Live data from Hacker News

Tell HN: MS forcing Edge shortcut on desktop

news.ycombinator.com

121–130 of 158 posts

Re: Tell HN: MS forcing Edge shortcut on desktop

#121
post #71

Speaking of, I'd love to get rid of the mandatory search bar on the Android home screen.

I think android let's you install whatever home screen you like

It does, although some devices (Samsung?) will force you back to the default homescreen with every reboot.

Other devices force you back to the default homescreen whenever you activate the google assistant via long pressing the home button, and you can't disable it.

Luckily both behaviours seem to be a minority.

Re: Tell HN: MS forcing Edge shortcut on desktop

#122
This isn't just an issue with Edge, Adobe Acrobat, and a few other apps (I forget which ones now) will add a shortcut to the desktop when they update.

It's super annoying, and doesn't seem to be a way to just disallow that behavior without uninstalling the apps (which I think with Edge you can't do anymore).

I'm very tempted to try a Linux installation on my next device, it might actually be worth the extra effort now.

Re: Tell HN: MS forcing Edge shortcut on desktop

#123
post #82

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> The only real issues these days are with anti-cheat stuff in competitive multiplayer games Every game I play is a competitive multiplayer game.

With which anticheats? BattleEye and EasyAnticheat work pretty well with Proton nowadays, you won't have luck with stuff like Ricochet though.

There are still big games with BE or EAC which either don't launch still, or will sometimes allow you to play offline on Linux but won't allow you to join servers with Proton. Some examples: PUBG, Dead by Daylight, Ubisoft games such as R6 and For Honor, and Destiny 2.

Extra links for those who want to look:

https://www.protondb.com/explore?selectedFilters=antiCheat&s...

https://areweanticheatyet.com/

Re: Tell HN: MS forcing Edge shortcut on desktop

#124
post #60

Just open up a command line, change directory to your Desktop, and type: attrib +h "Microsoft Edge.lnk" Then you never have to see it again.

Unless you have set hidden files as visible as some of us do.

You can add +s into the mix for "system file", AFAIK (this may have changed with recent versions of Windows 10 / 11) it is then controlled by the seperate "Hide Protected System Files" setting.

(But doesn't help if that setting is also disabled)

Re: Tell HN: MS forcing Edge shortcut on desktop

#125
post #93

Also windows 11 keeps enabling windows defender real time protection. This behavior is common on windows: do not respect user preferences.

not only W11, happened to me this week on W10 Pro after update, wasted minutes reenabling qbittorrent despite it was in exceptions already

Re: Tell HN: MS forcing Edge shortcut on desktop

#126

Can confirm this is happening as well. I keep deleting it but it keeps coming back. Oh well, I might write a script to delete it automatically.

But remember, it's Linux that's only free if you don't value your time;)

Definitely not to "time sink parity" with Linux just yet. Depending on what you need your machine for, of course.

Re: Tell HN: MS forcing Edge shortcut on desktop

#127
This is becoming such a nuisance.

Last week I had to invest so much brain power to get around Microsoft’s dark patterns after installing an update. No, I don’t want to use Edge because it’s “safer”. No, I don’t want to redeem one month “free” of 365. No, please don’t “protect” my files with OneDrive. I am getting angry again from just enumerating this.

Re: Tell HN: MS forcing Edge shortcut on desktop

#128
post #10

It appears as though you can add a registry entry to prevent this behavior. I found details in the ms.edge admx documentation https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/deployedge/microsoft-edge-... (An admx is for adding group policy templates but group policy is essentially a nice list of registry changes. You (reader) can find the reg entry and enter it manually or might can download and install the admx package and make t…

Well yes, sure there is a registry setting to disable this behavior, but why? Why is this not opt-in by default? When did I ever consent to having an Edge shortcut on my desktop? Why are we expected to just passively accept this kind of stupid behavior?

Re: Tell HN: MS forcing Edge shortcut on desktop

#129

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A theoretically perfect but largely non-viable solution.

if you're someone who is willing to invest time into researching regedit workarounds (which will eventually reset or cease to work), then looking into desktop linux is perfectly viable...and not theoretically, but practically perfect. i used to do an enormous amount of Windows XP regedit tweaking and customization, using sysprep, rolling service packs into new ISOs, making use of https://ryanvm.net/forum/ scripts. al…

I have tried switching to Linux in the past and it was not for me. As upsetting as Microsoft’s recent decisions have been, it is not enough to make me change operating systems.

Re: Tell HN: MS forcing Edge shortcut on desktop

#130
post #97

It's just a shame Windows is the only operating system in the world, otherwise we could all use something else.

Ah, but you see: my edge case. I cannot live this mortal life without my edge case and taking a stance as hellish as firing a VM, or dual booting on an NVMe device where the operation takes less than a minute, is just unimaginable, unendurable pain. I'm afraid there's nothing to be done and Windows must always be a part of life and thus I shall contribute to perpetuate the circle rather than make the slightest effort to slowly erode it over time.
Post reply on HN