Live data from Hacker News

‘That girl is going to get herself killed’ (2022)

longreads.com

11–20 of 474 posts

Re: ‘That girl is going to get herself killed’ (2022)

#11
post #2

Ah, humans. Even when there are no cultural / group loyalty / greed / etc. reasons for a person to behave very differently from how they clearly know they should...they still tend to behave very differently from how they clearly know they should.

According to Jonathan Haidt in the righteous mind, western cultures value autonomy, so the behavior is well explained by this.

Re: ‘That girl is going to get herself killed’ (2022)

#12
post #4

Do your research before getting into rivers. My local river has several gauges and hotlines you can call to get dam releases. They also have a chart of the water release amounts and if you could paddle/float/canoe/kayak etc. It even has a turbidity gauge that will show you if any harmful bacteria is present, we have issues with fertilizer runoff and e-coli. It's a rather mundane river in an area not as known as Glaci…

Acquaintance did some suburban kayaking and didn't see a 3ft drop (some kind of dam or culvert under a bridge) until too late. The fluid mechanics of that drop are such that there is a vortex at the base that makes it difficult to get out. He was able to stand but just barely - scary to think how close a call that was in a pretty innocuous looking setting.

That's called hydrolic lock. It kills experienced people all the time. Weir style dams are so subtle and dangerous.

Re: ‘That girl is going to get herself killed’ (2022)

#13
post #4

Do your research before getting into rivers. My local river has several gauges and hotlines you can call to get dam releases. They also have a chart of the water release amounts and if you could paddle/float/canoe/kayak etc. It even has a turbidity gauge that will show you if any harmful bacteria is present, we have issues with fertilizer runoff and e-coli. It's a rather mundane river in an area not as known as Glaci…

I’ve done a decent amount of white water and stories like this make me shiver. If you’re in moving water, standing is surprisingly dangerous. Float or swim (depending on the current) to calm water and get out there.

If you stand (and especially walk) in a fast current, you’re asking to get your foot caught and then drowned.

Re: ‘That girl is going to get herself killed’ (2022)

#14
post #4

Do your research before getting into rivers. My local river has several gauges and hotlines you can call to get dam releases. They also have a chart of the water release amounts and if you could paddle/float/canoe/kayak etc. It even has a turbidity gauge that will show you if any harmful bacteria is present, we have issues with fertilizer runoff and e-coli. It's a rather mundane river in an area not as known as Glaci…

Acquaintance did some suburban kayaking and didn't see a 3ft drop (some kind of dam or culvert under a bridge) until too late. The fluid mechanics of that drop are such that there is a vortex at the base that makes it difficult to get out. He was able to stand but just barely - scary to think how close a call that was in a pretty innocuous looking setting.

I almost drowned on a beach without surveillance, jumping into the surf waist high, for fun, until suddenly the receding water pulled me just a few meters further away and now I couldn't touch the floor anymore, and was slowly being pulled further and further away from the beach. My girlfriend of the time was on the beach far enough away that she couldn't hear or grasp that I was struggling. By luck and after perhaps 10 minutes of fighting, I managed to move sideways and forward by persistence until I could touch the ground again and walk out. I was completely exhausted and I'm not sure how much longer I could have persisted like this. Just as I exited a few locals were arriving in haste for me. Apparently they had seen me struggling to come back. I'm guessing they had witnessed tragedies there before, because whereas my girlfriend hadn't picked up that I was in trouble, they had.

Re: ‘That girl is going to get herself killed’ (2022)

#17
post #5

Because of modern civilization we have a rose-tinted view of nature and take it for granted. Raw nature is scary and easily able to kill you.

...and the more we try to legislate away any possible source of danger we might encounter in our day-to-day lives, the less prepared we will be for places where nature is left to fend for itself.

I don't think it's a problem of legislation as much as forgetting to repeat the message that danger is everywhere.

A car can easily crush you, electricity can stop your heart. Don't be paralyzed in fear, but still think a bit of the worst plausible case.

Re: ‘That girl is going to get herself killed’ (2022)

#18
It doesn't take much. I live near the Potomac, just upstream of Great Falls and DC. People drown on the flat stretches every summer. Usually a family picnic, somebody goes for a quick dip, and never returns. It looks calm. It isn't.

And just downstream, world class kayakers paddle Great Falls for fun and practice.

It's wild (and sad) to think about the two groups of river users.

Re: ‘That girl is going to get herself killed’ (2022)

#19
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

...and the more we try to legislate away any possible source of danger we might encounter in our day-to-day lives, the less prepared we will be for places where nature is left to fend for itself.

That doesn't make a lot of sense to me as an argument. "We need to keep life more dangerous in general so that when we hit special cases it'll be easier to deal with" strikes me as generally doing more harm than good because our day to day is going to cause more harm and those special cases are always going to be special. Unless you have specific examples that you're thinking of here.

Hypothetically I'd rather my kid learn her limits by breaking her arm in the playground at age 10, than doing so in the wilderness at age 20.

Re: ‘That girl is going to get herself killed’ (2022)

#20
post #4

Do your research before getting into rivers. My local river has several gauges and hotlines you can call to get dam releases. They also have a chart of the water release amounts and if you could paddle/float/canoe/kayak etc. It even has a turbidity gauge that will show you if any harmful bacteria is present, we have issues with fertilizer runoff and e-coli. It's a rather mundane river in an area not as known as Glaci…

Acquaintance did some suburban kayaking and didn't see a 3ft drop (some kind of dam or culvert under a bridge) until too late. The fluid mechanics of that drop are such that there is a vortex at the base that makes it difficult to get out. He was able to stand but just barely - scary to think how close a call that was in a pretty innocuous looking setting.

Yep, we call those low head dams around here. It's like the roll under a big surf wave, but perpetual.
Post reply on HN