Live data from Hacker News

Scientists dug up Gregor Mendel and analyzed his DNA

npr.org

31–35 of 35 posts

Re: Scientists dug up Gregor Mendel and analyzed his DNA

#31
post #20
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> We sequenced Mendel's DNA!" what was the actual point? The article addresses that. Indeed, before I read the article, I too was tempted to write an angry dismissal. However, their approach and reasoning were very respectful. It was less about curiosity than honoring the fellow for his contribution to human knowledge. If they managed to enlist the support of the Augustinians themselves, I'm certain that we can entir…

Jeez you got really hung up over someone having the audacity to hit the comments with a reply before reading.

I assumed mattlondon did read the article.

Re: Scientists dug up Gregor Mendel and analyzed his DNA

#32
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> We sequenced Mendel's DNA!" what was the actual point? The article addresses that. Indeed, before I read the article, I too was tempted to write an angry dismissal. However, their approach and reasoning were very respectful. It was less about curiosity than honoring the fellow for his contribution to human knowledge. If they managed to enlist the support of the Augustinians themselves, I'm certain that we can entir…

I don't think exhuming someone's dead body after several hundred years is really "honoring" them. I just don't see what the objective here was (regardless of approvals) apart from "wouldn't it be cool if..." type attitude. What does the world gain here apart from a bit better understanding that a historical figure was genetically predisposed to diabetes etc (which FWIU has no really relevance to his research) I just…

[deleted]

Re: Scientists dug up Gregor Mendel and analyzed his DNA

#33

Just want to say, I wish every site had a text.foo.com version like this that was accessible/readable and ad-free. What a pleasure.

68k.news is also really nice in this regard, and allows you to look at a variety of sources covering the same topic.

Re: Scientists dug up Gregor Mendel and analyzed his DNA

#35
post #4

This was actually pretty amazing, as is the quote from the scientist at the university in Brno: "We believe that he would be happy. We know he was very enthusiastic for all kinds of research," she says – noting that just before he died, Mendel requested that an extensive autopsy be done. "He wasn't against research on his own body," she says.

What about this, would you say, is "science"?
Post reply on HN