Live data from Hacker News

Google demotes Chrome in search results over pay-for-post promo

news.cnet.com

11–20 of 39 posts

Re: Google demotes Chrome in search results over pay-for-post promo

#11
Regardless of the rationale, Google's willingness to manually manipulate page rank for the sake of PR doesn't make a positive impression on me. There was the appearance that Google was gaming SE results, publicly doing so does not seem like a very convincing argument that Google is above such practices.

In other words, I am not inclined to bestow accolades upon them for making real the concerns which were raised.

Re: Google demotes Chrome in search results over pay-for-post promo

#12
What I see when searching for "Google Chrome" is support.google.com/chrome, with sub-links underneath and the top-left sublink going directly to google.com/chrome. I think the system has been worked a little bit, but it's still interesting that they made this move. It may be enough to make it hard for people who have to search to find the download to get to it.

Re: Google demotes Chrome in search results over pay-for-post promo

#13
post #6

Wowzas. That's a pretty big move for Google to make. Google.com/chrome isn't even the top result for the query "Google Chrome" or "Chrome" https://www.google.com/search?ix=heb&sourceid=chrome&#38... https://www.google.com/search?ix=heb&sourceid=chrome&#38... Good on you, Google.

It isn't? The first thing I see when I search for "google chrome" is Google Chrome Download | google.com www.google.com/chrome

That's a paid ad. You can tell from the yellow background and from the text that says "Ad" in the upper-right.

Re: Google demotes Chrome in search results over pay-for-post promo

#15
post #13
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It isn't? The first thing I see when I search for "google chrome" is Google Chrome Download | google.com www.google.com/chrome

That's a paid ad. You can tell from the yellow background and from the text that says "Ad" in the upper-right.

I'm aware of that. My point was that not much has actually changed in practical terms. Yes, there is a little "Ad" text and slightly different background, but both before and after, the first thing people see when they search for "google chrome" is the Chrome download page.

Re: Google demotes Chrome in search results over pay-for-post promo

#16
"During the 60 days, the PageRank of www.google.com/chrome will also be lowered to reflect the fact that we also won’t trust outgoing links from that page."

That was the strangest part, for me. Google clearly can trust outgoing links from www.google.com/chrome.

Its clear they had no intention of gaming their own system with this campaign. But they obviously feel the need to act in a 'beyond reproach' way, to avoid the accusation of conflicts-of-interest.

In one way its good that they are being held to high standards; on the other hand, this is resulting in less relevant search responses, for no real benefit to anyone (including those whom antitrust law, which they might be thinking about, is there to protect).

Hard to say what what the right thing to do is. Sometimes, it looks like its a tough job to maintain the 'dont be evil' image.

Re: Google demotes Chrome in search results over pay-for-post promo

#17
post #14

I'm torn between "That's almost cute " and "This is wrist-slapping ourselves to give the appearance that we administer our guidelines in a manner which is not arbitrary and capricious."

I imagine the FTC and FCC are an incentive to do something to ameliorate the situation.

Re: Google demotes Chrome in search results over pay-for-post promo

#18
post #14

I'm torn between "That's almost cute " and "This is wrist-slapping ourselves to give the appearance that we administer our guidelines in a manner which is not arbitrary and capricious."

I'm sure trying to decide which snarky remark best conveys your condescending attitude towards a company's attempt to maintain its integrity and good standing is such a terrible dilemma.
Post reply on HN