Live data from Hacker News

Ain't it funny how the knight moves?

funnyhowtheknightmoves.com

131–140 of 211 posts

Re: Ain't it funny how the knight moves?

#131

I think the instructions should be: Move to the square indicated below the board without moving to a square the queen can capture and without capturing the queen. Once accomplished a new square will be indicated. Repeat until all possible squares are done.

another hidden UX: clicking a square will move the knight there (if valid move). do not have to drag and drop.

Re: Ain't it funny how the knight moves?

#132
post #79

I mapped out the structure of the board as a graph of which squares you can get to from which other squares. It's surprisingly stringy without all the squares forbidden by the queen placement. https://i.imgur.com/8OuQcu8.png

Same but with the original board as part of the visualization, and with different parts of the structure highlighted:

https://ibb.co/JFY3jm4

It made a lot more sense after doing that, as I'm nowhere near proficient enough at chess to see the board and all its moves in my mind's eye.

Re: Ain't it funny how the knight moves?

#134

I think the instructions should be: Move to the square indicated below the board without moving to a square the queen can capture and without capturing the queen. Once accomplished a new square will be indicated. Repeat until all possible squares are done.

Holy... is that what you're supposed to do?!? No wonder the bar wasn't growing even though I jumped to every possible square -.-

"It's a user error".. "Users are stupid".. "Why can't they just understand something so simple"

Re: Ain't it funny how the knight moves?

#135
post #39

As a teenager I had a chess lesson with Ben Finegold and I practiced this puzzle for weeks on a physical board. He also mentioned this riddle off hand which I had a ton of fun solving. https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/how-about-a-nice-game-o...

That is fun! It's interesting, the solution is presented here[1], but I'm pretty sure it's wrong (off by 19) due to not taking into account the possibility for the pawn to move two squares on its first move. [1] https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/can-you-survive-this-de...

That post says,

> Note: If you counted the pawn moving forward two squares with its initial move as distinct from its moving two individual squares, then there are 160 paths. Feeling generous, I gave full credit for either approach.

Re: Ain't it funny how the knight moves?

#136

In case anyone else goes nuts trying to write a program for a knight's tour with the additional queen constraint from this game: you can't get to B7. Obvious if you actually look at the board.

How is B7 more noteworthy than anywhere else that is under attack from the queen?

Re: Ain't it funny how the knight moves?

#137
post #63
post #49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How does that help you get to the indicated square?

I didn't actually realize the goal of the game was to do it all in order! The help text just says "Move the knight to every square, right to left, top to bottom."

I'm having difficulty understanding your difficulty in understanding. What did you think "right to left, top to bottom" meant?

Re: Ain't it funny how the knight moves?

#138

I think the instructions should be: Move to the square indicated below the board without moving to a square the queen can capture and without capturing the queen. Once accomplished a new square will be indicated. Repeat until all possible squares are done.

Thanks.

They wouldn't have to write any instruction nor add letters and numbers around the board (they are missing) if they marked the goal square. Even after I read your instructions I equivocated where f8 is. I actually moved to f1, then realized that's a long time since I looked at a chess diagram.

A demonstration of how a little detail can ruin a project.

Re: Ain't it funny how the knight moves?

#140
post #31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Holy... is that what you're supposed to do?!? No wonder the bar wasn't growing even though I jumped to every possible square -.-

Judging by this thread every single person did the same thing and became equally frustrated (myself included).

I'm confused. What "same thing" did everyone try? The instructions in the help section in the game seemed perfectly clear?
Post reply on HN