Earlier quoted context omitted.
What is this guild license, and how does it differ from the current system of having private companies own software licenses, tech patents, and trade secrets? It sounds to me like you're just describing a tech company.
It is a tech company but it is owned by specialized, skilled workers. It is a guild because tech workers are professional artisans. Guilds are an organization of skilled professionals which have quality certification for work, often times integrated with legal frameworks in a government. Software needs to be elevated, credentialed, regulated, and more respected. This is what a guild would enable. But I think merging…
You haven't convinced me that this is a thing desirable or plausible. You keep mentioning benefits that I feel I already have. You haven't convinced me that the technical output would be better than the current system. You haven't convinced me that there is a place for this in our current world, or that their is a reasonable growth path for the idea. In fact, the discussion is largely abstract. I wish you all the best with your idea, maybe there is something here than just isn't getting through to me right now.