think this is the point. Because the game is actually the psychology around why people buy shit. I can't make myself do that. For example. I can't ride the wave of hype because I don't believe its value is real or sustainable. Well a lot of excuse, right, that's why it's my trap.

> I can't make myself do that. Then don't. Or maybe you subconsciously don't want to do the work or have no good ideas. That's OK. But I can't see how this cynical attitude serves you otherwise. As a reminder YC's mantra is "build something people want". There are plenty of now wealthy people on this forum that did that. Some never even had to do marketing because customers were so happy.

I don't get why they were so happy with avatar generator for example. I actually understand it's sort of fun. But $30 for that is a nope to me. This is why my mindset limits my idea space. I need to get out of that.

Re: How to get new ideas

#210

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It doesn't matter. But as I said, I can't make myself do it. I can't made up beuatiful words to describe pseudo values that I can't provide. For example, I don't believe in productivity app like timer that records many activity in a day, but people do really buy it I couldn't make myself believe .. like really? So when something is obviously good to sell, and I think it's dumb, I guess I can't make myself sell the th…

Seems to me like you're not much of a consumer yourself. Me neither, I'm a producer. So I sell to other producers. Sometimes big ones. Then one call does it all. Yes it has to be good.

Yes, I found myself a minimal consumer and I think it affects my producer side because I have less clue why people why things.
Post reply on HN