Live data from Hacker News

Apple Introduces the New HomePod

apple.com

11–20 of 34 posts

Re: Apple Introduces the New HomePod

#11

Does anyone have experience with the HomePod mini? Likewise, it’s not clear from Apple’s site wether or not a full size HomePod is required to use HomePod minus as part of a full home audio system

The Minis are basically the Google Home Mini/Alexa Dots of the Apple ecosystem. They're all standalone, you don't need any full sized HomePod to do anything.

If you want whole home audio, you can just buy the minis. They just operate via Wifi.

Re: Apple Introduces the New HomePod

#12
post #9
post #7

1. What is the difference between this and HomePod version 1? Because I'm struggling to see anything different to the original. 2. Does it come with a removable USB C cable or are you stuck with the stupid, permanently attached 1m cable that requires you to buy either power or USB C extension cables rather than just a longer usb c cable if you want to use it anywhere where there's not a socket?

This is the HomePod full size, not the Mini; the power cable is a standard power cable... not a USB-C cable. Differences vs. version 1 that I can see: * Thread Hub capabilities * Ultrawideband chip support, for locating devices * Fewer microphones/speakers compared to v1 * Slightly lighter? Probably from fewer speakers. Notably, the V1 HomePod was discontinued... so not a lot of that matters. You haven't been able to…

> Ultrawideband chip support, for locating devices

Excuse me? Are you trying to find your fat, lost homepod or find other lost devices with the fat homepod?

Re: Apple Introduces the New HomePod

#13
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is the HomePod full size, not the Mini; the power cable is a standard power cable... not a USB-C cable. Differences vs. version 1 that I can see: * Thread Hub capabilities * Ultrawideband chip support, for locating devices * Fewer microphones/speakers compared to v1 * Slightly lighter? Probably from fewer speakers. Notably, the V1 HomePod was discontinued... so not a lot of that matters. You haven't been able to…

> Ultrawideband chip support, for locating devices Excuse me? Are you trying to find your fat, lost homepod or find other lost devices with the fat homepod?

It also (should) handoff a lot more seamless, as seen on the HomePod mini

Re: Apple Introduces the New HomePod

#14
Agggrrrr so much hate for these devices. I bought a Mini for my oldest kid and now, when I pick up my phone in my downstairs office, hold it near my mouth, and say "hey Siri set an alarm at 7am", the phone briefly shows the Siri vortex and then stops. And I find out at 7am when my sad and confused daughter is startled out of bed that her stupid HomePod upstairs on the opposite side the house picked up what must've been to it an almost inaudible command.

Re: Apple Introduces the New HomePod

#15
post #7

1. What is the difference between this and HomePod version 1? Because I'm struggling to see anything different to the original. 2. Does it come with a removable USB C cable or are you stuck with the stupid, permanently attached 1m cable that requires you to buy either power or USB C extension cables rather than just a longer usb c cable if you want to use it anywhere where there's not a socket?

IIRC the power cable is not permanently attached it's just very strongly attached but removable

Re: Apple Introduces the New HomePod

#16
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is the HomePod full size, not the Mini; the power cable is a standard power cable... not a USB-C cable. Differences vs. version 1 that I can see: * Thread Hub capabilities * Ultrawideband chip support, for locating devices * Fewer microphones/speakers compared to v1 * Slightly lighter? Probably from fewer speakers. Notably, the V1 HomePod was discontinued... so not a lot of that matters. You haven't been able to…

> Ultrawideband chip support, for locating devices Excuse me? Are you trying to find your fat, lost homepod or find other lost devices with the fat homepod?

It think it's mainly used for determining if your phone/ipad/whatever is close to the homepod so it can do the handoff of music seamlessly. The minis have it too, but the original homepod did not.

Re: Apple Introduces the New HomePod

#17

Agggrrrr so much hate for these devices. I bought a Mini for my oldest kid and now, when I pick up my phone in my downstairs office, hold it near my mouth, and say "hey Siri set an alarm at 7am", the phone briefly shows the Siri vortex and then stops. And I find out at 7am when my sad and confused daughter is startled out of bed that her stupid HomePod upstairs on the opposite side the house picked up what must've be…

I have turned off "Hey Siri" on mine. This can be done within the Home app.

Re: Apple Introduces the New HomePod

#18

Agggrrrr so much hate for these devices. I bought a Mini for my oldest kid and now, when I pick up my phone in my downstairs office, hold it near my mouth, and say "hey Siri set an alarm at 7am", the phone briefly shows the Siri vortex and then stops. And I find out at 7am when my sad and confused daughter is startled out of bed that her stupid HomePod upstairs on the opposite side the house picked up what must've be…

I really wish we could name individual devices so we can target Siri request to specific devices. Partially for situations like you describe.

Also not all siri+device combos can do the same things. Our HomePod is not customized so anyone can use it for basic things like playing music but then it can't do personalized tasks like set reminders. Some apps only exist on some devices and a Siri request involving those will fail on other devices.

I've turned off "hey Siri" for most devices and only use it for the HomePods who really need it to be useful. For my phone or watch, I hold down the button and the whisper to the device hoping the HomePod down the hall doesn't hear and start playing something in the living room I only wanted to play in my office.

Re: Apple Introduces the New HomePod

#20
post #7

1. What is the difference between this and HomePod version 1? Because I'm struggling to see anything different to the original. 2. Does it come with a removable USB C cable or are you stuck with the stupid, permanently attached 1m cable that requires you to buy either power or USB C extension cables rather than just a longer usb c cable if you want to use it anywhere where there's not a socket?

IIRC the power cable is not permanently attached it's just very strongly attached but removable

[deleted]
Post reply on HN