Live data from Hacker News

Eggs are 60% more expensive than last year in the US

semafor.com

91–100 of 389 posts

Re: Eggs are 60% more expensive than last year in the US

#91

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As an athlete who eats like a highschool linebacker (in Colorado), I've been watching eggs prices climb up $0.50 each week for a dozen, then jump $3 in one week. Now there's none on the shelves at all.

[flagged]

Treating the short term adjustment effects of a new rule as the same as the eventual steady state impact of the rule makes arguments against new rules seem deceptive and misleading

Re: Eggs are 60% more expensive than last year in the US

#93
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Actually there’s more. On Jan 1st several more states laws about animal welfare went into effect whereas before essentially only California had those requirements. The supply of eggs meeting those requirements had not been ramped up to meet the step in demand. I expect that disruption will be temporary.

So why then are my Pasture Raised Organic eggs increasing at the same rate as budget eggs. These regulations would not impact those operations

Because the seller of those eggs can raise prices while they are (at least for now) in possession of an item which has excess demand relative to supply. You could look at this as compensation for early adoption of tighter regulations, as a natural variation in the prospects of their business, or as evil price-gouging. Which you choose to focus on is a choice that will vary from person to person.

Re: Eggs are 60% more expensive than last year in the US

#95
post #36

My wife has a cottage baking business and would buy 15 dozen eggs from Costco Business Center. Already high, a few months back in cost about $45 for the box. Just last week it was $110. She doesn't recall but it fairly certain the box was between $20-30 before inflation hit. However she said they had chicken legs that were .49/lb which is a great price but hard to reconcile with the narrative that avian flu is the ca…

Longer business cycles? Broilers would be last years layers

Only if you live on a farm! Broilers are purpose-bred on a ridiculously fast timeline.

Re: Eggs are 60% more expensive than last year in the US

#96

I talked to a farmer yesterday who said (at least in the US) it is bird flu. For some reason, the layers seem to have been hit harder than the boilers.

When bird flu shows up in an area, the only way to stop it is to cull the entire flock. Broiler chickens go from hatch -> slaughter in as little as 8 or 9 weeks. Hens need closer to 5 months before they start laying eggs. It just takes longer for the stores of hens to be replenished.

Re: Eggs are 60% more expensive than last year in the US

#97
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Actually there’s more. On Jan 1st several more states laws about animal welfare went into effect whereas before essentially only California had those requirements. The supply of eggs meeting those requirements had not been ramped up to meet the step in demand. I expect that disruption will be temporary.

So why then are my Pasture Raised Organic eggs increasing at the same rate as budget eggs. These regulations would not impact those operations

Because the company you are buying from what doing the minimum to achieve the "Pasture Raised Organic" label, which is not a very high bar. These laws impact them just as much as the "budget eggs".

To be a "free-range" or "pasture-raised" chicken you simply need access to the outdoors. So, these animals are kept in the same cramped, feces-filled hothouses that the "budget chickens" are, but there's a tiny hole in the side of the barn where they can access a tiny bit of grass. That's it.

There is no incentive for these companies to do anything above the bare minimum; you will never find a large-scale egg supplier that raises chickens in the idyllic environment you may picture in your head.

Re: Eggs are 60% more expensive than last year in the US

#98
post #36

My wife has a cottage baking business and would buy 15 dozen eggs from Costco Business Center. Already high, a few months back in cost about $45 for the box. Just last week it was $110. She doesn't recall but it fairly certain the box was between $20-30 before inflation hit. However she said they had chicken legs that were .49/lb which is a great price but hard to reconcile with the narrative that avian flu is the ca…

I do a good deal of baking, and I buy a lot of my supplies from Costco. I also have spent a fair amount of time very diligently tracking my family's grocery expenses. (I have a spreadsheet of almost 3 years of just about all groceries we bought.)

In 2019, I picked up 15 dozen eggs for $8.69, and the 5 dozen was $8.99 at that time. (There were times when they didn't stock the 15 dozen, so I had to opt for 5 -- a much more expensive $1.80/dozen but still reasonable.)

Re: Eggs are 60% more expensive than last year in the US

#99
post #53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Broilers take a fraction of the time to grow compared to the five months it takes before a hen lays the first egg.

12 weeks for most chickens we eat. It’s honestly crazy lol

8 weeks max, probably more like 6. disclosure - I raise meat chickens at a small scale

Re: Eggs are 60% more expensive than last year in the US

#100

Apparently the reason the price of eggs is so high is because A LOT of chickens had to be destroyed this year due to avian flu. We're talking millions of birds. Fewer chickens, less eggs, higher prices.

And laying hens are bred for that specific purpose; all chickens are not the same.
Post reply on HN